Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Oscillating Edge Sanders

Posts

Oscillating Edge Sanders

#1

Oscillating Edge Sanders

Steve in Phoenix

Just moved, and wouldn't you know it, this house needs new cabinets in both bathrooms, my office, the garage, and so on. This calls for a new tool. I feel I have paid my dues with the hand-electric sanders and should move up to something bigger. Something that will hopefully save me some time. Especially on all of those edges (which I have done by hand with a piece of sandpaper, and sometimes a jack plane). Maybe on smoothing out panel faces too?

As a Grizzly junkie, I have my eyes on their 2 and 3 hp models. I admit that the 3hp may be overkill, but for just another $200, I wonder if it's worth the bigger footprint?

Any comments regarding the usefulness, and safety issues regarding a big edge sander like this? From what I have read, there are a few of you who may have sanded off some bone in your time.

I assume the shop protocol on that one is to wrap it promptly in a blue shop towel, and get your butt back to work...

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#2

JL

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

JL

I have used an older 3 hp Powermatic oscillating edge sander over at JCC Folkschool. They are quite nice to use. I can only say - I wish I had the space (and the budget).

However, if I had to choose between an oscillating edge sander and a drum sander, I think I would choose a drum sander.

But, to get back to your question - it is just a sander. You'd probably be happy with the 2 hp unit. A 3 hp unit really takes off material quite quickly - maybe a bit too quickly (DAMHIKT).

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#3

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders *LINK*

Dave Paine

At a Woodwork show in Reading, PA last weekend, I watched a demo of a machine called "Flat Master". This machine did a great job of sanding panels flat, and if used with 90 deg fence, it would also sand edges.

I decided to take the plunge. I ordered a 30in unit and it arrived on Friday. I spent most of Saturday getting this ready. The motor needs to be purchased separately.

I ordered the fence and hold down package. May not be a good idea. The fences are not 90 deg. Will work with the hold-downs, but not as support for edge sanding.

I still feel this unit with good 90 deg fences will perform better than an oscillating belt sander. I have one, a small Ridgid unit, which I use often, perhaps less often now that I have this Flat Master.

Today did some test sanding. I think once I build some true 90 deg fences, this will be a better machine for edge sanding that the Ridgid osillating belt unit. I do not like the thump of the belt joint.

The Flat Master has no joints on the drum.

Although this is not oscillating, I am pleased with the surface from my 100 grit test. I expect if I used the 220 or 320 paper, I would not have any issues with "lines" as I see with my normal drum sander.

This is a different sanding concept. The paper is not pressed into the wood. The pressure is from centripetal force. Also means little or no heat build-up, which is a big problem when I use the Ridgid machine.


http://www.stockroomsupply.com

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#4

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

Steve in Phoenix

I hadn't considered a drum sander...

I find edges to be more of a chore than faces. Do you hand sand yours, or rig a hand electric to do the job?

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#5

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

Steve in Phoenix

Like this?

http://grizzly.com/products/18-1-1-2-HP-Single-Phase-Open-End-Drum-Sander/G0458

I find edges to be more of a chore than faces. What do you do with your edges?

Thanks

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#6

JL

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders *LINK*

JL

I usually use a plane for the flat sides. I find that I can get a reasonably smooth flat with a plane. I then finish up with a 5" ROS or hand sanding if needed.

The Grizzly G0458 would be a reasonable compromise for a drum sander. I really fell in love with the Jet 22/44 Oscillating drum sander at a show a couple of years back. I couldn't justify the purchase though, I don't do enough doors.

I don't really have a problem with edges - probably because I usually end up beveling and shaping the edges on most of my work. I rough them out with machines and fine tune them by hand.


Jet Drum Sanders

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#7

Very Useful Tools

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I bought a Powermatic Osc. edge sander a little over a year ago and I have been amazed how much I use it. Many uses. And for cabinets, I could see a real value...great for truing doors etc. If you have the space it's a great tool to have. Tom

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#8

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

Steve in Phoenix

That little drum sander might be a great idea. The oscillating edge sander is really expensive.

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#9

Re: Very Useful Tools

Steve in Phoenix

At this point I have no floor-sanders, and I'm starting to wonder if a drum sander might be put to more use. Or use the edge sander in the horizontal orientation to smooth glued-up cabinet panels too?

Do you do more than edges with yours? Is the oscillating feature a luxury or necessity? Am I asking too many questions?

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#10

Re: Very Useful Tools

Kevin H.

I didn't get the edge sander concept until I worked in a shop with one. They are a great machine that I would choose over the belt/disk combo in a heartbeat. Oscillation quickly pays for itself with time savings and belt replacement savings in a commercial enviroment.

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#11

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders *LINK*

charlie belden

While you're at it, how about a nice stroke sander - with power table lifter?

Not sure about the need for oscillating. Michael Colca made a nice wide belt edge sander

- WITH changeable end diameters. You will need to turn a drum for the motor end.

Attached link - if you scroll down a bit shows his stroke sander and DIY edge sander.

Michael does mainly cherry furniture and has a need for both sanders.


Stroke Sander & DIY Edge Sander

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#12

Re: Very Useful Tools

Steve in Phoenix

If it has to be one or the other, would you choose a drum sander or edge sander?

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#13

Re: Very Useful Tools

Kevin H.

If funds and space were available, I would buy an oscillating edge sander first. Some drum sander functions can be performed on the end of it.

A drum sander has the benefit of changing drum sizes, amoung other things, but does not excel at sanding straight edges.

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#14

I Agree

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have a large dual drum sander. It's nice for surfacing difficult grained wood but I don' use it often. I use the edge sander weekly. It's much more versitile and addresses more needs than the drum sander.

Tom

Re: Oscillating Edge Sanders

#15

Re: I Agree

Steve in Phoenix

Thanks for all the help guys.

It will be the Grizzly G0564

http://grizzly.com/products/Oscillating-Edge-Sander-3-HP/G0564

Seeing as I've moved, that means starting over with the garage. On the upside, there is a window to put the air conditioner this time (as opposed to chiseling through 8" CMU). The walls are also insulated, drywalled, and painted white. I have just had an insulated garage door installed, and the subpanel will be installed thursday. Then it's off the the races. Lights, 120's, 240's, pegboard, etc.

The wife is most pleased to hear that I will be taking care of the cabinetry for the house. I just want the tools...