Re: To be fair. . .
Dave Mount
I'll agree that Bill's experiment used only one set of conditions and, beyond what Lee said, was unreplicated (not that I'd be expecting a different result if it were). However, Lee's response implies that the excess clamping pressure assertion couldn't be disproven until all the thousands of permutations of wood, MC, temperature, glue, etc. have been tested. This is reasoning follows the path of requiring the proof of a negative, which is not possible.
To turn Lee's criticism around, the "excess clamping pressure" assertion is not made with any reference to certain species of wood, MC, temperature, glue, etc., so Bill's experiment does offer legitimate contrary evidence. I wouldn't personally say the it's "myth busted", but I would say the claim was put on the defensive. Has someone offered up a similar experiment where failure of an �overclamped� joint has failed when one with lesser pressure has held, regardless of the wood, MC, temperature, glue, etc?
Also, I wouldn't say Bill's experiment is anecdotal. He gave us the conditions for his experiment and showed us the result. He didn't just claim to have done it without providing evidence that he did. He did something that would be reasonably expected to show a different result if the "excess clamping pressure" assertion was true in the general case. Sure we have to trust that what he did is exactly what he said he did, but I see no reason to doubt that. More than that, he gave us some information from the glue's manufacturer that actually suggests a reason why one wouldn't expect it to be possible to overclamp a yellow glue joint.
It is very possible that hide glue might not respond the same way, as I believe hide glue works differently than PVA. But again, I've not heard the "excess clamping pressure" assertion is not made in a way that suggests it is with respect to hide glue only.
Bill Tindall has a long history on this board of actually doing experiments to test different ideas rather than simply repeat conventional wisdom. This is particularly true for assertions for which the mechanistic basis is not clear. From my interactions with Bill, I get the strong impression that Bill is not happy simply being told something is so, he wants to know why it's so. I agree this is important -- if you don't understand why something is true, you have no ability to understand where to apply the principle and where it might not hold true. Anyone can repeat adages; what is more valuable is those that impart knowledge. Adages are not knowledge unless you know why they are true.
Even if his experiments are not definitive, I think he deserves great credit for at least trying to examine the basis for such things, and for allowing the rest of us to benefit from it. It troubles me when he gets a response that discredits his effort while at the same time offering no particular alternative insight or countering information. From the responses he has received at times over the years, I'm sometimes surprised that he continues to do these experiments and report back to the group. I'm glad Bill has a pretty thick skin, because it would be a real loss if he quit doing it.
My $0.02,
Dave