Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

Posts

Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#1

Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

Bill Tindall

The myth goes that applying too much clamp pressure will squeeze out the glue and leave a "starved joint" that will be weak.

Facts: Borden recommends 150 psi clamp pressure and Franklin recommends 100-300 psi for edge gluing. As soon as the glue contacts the wood water is removed from the glue and its viscosity increases dramatically. In principal only three molecular layers of adhesive is sufficient to form the strongest possible bond between two materials. It is simply impossible to squeeze so much high viscosity glue from the joint as to leave behind too little. (This statement presumes adequate glue was applied in the first place. (That would be enough to wet both surfaces )

To validate these claims the joint shown in the picture was prepared and clamped in a full sized machinist vice with as much pressure as I could muster on the 14" handle. I would presume that this amount of jaw pressure on the small joint resulted in substantially more pressure than could be applied with woodworking clamps. After several days to cure to maximum strength the lap joint was whacked with a mallet. There was 100% wood failure /0% glue failure.

Myth Busted!

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#2

Lee Grindinger

Hmmm, a limited anecdotal experiment

Lee Grindinger

You only tested one glue? One species? How about the other glues woodworkers use? Other woods? How many conditions did you use? Temperature, MC, speed, porosity of the wood, etc. I can see many omissions in your process.

So, I 'm skeptical of your conclusions.

Lee

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#3

Re: Hmm, a limited anecdotal experiment

Barry Irby

I have a friend in the cabinet business who orders doors from a company specializing in doors. They will make about any door style and any species he is interested in, in about any size.

Obviously they have sophisticated machines to cut the joints and they use carbide made of diamond dust. (Something like sintered diamond carbide???) The company would glue the joints and pull the mortise and tenon joints up in a clamping table and put a single small pin or staple to hold the joint until the glue set. He ordered numerous doors, but then a few of them fell apart. He returned them and the company claimed the glue joints were cut so accurately that there was no room for glue and the joints were starved. They claimed they had the cutters remilled to allow for glue and he never had another failure. (They replaced the failed doors without charge.) I have always been a little suspicious of this claim. I suspect the guy on the line failed to glue the joints adequately or at all.

I can not remember a joint that failed because it was starved. I do slather mine with glue and coat both sides of the joint and like to see squeeze out.

I did have a cutting board I glued up with resorcinol that fell apart completely immediately but we had glued it when it was way below freezing and we were in a hurry. Haste makes waste.

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

Clint Searl

On the other hand, if the wood is stable and doesn't need to be warped or pulled together to make it fit, it takes little yellow glue and modest pressure to to create a sure joint. On edge joints, I purposely try for no squeeze out by laying a thin bead on one edge and not trying to wet the whole surface. Applying moderate pressure spreads the glue and makes the joint. I've never had a joint spontaneously fail. I think a failed joint indicates poor design and construction.

Clint

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#5

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

john lucas

There was an article in one of the magazines a few years back that stated the same thing. You can't apply enough pressure with the clamps that we use to starve the joint and get glue failure.

I had always heard about starved joints and was kind of shocked by the article. I was in the process of testing glues on end grain to endgrain joints to I just tried some side grain joints with all of my different glues and as much pressure as I could apply with my pipe clamps. None of the side grain glue joints failed.

Then end grain test which was 3/4" square pieces glued end grain as a butt joint. On the Yellow glues I presoaked the ends with diluted glue the way I had always learned. I tried CA, yellow glue, Gorilla glue, 5 minute epoxy and slow cure epoxy, and some liquid hide glue. I was amazed how weak this joint is. To test them I clamped on end in a vice and put a 5lb weight on the joint and then slid it away from the joint. Only the epoxy let me get the weight more than an inch away before it snapped off. It made me a believer in doing anything you can avoid a straight butt joint.

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#6

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

FredD

I agree with Clint , I would bet that many joint failures could be traced to a joint that was using glue for a crack filler.

FredD

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#7

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

Alexander Grigoriev

Maybe those who had glue failure, forgot to apply it to both sides of the joint?

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#8

Re: To be fair. . .

Dave Mount

I'll agree that Bill's experiment used only one set of conditions and, beyond what Lee said, was unreplicated (not that I'd be expecting a different result if it were). However, Lee's response implies that the excess clamping pressure assertion couldn't be disproven until all the thousands of permutations of wood, MC, temperature, glue, etc. have been tested. This is reasoning follows the path of requiring the proof of a negative, which is not possible.

To turn Lee's criticism around, the "excess clamping pressure" assertion is not made with any reference to certain species of wood, MC, temperature, glue, etc., so Bill's experiment does offer legitimate contrary evidence. I wouldn't personally say the it's "myth busted", but I would say the claim was put on the defensive. Has someone offered up a similar experiment where failure of an �overclamped� joint has failed when one with lesser pressure has held, regardless of the wood, MC, temperature, glue, etc?

Also, I wouldn't say Bill's experiment is anecdotal. He gave us the conditions for his experiment and showed us the result. He didn't just claim to have done it without providing evidence that he did. He did something that would be reasonably expected to show a different result if the "excess clamping pressure" assertion was true in the general case. Sure we have to trust that what he did is exactly what he said he did, but I see no reason to doubt that. More than that, he gave us some information from the glue's manufacturer that actually suggests a reason why one wouldn't expect it to be possible to overclamp a yellow glue joint.

It is very possible that hide glue might not respond the same way, as I believe hide glue works differently than PVA. But again, I've not heard the "excess clamping pressure" assertion is not made in a way that suggests it is with respect to hide glue only.

Bill Tindall has a long history on this board of actually doing experiments to test different ideas rather than simply repeat conventional wisdom. This is particularly true for assertions for which the mechanistic basis is not clear. From my interactions with Bill, I get the strong impression that Bill is not happy simply being told something is so, he wants to know why it's so. I agree this is important -- if you don't understand why something is true, you have no ability to understand where to apply the principle and where it might not hold true. Anyone can repeat adages; what is more valuable is those that impart knowledge. Adages are not knowledge unless you know why they are true.

Even if his experiments are not definitive, I think he deserves great credit for at least trying to examine the basis for such things, and for allowing the rest of us to benefit from it. It troubles me when he gets a response that discredits his effort while at the same time offering no particular alternative insight or countering information. From the responses he has received at times over the years, I'm sometimes surprised that he continues to do these experiments and report back to the group. I'm glad Bill has a pretty thick skin, because it would be a real loss if he quit doing it.

My $0.02,

Dave

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#9

Re: To be fair. . .

Jesse Cloud

I think the real danger of using a huge amount of pressure is causing the workpiece to rack or warp. Something thats square under huge pressure may not be when the pressure is released.

I think Bill hit it on the head with the comment that excessive clamping pressure usually is applied to overcome poor joinery and its the poor joinery that causes the failure, not the clamp...

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#10

Re: To be fair. . .

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I can think of only one condition in which excessive clamp pressure will result in a failed joint and that is epoxy. The West System instructions rely on a bit of a gap, even though slight, and warn that if excessive clamping force is used, the joint will be starved and thus fail. But then, epoxy bonding doesn't work the same way as a water-based glue. I can't tell you why, just repeating the insructions that came with my epoxy.

I've had M&T joints fail, but that had nothing to do with clamping pressure. Rather, I made them piston-fit and the tenon scraped the glue from the joint as it was inserted into the mortise. I did learn from my mistakes.

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#11

What is "adhesion"?

Marv

Adhesion is the absense of space. Glue of any kind including epoxy merely allows two surface to be close enough together to create adhesion. Epoxy works well due to it's ability to wet. It will move into the fibers of wood for example due to it's outstanding capilary action, hence, it doesn't require a lot of clamping pressure. With other bonding agents, the clamping pressure forces the liquid into the fibers because it's capilary action isn't as great. Once the glue is clamped to a certain point, any additinal clamping does nothing to force more glue into the fibers.

Adhesion can take place without a bonding agent. For example, two pieces of glass is ground and polished to a flatness measured in angstroms which is the next level of measure down from microns, force the air out from between the two finely ground pieces of glass and you have adhesion. The two pieces of glass cannot be pulled apart without breaking them.

Why does scotch tape stick to things? The sticky stuff on one side does the same thing that yellow glue does, only it doesn't dry or cure. The tape won't stick until you rub on it and work the sticky stuff into the pores of the material it is sticking to. By rubbing on it, it's the same as clamping wood when using yellow glue. You are forcing the bonding agent into the rough surface to obtain a closeness in angstroms. Adhesion doesn't take place until surfaces are at least angstroms apart.

Marv

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#12

Lee Grindinger

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Lee Grindinger

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#13

Re: Mythbusting and human behavior

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I concur that Bill Tindall's statement that "It is simply impossible to squeeze so much high viscosity glue from the joint as to leave behind too little" may be too global a statement, based on his experiment with one type of wood and one type of glue.

As I understand it, scientific theory is an attempt to explain phenomena, and one replicable experiment that refutes existing theory demonstrates that the theory is incomplete or wrong, in whole or in part. Theories are always, in effect, tentative, ready to be refuted by the next genius who sees the flaw and carries out the right experiment. It's quite common to find articles in scientific journals that describe a single experiment that tests a theory and finds it or an aspect of it wanting. Indeed, given the need to control variables to ensure that you are testing a clearly defined hypothesis (and the cost of most modern science), huge, global experiments are rare indeed, and there is a tradition in many disciplines of papers that study studies - assemble the results of multiple experiments into a summary that attempts to illuminate any larger lessons from the aggregate.

Bill described one theory of gluing practice to include "...that applying too much clamp pressure will squeeze out the glue and leave a 'starved joint' that will be weak." He offered an experiment that appears to refute this assertion. Any of us with some wood, clamps, and glue could attempt to replicate this experiment. If it holds up, then that particular theory is, at best, incomplete - that is, there may still be conditions in which it is true, but it is not true universally, and further experimentation will reveal whether it is incomplete or wrong. For instance, Bill chose a wood with fairly large pores; would the same results occur in rock maple?

I think Bill's only mistake, and I can understand the attraction of the idea, is using the "Myth Busters" TV show as the metaphorical framework for his post. Popular culture is rarely rigorous enough for the scientific method (although the show has a lot more visual flair to it than most scientific research).

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#14

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

wilbur

"To validate these claims the joint shown in the picture was prepared and clamped in a full sized machinist vice with as much pressure as I could muster on the 14" handle. I would presume that this amount of jaw pressure on the small joint resulted in substantially more pressure than could be applied with woodworking clamps."

Actually, this is a pretty big presumption, given the hypothesis you're testing. Are there numbers on the amount of pressure a machinist vise can generate? If it's a machinist vise with a lot of surface area (8" jaws), the amount of pressure that can be generated might be spread out enough over the large jaw surface so that the actual psi might be lower than you think.

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#15

Re: Mythbusting and human behavior

Marv

The reason I posted "What is Adhesion?" below was an attempt to explain in some what general terms how to think of a glue joint. The variables are endless when discussing this subject. To discuss it in anything but general terms only invites disagreement rather than being instructive.

I have had glue joints fail when only applying glue to one surface. I have never had one fail when applying to both surfaces and allowing the glue to soak in for a few minutes before clamping. I always use enough to get plenty of oooz. As I explained below, once the clamping pressure exceeds a certain amount of pressure, the added pressure does nothing to effect the joint. I never worry about over clamping. I am concerned about under clamping and or uneven clamping.

The amount of clamping pressure need only be enough to force the bonding agent into the fibers so as to reduce the space between the fibers enough to effect "adhesion". If there is a concern about minimizing a glue line, the amount of clamping could help in that regard.

The new upper horn on the saw handle in the picture below is an example of what I consider a good joint made with yellow glue. The wood is Mahagony. This of course is only one type of glue joint. IMO, it is best to glue both surfaces, however, I'm sure there are many situations that won't require gluing both surfaces. The joint on this saw handle is consistant with Bill T,s demonstration where the joint is stronger than the wood.

Marv


Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#16

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

Marv

Wilbur,

Having used mill vises I can easily believe that Bill did in fact apply more pressure than what would normally be applied with a wood clamp. The size of the jaws on his mill vise didn't have any effect on pressure per square inch of the jaws because the clamping was mainly on the smaller piece of wood. For his particular gluing/clamping example, I think he proved his point regarding "over-clamping".

Whether using a mill vise or a wood clamp, using more pressure than is necessary to effect adhesion can easily be done. Bill used a mill vise mainly to perhaps over emphesize that he was applying what he considered to be "over-clamping". For demonstration purposes he could have parked his truck on it or used a pressure gauge of some kind.

Marv

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#17

Re: What is "adhesion"?

Chris Friesen

"Glue of any kind including epoxy merely allows two surface to be close enough together to create adhesion."

I'm afraid this is false. Epoxy (as well as some other glues like construction adhesive) can be structural substances in and of themselves. Thus they don't require the surfaces to be particularly close (and indeed in the case of epoxy they work better if the surfaces _aren't_ particularly close).

PVA glue on the other hand is _not_ gap filling and works best with very thin glue lines.

Re: Myth busting "excessive" clamping pressure

#18

Re: What is "adhesion"?

Marv

Chris,

Are you saying that epoxy is not close to the fibers? I think I explained that epoxy does not require as much pressure as glue due to it's capillary action. It will soak or wet into the wood fiber pretty much on it's own.

My main point was/is, adhesion will only occur when the elements involved are within angstroms from each other. The bonding agent allows that to happen.

Marv