Table Saw Safety
Bob S
Hi, Is it ever okay to crosscut against the fence? I always thought this was a no-no under all instances. What about plywood, can that get cut any way desired since there is no true grain direction?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Table Saw Safety
Bob S
Hi, Is it ever okay to crosscut against the fence? I always thought this was a no-no under all instances. What about plywood, can that get cut any way desired since there is no true grain direction?
I don't recommend it
Ellis Walentine
I'm glad you asked this, Bob, before running your own experiment. You're likely to get several good answers that can save you a world of trouble. My answer is that I only use the fence for crosscutting if it is safe to do so, and that isn't very often.
Here's a bit more of an explanation: Regardless of what you're cutting against the fence of a tablesaw, you need to make sure the workpiece is long enough to have a completely controllable bearing surface on the fence. This usually means that the piece is longer than it is wide, and it's long enough that you can get a push block or Grrripper on it and keep the edge against the fence with no danger of rocking. I suggest a boot-shaped push block or Gripper because they hold the workpiece down firmly as you push it forward. A reasonable working length might be 12" or 16" (or possibly a little less, if you know what you're doing), so odds are you won't be having too many boards that wide and short to crosscut. One other caveat with crosscutting solid wood is that the piece you're cutting will have short grain, so you need to judge whether it is sound enough to cut without fragmenting and blowing up in the cut. All in all, a potentially dicey operation, which is why I don't recommend it. A Dubby or even a miter gauge is a better bet. If you need to gauge the length of the cutoffs, clamp a reference block to the fence well in advance of the blade, but never trap a piece between fence and blade!
Plywood doesn't have a grain direction for tablesawing purposes (except regarding veneer or surface chipout), but the same rules of thumb apply: make sure you have a long enough edge against the fence and that the piece isn't too wide relative to its length for you to control with full confidence.
If anyone has further recommendations, I'm all ears.
Ellis
Re: I don't recommend it
Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft
I agree with Ellis. What we have here in a long, narrow piece of plywood between the blade and fence is a leverage situation with a major catch. It is the lever that will be thrown since the fence and blade are immovable - for the lever that is.
Re: A spacer jig improves safety
Ralph Lipeles
I made made a jig that sits on the rip fence and slides along it. I can clamp it any place that I want. The side of the jig that faces the blade is exactly 1/2" thick. When I am planning a cut I must account for the 1/2" offset from the fence. By using the jig there is always a 1/2" clearance around the piece just cut off so it it highly unlikely that it will touch the blade and jam.
Re: Table Saw Safety
Bill Howatt
In short the answer is a no. To be honest, I do it but if the stock is wide which means about 8" or more against the fence AND the cut-off piece is only a few inches long. The further the fence is from the blade the more you need against the fence to reduce any tendency to rotate into the blade. I also have a good overarm blade guard but I don't say I'll do it this way just because I have the guard - if it doesn't appear safe without the guard, I won't do it with the guard.
Bill
Cross cut sleds...
JL
and "flip stops" are wonderful things for many repetitive cuts. Another alternative is a miter gauge with a flip stop.
Accuracy is also an issue...
Grant in Iowa
...Especially when making multiples of a given part. If you are cutting up stock, and decide to make some cuts between the fence and the blade, you have few ways to ensure the adjacent edge is a square cut. Indeed, you really don't know that it is, since it wasn't referenced to the adjacent edge. You are really creating a cut parallel to the surface against the fence, and not necessarily square to an adjacent edge. Additive error can easily work into the process to cause an out of square workpiece, particularly in repetative or sequential cuts, such as making a bunch of 6" squares from a single long 6" wide board. Your best bet is to use one of the following methods:
-crosscut sled on the table saw with a stop block if multiple parts will be made
-Miter or radial arm saw (well tuned)...again, a stop block for multiple parts
-miter jig for smaller workpieces on the table saw.
All of these, when tuned well and used properly will ensure that you can get a square cut the first and every time. These methods of cutting are referencing the cut line to an adjacent edge. By subsequently flipping the workpiece smartly, you can limit the effects of additive errors.
All of that said, when ripping long strips or long boards to width, the fence is the go-to tool because you want to first create a parallel edge, then cut to length (as described above or in the previous posts).
Clear as mud?
Grant in Iowa
Re: Table Saw Safety
Bob S
Ellis - Thanks to you and all for the feedback. You have all re-inforced my beliefs. I am in a woodworking class simply to use the tools, (local adult ed. with VERY NICE wood shop). We come across this a lot, and I just wanted to be sure, when I demand that the shop-rookies DO NOT make this cut. At least once a semester (i've been (3) times in 10 years), it seems someone has a board fly off and get lucky not to get hurt. The instructor doesn't emphasize this fact enough in his overview of the tool-useage. Plenty of new students don't even know cross cut from rip!
Simple rule of thumb
Lee Schierer McKean, PA
The piece against the fence should always have more length in contact with the fence than the distance between the blade and the fence and the overall length of the part.
Pieces with less than about 6-8" in contact with the fence should be cut by another method.
One last thought. If that little voice in your head is saying that something feels dangerous, it probably is. Always listen and find another way to make the cut.
Lee
Re: Adder to Lee
Brian in Brighton
I also was taught that the width of the material you're ripping should always be equal to or more than the length. But, it depends on the blade, material, etc.
I had a 24x24x1/2 plywood panel rise up and spin into the fence on me about 10 years ago when I was making a 3/16D x 1/2W dado cut about 1/3 of the way across the panel. So it can be very dangerous without a cross cut sled. I shut off the saw and went inside for the night.
One thing I've learned from many shop managers is that if you have a close call like mine, stop working and take the day off.
Brian in Brighton