Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Filter Sizes

Posts

Filter Sizes

#1

Filter Sizes

Joel

My friend suggested I try this as the store that I'm working with has no clue to the answer that I'm looking for. I'm in the market for a dust collection system. I'm looking at a couple of differnt ones...A General dust Collector, a Jet Powermatic, and a Steel City Dust collector. Does anyone have any information on any of the above mentioned three as to which is a better dust collector. Also with reference to filter size...which is a better filter...one that filters 1 micron or one that filters 30 microns? They can't seem to tell me that at the store. My wife says in medicine...a 30 micron filter is better then a 1 or 2 micron filter...but I don't know if that relates to mechanical filtration.

Thanks for any assistance....Joel

Re: Filter Sizes

#2

Re: Filter Sizes

Barry Irby

Can't answer all your questions, but I believe your wife has the filter thing backwards. I believe the designation referred to the largest particle the filter will allow to pass or the size of the holes in the filter. So, In theory a thirty micron filter will allow particles smaller than thirty microns to pass while the one micron filter only allows ones smaller than one micron to pass.

None of this is exactly true. Part of what makes a filter work is that it cakes up with dust particles and then it filters much smaller particles than the Micron size would indicate. Conversely, as the cake builds up the volume of air the unit is capable of blowing through the filter goes down.

Also, it is the very small particles that are the most dangerous. Larger particles that you can easily see are not very dangerous. Messy, but not dangerous. In order for the dust to injure your lungs you must inhale it. For that reason the large particles don't matter, they settle out of the air too quickly to inhale. (The wood dust might injure you without your inhaling it if you are allergic to it and it gets on your skin or in your eyes.)

One solution is to put the unit outside the shop(out doors) so that any dust it collects is either in the bag or gone into the atmosphere. But so is your heat and AC.

Go to Bill Pentz' site and read more than you ever wanted to know. Billpentz.com, I think.

Re: Filter Sizes

#3

Re: Filter Sizes

Dave Paine

Too many variables. You do not state the difference in the "head" curves, which is the amount of air flow vs static pressure.

As Barry stated, micron size is normally preferred to be smaller. This means smaller dust particles getting through back into the air.

As a normal filter collects dust, its "nominal" particle size will reduce. However this is at the expense of airflow and/or static pressure.

The smaller specification for particle size should infer larger surface area of the filter media.

You also need to consider the published "head" curves. Some are more accurate than others. Big difference in how fast the airflow falls as static pressure drops.

All systems will have static pressure, but to filter media and especially the duct system you install.

So in theory a system which provides a larger airflow at lower static pressure would be preferred. This is theory. In practice, not so simple.

Good luck. I switched from a bag filter machine to a cartridge filter machine. Much easier to clean than the bags. Still a messy operation, but not as messy as bags.

Re: Filter Sizes

#4

Smaller is better, and...

Joe Pack

Smaller numbers equal better filtration of smaller particles. A collection system using a 30 micron filter system is great for keeping most of the mess out of the shop, but useless for protecting your lungs.

Of equal concern is the fact that the people you talked with at the store could not tell you that. I would be VERY cautious about any information I got from a merchant who could not answer that very basic question.

Finally, don't get caught up in the "bigger is better" idea. Sure, a 5hp cyclone with 12' high bags would be great, particularly if you are running a planer, sander, table saw and jointer at the same time, but do you need it? If your shop is like most of ours, you will be using one machine at a time. I really doubt that most of us could tell the difference between the major brands if they were all painted the same color. My advice is to put your money into 1 micron bags or cartidges and not be too concerned about the brand of collector.

My 2 centados, fwiw.