Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OSHA and bench grinders...

Posts

OSHA and bench grinders...

#1

OSHA and bench grinders...

John in NM

So our safety guy at work insists that the tool rests be installed on the bench grinder, saying that it is an OSHA guideline - which is correct. Not being one to follow rules for their own sake, I can't for the life of me figure out why this is a "safety" concern. In some cases tool rests are needed for proper use, in some cases they are not - i grind knives freehand for example.

Does anyone know the actual logic, if any, behind this rule? Or should I just resign myself to another bit of institutional irrationality? :D

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#2

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I can picture someone who doesn't know how to hold a tool to the grinder getting the grinding equivalent of a woodturning catch, and having the tool pulled out of his/her hands or something similar.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#3

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

John Lucas

Ditto what Bill said. If you get the tool below the center line or you are feeding it into the wheel so the leverage pushes it down and deeper into the wheel you get a nasty catch. I could easily see a beginner doing this. I did it one day when cleaning the wheel. I sharpen woodturning tools free hand and sometimes will hold the diamond dresser gently against the wheel to clean it and true the surface up. I've done this hundreds of times. One day I did something different. Don't know exactly what but it grabbed the Dresser and pulling down into the wheel covers. Bent them and the dresser but no damage to me. If I had used the tool rest it never would have happened. I can't use the tool rest to sharpen the tools so I have to remove it for those operations.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#4

Interesting...

John in NM

I've never tried that, grinding below the center. In theory, that would just change the angle of cut, more surface area causing more drag. I still find the concept of an abrasive wheel catching a bit hard to imagine, but that doesn't make it impossible. First shop I worked in they would run wire wheels on a bench grinder, which I found absolutely terrifying, as we were cleaning up irregular parts and they would catch and get thrown across the room - horrible. I smoked back then and would go out for a smoke whenever someone turned that grinder on :D

This safety guy is a bit of a pet peeve of mine, as he misses obvious (to me) stuff, then comes back with the grinder business, or tells us we can't grind aluminum (correct) - when the loading on the wheel is mild steel :(. I've gotten in the habit now of dressing the wheels before he shows up :D :D :D

On the whole though, I think I'm coming around - we do have one guy who uses the shop who could probably hurt himself with a bench grinder, so its good to know it might be possible. Since the whole tool rest thing came up I've mostly been using an angle grinder for anything free hand anyhow, cleaning burrs off tube steel and stuff.

Thanks for the input guys.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#5

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

Hank Knight

As with many OSHA Standards, it's required because it's in the book - period. In a former life, I was a manufacturing plant manager. We never had an OSHA inspection where we didn't get cited for failure to have a proper tool rest on the bench gtinder in our shop. On one inspection I recall, the office manager called the maintenance shop to give them a heads up that the OSHA guys were on the premises and to put the tool rest on the grinder - which the maintenance guys did, bless their hearts. It was a bright shiny new one because I don't think it had ever been used. The inspectors went through the shop and passed the grinder. On their return to my office after completing the inspection they stopped by the shop to ask my maintenance supervisor a question. You guessed it: the maintenance guys had already removed the tool rest and we got cited - agian. Bless their hearts.

Hank

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#6

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

ash Sioux Falls SD

You wrote: *So our safety guy at work insists that the tool rests be installed on the bench grinder, saying that it is an OSHA guideline - which is correct.*

It's right . . . sort of. I took a safety engineering grad class at SDSU in 1987 taught by an OSHA inspector. I applied for and got an OSHA inspection exemption from OSHA. As I remember, normally, a grinder is required to have a tool rest set less than 1/4" from wheel, a plastic face shield, and a written policy of required safety glasses use. I believe double eye protection is required. There are exceptions and a missing tool rest isn't an automatic fine.

The exceptions are removal by maintenance staff for servicing the machine and using the machine without the tool rest for special uses. The special use exception requires a written policy rule for using the machine without the tool rest as well as documented training and a list of personnel approved to use the machine. If the machine is resting and under power, it needs to comply with published guidelines. If the machine is not complying with published guidelines, all that needs to be done is the power locked out on the machine and an *Out Of Service* tag attached to the machine.

I might have forgotten something. My company had an OSHA exemption on the wall for a number of consecutive years. I had between 25 and 40 employees and I never had another OSHA 200 form injury after I started in the inspection exemption program. It was the single best business decision I ever made. I also took an industrial hygiene grad course at SDSU. That helped to manage the dust issue as well as the spray booth operation.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#7

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

Alexandre Grigoriev

Isn't it a bit like bitching "That damn officer gave me a ticket for running a stop sign. I do it all the time and never had an accident", or like that. It's only because of those rules you (your shop) don't have as much injuries as could be. People make stupid mistakes. They think the rules are stupid. Then they go use a RAS freehand.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#8

More to it than that I think....

John in NM

The tool rest seems to me to be primarily designed as an aid for smooth and efficient edge work, so I was fairly surprised to find it billed as a safety device by an individual who had clearly never gotten dirt under his finger nails. If the device were clearly designed for safety purposes - like the blade guard on a jointer for example, or better yet the required plexiglass spark shields on this same grinder - the question simply never would have come up.

I ask less to debunk the possible safety uses of a tool rest, but more to dip into the wealth of experience to be found here and perhaps learn something that is not obvious to me based on my own experience. The post just above yours, by ash, was particularly interesting to me - not in the least because it points out a couple other ways that we are lacking by OSHA standards, and that our safety guy has not pointed out.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#9

I believe..

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

Part of the safety aspect is to assist in contain stone fragments should the wheel explode. I also believe that you are required to have a "tounge" guard where the stone enters to top of the "wheel" cover for the same reason, to help contain explodeing wheel fragments. As much as I hate how this may sound and given that OSHA inspectors often don't seem to come from the real world, I'm pretty sure that virtually every OSHA requirement is based on someone getting injured or killed. One the safety slogans I like is "Don't become a warning label" I worked with a guy who did. luckily he wasn't killed, he only got a fractured skull.

glc

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#10

OSHA's dilemma

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's impossible to idiot proof anything; idiots will think of ways to bung things up that no reasonable person would ever imagine.

Yet, OSHA is legally charged to keep people from getting hurt, even if they're idiots.

I don't envy OSHA folks - most of them I've talked to really mean well, but they're about as well liked as IRS agents.

Re: OSHA and bench grinders...

#11

Every time

Dan Donaldson

every time someone invents something to make something idiot proof, the universe comes up with a better idiot. ;)

Call it the "ID 10 T" syndrome (pronounced "eye dee ten tee"