We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
A leak has caused water to rot about a 2-3 foot section of my sill plate. The area above it on the first floor is a fireplace with a large stone mantle and hearth that go to the top of an 11 ft wall. The drywall on both sides of the mantle has a 1 foot long crack.
The picture shows the rim joist (A), the sill plate (B), a second sill plate inside of the first one (C), a rotted piece of bridging (D). (F) and (G) are floor joists that project out beyond the foundation and support the chimney structure. What is NOT shown is that the 2 joists(F & G) that extend under the chimney are rotted as is the decking on top of them. There is no way to access this from outside. There is only about 4" of ground clearance under the chimney.
My plan was to jack up the floor just enough to remove and replace the rotted sill plate and sister the 2 rotted floor joists. I'm planning on renting 2 hydraulic jacks and use 4x4's to bridge between the jack and the joist. Any other suggestions would be much appreciated.
The thing that would scare me is the damage that may occur to the wall upstairs. When I rehabbed the old garage that my shop is in I had to replace all the sill plates due to termite damage. Even with everything stripped down to the studs and ceiling joists the noise of protesting nails and lumber was scary as hell.
If it were me, I think I would call a pro on this one. Someone with the experience to do it right and the insurance to cover it if something goes wrong.
Ken, As a Home Inspector I see stuff like this frequently.
I am guessing, but do you think it is possible someone put in the second row of sill plate inside the original outer row because it was rotting?
And, In general this is a two part problem. You really need to figure out how the water got in there and caused the rot and cure the leak?stop the penetration so that the rot will stop and won't just rot the new work. The first step is to arrest the water problem and the second is to repair the damage. Repairing the damage does not necessarily mean removing and replacing every rotted piece. It means replacing the STRENGTH of the rotted pieces.
You don't mention what kind of siding is on the house, but it might be easier to do this if you could take some of it off to gain access from the outside also.
I would recommend that you use treated wood for the repair. Any wood you put against rotting wood will be prone to rot. The fungi will simply migrate over into the new wood. Especially if you don't cure the leak or the wood is damp. Also, Treated wood is generally wet and swollen form the treatment process and that makes it heavy and over sized, difficult to work with. Try to see if someone in your area carries treated wood that has been dried after treatment. (KDAT= Kiln Dried After Treatment or ADAT= Air Dried After Treatment). This lumber will be much lighter and more nearly the same size at the original lumber, making it easier to install.
If you use wet treated lumber it will shrink as it dries in place and may allow for some slight settlement in the work.
If you do not use treated wood, you should separate the new wood from the old wood with some sort of barrier/flashing the rot will not penetrate. Either way, its a good idea to soak any remaining rotted or stained wood with an effective fungicide such as Bora Care.
You will have to remove that electric wire that is in the way. The Pro's turn the power off, cut the wire on either side of the repair and Install two junction boxes to make the splices.
What are you planing to do about the rot under the fireplace itself? Can you insert a joist into the space from inside the crawl Space?
This is difficult specialized work. Be careful. Easy to get hurt. Uses skills and muscles you may not be used to using. This is a project where you shod consider calling in the pro's. What are you going to do if the mantle falls off the wall or the fire place drops through the floor? I have done things like this and they never go as expected.
Automotive practice is never to trust a jack to do anything but jacking - the lifting stage. Hydraulic jacks can leak back down. Once you've got it to the height you want, block it up substantially. This is best done with crossed 4x4s - lay down 2 4x4s, a bit apart, on firmly packed and flat soil - cross two more at right angles, a bit apart, so that you're making an open square. Repeat until you're supporting the joists, then let the jacks down so that the weight's resting on the wood.
I've done some jacking on our house, and am no expert; we replaced mudsill on two six-foot sections of wall when we did our kitchen remodel. I agree that this job may be tricky enough to consider hiring a professional.
Let me tell you about my exprinces, I had a house moveda couple of years ago, to satisfy the lender I had to have a contractor involved. He only did enough to ge the house finaled, that was ok because he charged accordingly. However the floor felt like a cros between a skateboard park and a trampoline. I got the job of releveling everything, at one place the rim joist didn't touch the sill plate for 12 feet. Here are a couple of thoughts. First get three jacks in the 20 ton or bigger range, a 4X4 is not thick enough for a "bridge" use a 4X8 make jack pads of three layers of two by material crisscrossed with 3/4 plywood on each side 16" square (I was able to use pier pads as a base for the jacks so I didn't have to worry about this, but I use something similar for pads on our boom truck at work) and put an 1/4" steel plate between the top of the Jack and any wood. Wear darn good knee pads, have someone watching the walls for cracks, your existing crack should cloase up before work make new ones, but of course.... If you are going to try to use a level ( iwas able to use a rotating beam laser) measure off the bottom of the floor not the bottom of the joist. E-mail me if you want. I spent what felt like weeks under the house, and still have areas tha tneed work.
Thanks for the replies. Barry, I found the leak and have fixed it. I moved into the house about a year after it was constructed so I think the double sill plate was original. The exterior of the house is stucco. I thought about removing it but I have plenty of room in the basement to slide in 2x10 sister joists. I was ignoring the part about replacing the decking. Even if I cut the stucco off the chimney, I don't see how I could get new decking in. There will still be studs in the way.
Funny you mention pressure treated. I had PT wood in my cart and then decided against it due to weight (wet). I may reconsider.
My plan with jacking was to just support the floor while I remove the rotten sill. I will plane down the new sill plates so that they are the same thickness as the rotted ones are. Hopefully, that will only result in rising the floor maybe 1/16". I think that as long as it doesn't settle any more, I will be ok.
There are so many aspects to this. Others have brad guth up points I over looked or failed to mention. Gary mentions to have a plate of steel to put between the wood and the jack. I would suggest an even thicker plate, something like 3/8" or 1/2". I tried a thinner piece and it ended up a dome.
I have made good use of Telecolumns or screw jacks. Get the heavy duty ones at the borg. In short lengths they are about $30. A worthwhile addition to the hydraulic jacks. You can lift it with the hydraulic jack and hold it with the screw jack. Try Pier block as bases. (12 x 12 x 8" solid blocks) My experience is that you jack it up and it settles again as the soil and the wood compresses, so be prepared to jack and then jack again. The plates that come with the telecolumns aren't strong enough. Adding a thicker plate to them will help. The telecolumns and hydraulic jacks need to be vertical and not at an angle. If they are angled they will kick out and that is very dangerous. The screw jacks do not leak down like some hydraulic jacks. Think redundancy here. If you a struggling with a piece of wood and knock down one of the jacks it might be a disaster. Have others in place.
The pieces that rotted and settled did it over a long period of time. Things move very slowly. You are trying to reverse that rather suddenly. Some of the materials have acquired a new shape and really don't want to go back to where they were. Its like a permanent wave in hair. You might think these things want to spring back into position. Probably not.
After you make all the structural repairs, you probably want to wit a month or two before making the cosmetic ones. There may be some new settling and cracking as the structure adjusts to its new shape.
One thing not mentioned here is the length of your "sisters" so I'll point out that, since they are supporting all the weight of the masonry, you should be looking to having these members supported by more than the new sill plate. That usually means running you sister joists back to the first beam for 2-point support. Not doing so will rob the sisters of much of their strength because the weight above will tender to "scissor" the repair. Absent this, the joist assemblies should be wrapped and bolted in two locations Of course, you can also install several permanent piers, but I doubt you'll be wanting to dig the footings for them.
For any degraded wood that you're not removing completely, you should look into restoration injection of resin once the area has dried (less that 12%mc); PolyAll 2000 is one, but there are several others systems available that can can be absorbed into the wood.
From experience, I can tell you the project you are thinking of undertaking is both dangerous and quite involved.
Further, you stated:''I was ignoring the part about replacing the decking.'' When it comes time to sell your house, you may well be required to divulge any known defficiencies with the structure. Failure to do so can have legal ramifications.
My thought is that you would be far better off hiring a licensed, bonded and insured contractor to remedy the situation. Then when resale time comes, you can divulge the past problem and state that the contractor had taken care of it. This, in my opinion, would be far more reassuring to a prospective buyer than a homeowner done repair.
I am sorry to see that a thoughtless or incompetent builder or Code Authority allowed that fireplace to be carried on the floor support members alone.
Now you have a problem that is only partly fixed by replacing rotted wood.
The fireplace should have been supported by Masonry or a concrete wall constructed inside of a well headed off in the floor .
It never should be allowed to depend on wood joists and sills for it's support.
If it had been done that way , you only would have a water leak and dry rot to contend with, not with the entire dead load of the fireplace.
This is a good thing to look for in the purchase of a older home or in areas without modern Code enforcement.
The Masonry foundation can still be installed by a Masonry contractor or Builder who is used to working in close quarters , it doesn't cost you a dime to have a couple of them to look at it before you start hacking and hewing on the floor system.
Ken, As you can see from the comments this has elicited, this is a complicated project. There are many facets. Curing the leak and replacing the strength are tow that I mentioned. then there are the ethical and potentially legal ramifications of making a "less than professional repair". Locally, you have to call a contractor that specializes in this type of repair and they are few and far between. I have seen some of the most half-a$$ed worked passed off as professional. As a Home Inspector I hate to be asked to inspect he area after the repairs are made. They are almost always pitiful.
I am assuming you have a manufactured "zero clearance" fireplace and not a masonry one.
There should be more than four inches of clearance to the ground under the flooring supporting the unit.
You could go to the lumber yards and see if you can find some joists that have be in stock for a while, giving the treated lumber time to dry.
Any joists you insert under the fireplace that are cantilevered over the foundation should be as long and possible and at least twice as long on the inside and they project over the wall. Perhaps they should be designed by a Professional Engineer. They should be bolted very securely to the existing joists. I would not hurt to glue them also. Choose joists for the repair that are of superior grade to the existing ones. No sense in doing all the work and installing crap that is destined to fail again.
I agree with the idea of only jacking them enough to support them where they are. Trying to jack them much further than that creates more mess than you have now. If you are jacking off a basement floor, be very careful. Most slabs are not designed to support point loads and while it might, it might not.
Do you have the EIFS or acrylic stucco or the old fashioned cement kind. The thin acrylic version has been something of a disaster and you are lucky if this is the only damage you have.
Ken, There are a few questions that I wonder about. Could you post a photo of the fireplace above? It is hard to believe that someone would have rocked up that high on top of wood framing.
While it would be normal for the mud-sill to be wood, I would be tempted to get your new joist in, then replace everything under that with brick or masonry.
For that mater, I don't know how you will replace the plywood sub-floor without loosing the rock-work above. I'm not saying you can't, but it may be easier to just take that down first.
If not, I would start by getting the wire out of the way as described above. Then cut out everything between two joist down to the masonry, then get some vertical support for the stone above while getting the new sisters in.
I would then be trying to shoot for getting solid masonry material between the foundation and the above hearth.
You should dig down to find out if there is some footing or footer on either side of the foundation wall that you might bring up some more brick to support that hearth.
You might be able to support the work above while you get some brick laid up under part of it, then after that has set up, remove the temporary support, then lay up the rest.
Don't think of it as a one-shot process, but rather nibble away at one solvable problem at a time.
I would not be even thinking about putting wood back to replace the sills. Horizontal grain wood down here is not what you need now. It will only crush under the weight above when it tries to expand and contract due to changing MC in the future.
Keith, here's a picture of the fireplace. As I see it, all the weight of the stone is inside the foundation. The exterior of the chimney is stucco.
Something else hit me last night while re-examining the situation. The foundation has a "dog leg" about 2x6 ft that goes out on a wall adjacent to the fireplace. I suspect they poured the foundation wrong or later decided to put the fireplace on a different wall. It doesn't change anything but at least partially explains the situation.
Wow, Ken I can't believe someone would lay that much stone on top of wood framing. Is that real natural stone, and not some light-weight man-made?
As some of the others have suggested, you may want to talk to someone who contracts this sort of thing, to get their feedback. However, I will just say, that I would not be thinking so much about replacing the decayed wood with more wood, but would be planning to expand the existing footing, then laying more brick up under that rock.
If that stone is sandstone, is would weigh about 145# per cu. ft., so you can estimate the weight pretty easy just by measuring the volume.
2. Is there a Homeowner's Warranty still in effect?
3. Is the builder still in business?
Your pictures show a major construction defect that should have prevented the structure from being given a CofO. Before you attempt any self-help here, I strongly suggest you contact an attorney in your area who deals with construction cases. "Mr. Bob the Builder" may be called back to remediate this, which will include foundation work and a permanent fix of the leak you corked which was most likely caused by the compromised structure.
viewing your outside shot of the house , leads me to believe that the structure is easily new enough to have to conform to current code requirements on a support system for the fireplace.
Just the hearth alone if it is more then 4 inches in height , will trigger the requirement for a separate foundation for the fireplace .
This is necessary for a couple of reasons besides holding up the structure, it also permits vertical movement of the masonry and or the wood members of the house to move independent of each other, failure to do that is what more then likely is causing the cracks in your Sheetrock.
A certificate of occupancy issued by the Building department really only lets the lender and the builder sign off on their part.
It will not address any omissions on the field inspectors part.
Some hell may be raised behind closed doors , but you will never know.
The best approach I have seen used in years of home building in this particular case is to engage a Structural Engineer to inspect the work done and the work necessary to remedy it and the estimated cost of fixing it and whether or not in his professional opinion you got what you paid for.
It is this guys opinion and his license number on that opinion that will draw the attention of the building department and whether they should rethink giving out permits to the company that built the house.
Next step is to approach the Contractors Bonding company for redress of the complaint.
They will give the Contractor a opportunity to do it over right or they will hire it done and back charge him and unbeknownst to most people , the bonding company has a enforceable lien on everything the Contractor owns , personally or otherwise.
Just take a business like approach to the matter , follow the steps and you should be okay with the results.
Good points but . . If Ken's not the original purchaser and/or the builder's down the tubes with no surviving bond and warranty to Ken's benefit, he's s.o.l.
Unless . . . when he bought the house, he hired an inspector who failed to catch the violation (unlike our Barry who would have nailed it), in which case Ken's got an E&O insurance policy to go after.
Hence my questions on the existence of the builder. etc.. There are a lot fewer of them these days. Before hiring that fancy engineer for a consult, he'd better make sure he's got somebody else to send that bill to. If he's on his own regarding recoverable damages and costs, he'll do better to hire a proper remediator. That's going to be some real digging from the outside and possibly a full ROAR of the existing fixture. Especially if the chimney is masonry rather than just a pretty face.
With all due respect Mark , a Structural Engineer is exactly the guy to determine after the fact what went on before Ken came along.
They are regular people who charge fairly and I would be surprised based on what I have had done in the past that the fee would be more the 250.00 unless he had to provide expert testimony in the "full roar".
Beyond that their are several tricks available to the uninitiated, One I used a couple times that worked like magic.
Assuming that the house is in a subdivision and was constructed by the same company or Builder, you can bet similar houses with the fireplace like Kens are in that subdivision owned by unsuspecting people like Ken who felt they were getting their moneys worth.
This kind of information can scare a builder to death and make them very accommodating.
Another possible option would be that the initial construction loan was rolled over into a conventional mortgage and is still held by the originating lender.
If this is the case , then that Lender has a Fiduciary obligation to the owner that he indeed got what he is being charged for monthly by that Lender.
This is where the Performance Bond that the Lender requires comes into play , regardless of whether the Builder went down for the count or not.
I would suggest to Ken that he explore the problem fully before it comes time to hire a legal beagle and choose up sides.
Naturally I would recommend you guy ;-))
FredD
BTW Ken,
since Ellis frowns on anecdotal recitals, or so he has said , if you want a couple of instances of what I did to get relief for a Cousin and a Client in situations like yours , feel free to email me.
I hate to mention this but the Cousin was a licensed Family Law
Attorney in California and naive in all things construction wise like you wouldn't believe and also sat on the State Bar's ethics panel.
Again, thanks for all the thoughtful replies. Filling in a few more missing pieces ---
The house is 20 years old. The builder lived in it for about 14 months before we purchased it. I have no idea where he is of if he is still in business. We did have the house inspected prior to purchase. Needless to say, no mention of this deficiency.
My guess is that trying to pursue either the builder, home inspector or the county inspector at this stage would just be throwing good money after bad. I think I'll just get it fixed and move on.
[Recommend me, that is ] I haven't done construction law since I was a pup, plus I have no idea where Ken is; I'm not admitted to practice in every state, so am precluded from giving him any or anyone else legal advise over the internet.
Last time I checked fees for consulting structural engineers in my area (for friend's use], they were $250 per hour with a minimum of $1k just to leave the office.
With the number of builders, banks, and financial companies gone belly-up in the last 18 months, it's a whole different world out there. I don't doubt that a good PE should get involved in the remedy, but I think Ken needs to see if anyone in his structure's "chain of obligation" is still standing before he starts laying out the bucks.
He'd best do this right because if his area is anything like mine, when he goes to sell the house, he might just get hammered by the thing failing to get a CofO for the new purchaser. Then they just deduct the $30,000+ repair cost from the sale price, and Ken gets the real feeling of not being able to sit down for a long while.
Not knowing where you live, but every new home in my area carries a warranty against this kind of thing that in effect for at least 5 YEARS.
Ken, call your mortgage company. I'm going to be very surprised if this is not covered on such a new structure. You're looking at some major bucks to correct this.
"He'd best do this right because if his area is anything like mine, when he goes to sell the house, he might just get hammered by the thing failing to get a CofO for the new purchaser. Then they just deduct the $30,000+ repair cost from the sale price, and Ken gets the real feeling of not being able to sit down for a long while."