Florida traffic light question
Bill Tindall
What is the purpose of the blue lights that sprout from short poles atop traffic lights in Fl cities? They seem to turn off and on depending on whether the light is red.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Florida traffic light question
Bill Tindall
What is the purpose of the blue lights that sprout from short poles atop traffic lights in Fl cities? They seem to turn off and on depending on whether the light is red.
Re: Florida traffic light question
Scott Crumpton
We have white ones in Gainesville and I believe that they're there so that the traffic cop who may not have direct view of the red light can still know exactly when it turns red in order to issue a ticket for running the light.
Re: Florida traffic light question
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
We have the blue ones here in St. Cloud and Scott is Right. Many places in an around Orlando have also installed Red Lights camers and take your picture as you run a red light. You then get a citation in the mail. Sure nab a lot of tourists that way. Keeps our taxes low.
Re: Florida traffic light question
Brian in Brighton
The guys are right. You'll notice that the blue lights are on the backside of the lights being monitored by the officer down the street. This way they can chase you to collect more money without risking going thru the light themselves.
My question to the officer would be something like this "After all the training you had to fight crime, how do you feel having your primary job being to collect money?" It's getting much worse here in the Denver area since the tax collections from sales and such are down, the police are expected to collect enough money to pay for themselves. It really is pathetic.
Brian in Brigton
Re: Florida traffic light question
Barry Irby
They get really ticked when they bust a drug deal before the money shows up. Better to bust the money, they get to keep it.
And why blue? I think I know the answer
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
purchased at Kmart during a clearance sale.
Re: Florida traffic light question
GolfSteve in Calgary
Lots of consipiracy theorists here...
I dunno about Florida, but around here the little blue lights are used for two reasons:
1. To give priority to approaching emergency vehicles (ie. to give "all green" lights to emergency vehicles), and
2. To give priority to public transit buses (ie. the light sequence might be held up for a few seconds if a bus is approaching).
Otherwise, the traffic control lights are sequenced so that drivers, driving the speed limit, will hit all green lights. The lights are timed for something like 46 km/h when the speed limit is 50 km/h to account for acceleration from the lights. If you are speeding or dawdling you will tend to hit more red lights than if you're doing the speed limit. The timing is also adjusted based on the magenetic pickups under the intersections...more traffic===more green light time.
Cheers,
Steven, who has friends in the transportation engineering department of my city who can actually answer my traffic related questions.
Re: Florida traffic light question
Kirk (KC) Constable
If you really asked an officer that, I'd be disppointed if he/she didn't find something else to cite you for in addition to running a light. They're doing their job, which includes traffic control/enforcement. People need to stop running red lights.
not so in Orlando, FL
Bill Tindall
Some fire trucks came through an intersection with these blue lights and they did not do anything beyond what they were doing, namely turning when the light turned. The intersection lights did not alter for the fire trucks. The trucks paused and went through on red.
Are right turns on red legal in Fl?
A. Kapocius
Re: Are right turns on red legal in Fl?
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
Unless otherwise posted it is legal,AFTER COMING TO A COMPLETE STOP, and as long as there are no pedestrians at the intersection. It is not legal in most school zones.
Thanks.
A. Kapocius
Re: not so in Orlando, FL
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
In some if not most areas there is a sending device in emergency vehicles that allows the driver to switch or keep the light green in the direction the vehicle is heading.
Maybe time to quit complaining about cops
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
If you ask me the odds of getting killed by a thief or drug dealer as opposed to getting killed by a speeder or red-light-runner, I think the traffic offenses are the far more likely source of my demise. Thus, I have little agreement with folks who think the cops have better things to do than enforce traffic laws. If they're there to keep me safe, their time is best spent doing just that. Yes, there are some petty traffic offenses, but running red lights is not one of them.
Re: Florida traffic light question
John Parker
Here would be my sons reply. (He is a state trooper) My job is to enforce the laws of my state and follow the commands of my superiors. Traffic enforcement is the primary job of our states state police. If you do not like the laws vote for change.
Emergency traffic light control
Scott Crumpton
Traffic light cycle preemption by emergency vehicles is done optically. That strobing white light on the front of most firetrucks, ambulances, and police cars isn't there just to get your attention. At appropriately equipped intersections you'll find a small box with a short tube aimed at oncoming traffic. This device is called an "opticon" (it probably goes by other names as well). It's purpose is to see the white strobing of an emergency vehicle and initiate a cycle change to green for the emergency vehicle and red for all other directions.
As a side note, in the early days the flashing was at a fixed rate and some people figured out how to game the system. Most systems now use a coded signal that's changed periodically. That's why the strobes now appear to flash "randomly". I should also probably warn not to try gaming the new systems as many of them log activity and if unauthorized use is detected you'll find a cop in waiting.
Re: Florida traffic light question
Brian in Brighton
NOt even close to that in Denver. They have the lights timed on major roads so that the traffic can get thru 5-6 lights without stopping. Driving the speed limit exactly will get you thru 4-5 lights. It is not intended to hit all green, otherwise you would also hit all red unless you really romp on it.
Brian in Brighton
Re: Maybe time to quit complaining about cops
Brian in Brighton
I agree, but using an officer to give out tickets can be abused. In Denver we have a major highway that runs thru town, several times a month the police sit on a chair on the pedestrian overpass and call ahead to the 7-10 waiting patrol cars. They do this for hours at a time, one ticket after another regardless of traffic conditions or flow. Stop the guy who is truly speeding, but if traffic is flowing 10 over and they decide to stop everyone they can possibly stop, it's purely for revenue.
Red light and speed cameras are the same thing. Purely revenue. They do little to stop traffic since there is no penalty on your license. If you have the means to pay, you can rack up as many camera tickets as you want and the police can do nothing to the person who pays the cash.
Re: And yet U-turns at a light are not in Mo.
Brian in Brighton
We were in Missouri years ago and I made a U-Turn at a light when it went green. An officer pulled me over, saw my Colorado plates and informed me that it is illegal to make a U-Turn at any traffic light in Missouri but did not give me a ticket. Here in Co, it has to be posted to be illegal. Otherwise it's OK to make a U on a green.
Brian in Brighton
If the speed limit is reasonable
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
then stopping everyone 10 and over makes sense. It seems to me that, if people presume the speed limit signs aren't meaningful, and that this presumption is reinforced by no one getting tickets for "mild" excess speed, then they're not meaningful; and then serious speeders figure they're entitled to what they can get away with.
It's kind of like that theory of community policing that, if you ignore the graffitti and broken windows, you're establishing an environment in which people of good will don't stay or aren't motivated; and Gresham's Law takes over.
Re: If the speed limit is reasonable
John K Jordan
>...if people presume the speed limit signs aren't meaningful, ...
I agree. Some sections of interstate through Knoxville here seem rarely patrolled and the traffic speed has inched up until nearly everyone is traveling 15-20 mph over the limit, some much faster. Other areas are patrolled and almost everyone drives close to the posted limit. I don't know of any places here with the reputation for being "speed traps".
JKJ
Re: Emergency traffic light control
Dean J in MN
Opticons are infrared, the visual strobes aren't tripping the lights as far as I'm aware.
Re: It all depends on conditions
Brian in Brighton
If the weather is mild and clear and the traffic is very light then going 65mph on an interstate should not be a problem. Using the logic that the speed limit should always be obeyed does not allow for conditions. In the snow, one would not go the speed limit, but the police could give a ticket for driving too fast for conditions. The safest speed is the same speed as traffic flow, regardless if it's 10 over, or 20 under.
Brian in Brighton
So if the Lambhorgini Countach Club comes to town
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
and they're all going 150 mph on the highway, that's the safest speed?
Re: Yup.
Brian in Brighton
No, seriously, the safest speed is keeping up with the flow of traffic. If traffic on I-4 is going 70 and you try to merge at 40 you could cause an accident, and YOU should be held at fault for it. Keeping with the flow is paramount to safety. If you feel that the flow is going too fast, or the road too rough, for you to be safe than you should exit the highway and find another route.
Using your logic, the safest speed is 0.00mph.
Brian in Brighton, happily traveling 80mph in Colorado everyday. :-)