Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

Posts

Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#1

JL

Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

JL

The LOML wants some raised beds. She doesn't want me to use pressure treated timber (even though I promised to put a liner near the wood). I'm thinking about using cedar as I can get 1 x 8 x 8' boards for about $9 or so. I was planning on using the Lee Valley raised bed hardware http://www.leevalley.com/garden/page.aspx?c=2&p=10351&cat=2

Any other thoughts as to wood or hardware?

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#2

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

FredD

I would use 2x rather then 1x, it seem a little thin to me.

FredD

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#3

Re: Raised bed sides

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

1x is going to spread on you in those lengths. You will have to stake at 2-1/2' from each corner. Cedar is great stuff for bugs, but it absorbs water like a sponge and then rots. You'll be replacing those boards often. Cedar 'round here doesn't do well on ground contact.

We built raised beds for a guy in our group from CCA. After the hoopla over arsenate, he's had the soil in the beds tested every year. Been 10 years and not a trace of chemicals, other than his fertilizer, in the dirt. Can't speak for the ACQ stuff.

If treated is out on general [SWMBO] principals, I'd use 2x spruce. Cheap and replaceable. Miter the corners and use a couple of 4" angle irons and screws.

You want real durability? Black Locust.

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#4

Re: Raised bed sides

Barry Irby

Mark is right. Black locust or osage orange. Or you might try some of the new stuff that has been heat treated. Not sure it is rated for ground contact, but you could do the test and let the rest of us know.

You could use Trex or similar material, but it would sag or bulge badly unless you stack it frequently.

How about stone?

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#5

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

Howard Norman

I have a raised bed 4x8' made from 1x rough sawn cedar using the LV hardware. On the 4' side I can not detect any movement. On the 8' side I drove a stake into the ground and fastened the cedar to that. The sides are lined with black poly. Here in the mountains of AZ I have had no problem with it at all. It has been out there for about 5 or 6 years I would guess. During the winters here it gets completely covered with snow for a week at a time.

BTW, I think that the LV hardware is the way to go. I have enough hardware for another raised bed and as soon as I can find some more cedar of that thinkness I will build another one.

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#6

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

FredD

I rememberd what I didn't mention on the first post, the nicest looking and strongest raised beds I have seen were done by my Electrician for his Wife who planed Herbs, flowers ,Tomato's and Onions.

He went to Lowes and got load of treated fence posts which were flat on two sides , made the beds about eight feet square, four layers high and left a path between each , very nice looking and in his front yard in the country at that.

I believe there was a sale on the posts at the time and he took advantage of it.

FredD

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

#7

Re: Raised bed sides (and Lee Valley hardware)?

David Hay Denver

Nothing against Lee Valley...I love the the company and their products...but I guess I'm somewhat cheap when it comes to garden projects. Why not get some 2x material and just screw the corners together? A couple of 1x2 stakes pounded into the ground on the interior of the box and screwed to the box will keep it from moving and bowing along the long sides. If you need to make them taller, stack the boxes and use some 1x or 2x material in the corners, and perhaps in the middle of the long sides to hold the two pieces together.

David