Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Questions on Cordless drills?

Posts

Questions on Cordless drills?

#1

Questions on Cordless drills?

Barry Irby

I have two Makita 12 volt drills. (Batteries died, so I bought a second setup, so two drills, two chargers and four batteries. Since then the battereis have been rebuilt by Primecell)

I took a drill and charger out to a jobsite. It seems the drill on the site has very little power. I can easily hold the chuck and stop it wih my hand. I assumed the batteries had died again and that maybe the drill was getting low voltage inspete of the batteries being vreshly charged. Broaught the batteries home and checked them. About 12 1/2 volts. Tried them in the drill in the shop. Much better power. Difficlut to stop the chuck.

The batteries were rebuilt in 2006 so they coudl be crapping out again.

The question is, what can be causing the "job" drill to be weak if the battery has a decent charge? Could it be in the connections to the battery?

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#2

Dunno, but I'm brainstorming...

Grant in Iowa

Wiring, speed control, brushes, motor...

If both drills ar ethe same model, you might be able to troubleshoot by swapping parts between the two.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#3

Temperature?

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

Several years ago there was an article in Fine Home Building about a builder who used a lot of cordless tools in cold conditions (Alaska in the winter I believe) and the rituals he went through to keep his tools operational. I sure that this was much older tech than Barry is using but... Temprature can affect batteries. I use cordless tools in cold weather all the time, but the tools go from a warm shop to a warmish truck to a few minute job, to inside my coat or back in the truck if it is really cold. The tools don't stay out in the cold long enough to get very cold. They guy in Alaska, had an insulated box / ice chest with jugs of hot water in it that he kept his tools and batteries in.

Probably not too cold but it is an avenue to explore

glc

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#4

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

AZ, Colorado Springs

Maybe the power sources are not equivalent. Don't know what your job site is like, but if there are long extension cords involved, perhaps voltage drop is leading to a weaker charge on those batteries.

Otherwise, maybe one of the drills is defective, as alluded to in another post, so the comparisons are unequal in that regard.

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#5

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

Barry Irby

The job site is unheated, but lately the inside temp has been shirt sleeves comfortable. Probably above 55 F.

The batteries are NiMH I think. Whatever the upgrade was from Prime cell.

The drills are very similar, but bought about four years apart. Both Makita and both 12 volt.

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#6

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

Neal in San Jose

Voltage of the the battery out of the drill is essentially meaningless. It the voltage under load that we are concerned with. I don't know how you can measure the voltage under load; I know on my Makitas it would be a real trick Competent car mechanics have a gizmo to test car batteries under load, and I'd guess that cordless tool battery rebuilders have a similar device.

Lacking that info, all you can really do is try different combinations and attempt to find battery/drill combos that work and those that don't, and from that deduce which batteries or drills are dying.

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#7

I'm sure you've checked, but

Bruce, a MN Galoot

do you have the drill set on the slow speed setting rather than fast? I have a Makita 12 NiMH drill and I can't stop the chuck on the slow setting, but can easily do it on high.

Re: Questions on Cordless drills?

#8

Re: I'm sure you've checked, but

Barry Irby

Yup, tried it both ways. Definitely a difference between the two drill. I will bring the whole setup home and try them side by side.

Still need to find a way to actually test the batteries.