Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Lithium Battery question

Posts

Lithium Battery question

#1

Lithium Battery question

Barry Irby

I mentioned below that I bought a Bosch Multi Tool. It has 12 Volt Lithium Ion batteries. After a while the first of two batteries went dead. I put it in the charger, but the charger flashed red. I let it sit for a few minutes and it was still flashing read. Took the battery out for a minute or two and put it back in. It still flashed red. At that point, we unplugged the unit and left the job and left it there for tomorrow. I don't have anything else with Lithium Ion batteries. Are they touchy about being recharged immediately? Do they need to cool first?

Re: Lithium Battery question

#2

Re: Lithium Battery question

Bill Howatt

I have seen it mentioned that batteries that go flat because of use and are warm should be allowed to cool before putting in the charger. I think it likely applies to all rechargeable batteries because charging will cause the internal temperature to rise and if it is already hot then it isn't good. How critical this is, I have no idea and I don't know if that's why your light is on.

Bill

Re: Lithium Battery question

#3

Re: Lithium Battery question

ehgauss

I don't feel like getting out of my easy chair right now to check, but my recollection is that the De Walt charger for my NiCad batteries flashes red when a battery that has less than a full charge is inserted, and keeps flashing red until fully charged, when it goes to steady red. Check your manual - maybe it's working correctly.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#4

Re: Lithium Battery question

Barry Irby

I left the manual on the job with the tool, but as I recall there is a red light and a green light. The manual was written in some other language and translated into gibberish.

The green light had a battery with an arrow into into it and a star burst of dashes around it. Then there was a fully green battery with a star burst of solid lines around it. My take on that (Don't you love the wordless symbols?) is that when the green light was flashing the juice was going into the battery and when the green light was on constantly the battery was full. I am guessing the flashing red light meant something negative, just not sure what.

I had just used the battery, but it did not feel hot. I guess hot is a relative term. There may have been some heat inside it, but the case did not feel even warm.

I will try again tomorrow. I am just a little nervous about this tool because I bought it on the close out table at Lowes and I am wondering if it was used before and return for some reason, like bad batteries. I guess I will know soon.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#5

Re: Lithium Battery question

John K Jordan

(My experience is with camera batteries. I've never had a power tool with Li-ions but I'm guessing the same principles apply.)

Li-ion batteries can be damaged discharged below a certain voltage. Even if not damaged, the charger may be unable to charge a battery that is too low. It is usually not a good idea to discharge these (or any) batteries until they are dead, dead, dead. Due to this problem, most Li-ion batteries contain smart protection circuitry that shuts the battery off if the voltage gets too low. (It works to prevent overcharging as well, which can cause the battery to explode.) If this circuit is missing or damaged or if the battery self-discharges due to inactivity the standard charger may simply not be able to charge it.

If the voltage has gotten too low and the charger won't work, perhaps the manufacturer can recharge it.

Li-ion batteries also have a limited number of recharge cycles. Your manual should say how many.

JKJ

Re: Lithium Battery question

#6

Re: Lithium Battery question

Scott in Montana

Sounds like you may have a bad battery or it's not fully inserted into the charger.

From the Bosch manual:

If the red indicator light is

�BLINKING�, the battery pack

cannot accept a charge or the

contacts of the charger or battery pack are

contaminated. Clean the contacts of the

charger or battery pack only as directed in

these operating instructions or those

supplied with your tool or battery pack.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#7

Re: Lithium Battery question

Barry Irby

Thanks, As I mentioned, this tool is new to me. I bought it on the close out at Lowes a few weeks ago and have not used it at all until yesterday. I got it out in preparation for the trip tot he job and charged both batteries. I put a pine scrap in my vice and played with it long enough to saw off a 2X4. Put it back in the case and took it to the job. Use one battery intermittently over an hour or so cutting mostly drywall. When the battery went dead, I put it in the charger and used the other one. It was flashing red, so I took it out and let it sit a while, thinking the battery might have been warm. It did not go to work before with left, so when I get here today, I will try again. I will check the contacts, but they appeared to be bright and new at a glance. These little battery packs are 12 Volt and about an 1 1/2" in diameter and maybe 2 1/2" long. Wonder what the run time is for the tool?

Re: Lithium Battery question

#8

Re: Lithium Battery question

Barry Irby

These are my first Li-ion batteries for a tool also and my first Bosch battery powered tool and my first Multi-tool. I have Makita cordless drills with Nicads or Nickel metal hydride batteries. They get warm and have to cool. These Li-ion batteries did not feel warm, but we were in a cold building.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#9

Re: Lithium Battery question

awleonard

Yes, Li batteries are very sensitive to temperature. If charge is attempted above a specific temperatire, bad things will happen! Every Li battery pack I have seen has a temp sensor (usualyl a thermistor) to avoid charging when the cell temp is above threshold. This is a big issue for us (we have over 100k batteries out in the field) as some of our equipment rooms are not cooled. There are several different methods of checking the temp and controlling the charge. Most of our battery packs can be charged independently, so the "smarts" have to be in the pack itself. Li doesn't like to be cold either.

I hate batteries!

Tony

Re: Lithium Battery question

#10

Re: Lithium Battery question

Scott in Montana

Hello Barry,

I was surprised how short the battery charge lasted on this tool but I guess I should have known if I had done the math.

I get about five minutes of sawing or ten minutes of sanding with this tool. I know it's not much, but it sure is handy around the shop or the house. It definately isn't a replacement for the Fein Multimaster, but much more convenient than dragging out a corded tool for a little task.

I bought it because I have the rest of the Bosch series, with exception to the metal cutter. Overall I think they're great tools, especially the driver and right-angle driver... and they all use the same batteries and the same charger. But, this tool isn't much beyond a convenience.

Scott in Montana

Re: Lithium Battery question

#11

Re: Lithium Battery question

Mitch from Canada

I have a Ryobi (green lithium ion) drill. Originally used in my unheated shop, the batteries needed recharge alot sooner than I thought they would. If it was too cold in the shop, they wouldn't charge at all (one battery left in the drill bag that WAS recently charged suddenly had NO charge)...the red light on the charger would simply flash when I clicked the battery in place. I had to bring the batteries and charger into the house and let everything warm up before they would charge.

Now that my shop is heated (overhead radiant) I've used one battery for a LONG time without needing recharge. The battery left in the bag still shows full charge after months of no use.

I've known of contractors placing their litium tools on the heat vents on the dashboard of their trucks before using them outside.

Not sure if trying to charge a "hot due to hard use" battery would cause any problems. It's never been a problem for mine.

Just my thoughts.

Mitch

Re: Lithium Battery question

#12

Re: Lithium Battery question

Jorge Casta�eda

Barry,

I have the 18V Milwakee set, the drill and the impact driver, work a looong time, days, on a charge, the skil saw and specially the sawzall go flat in 20 - 30 minutes, so I have a spare besides the 2 that came with the set.

Over a year of daily use in construction and not a problem, getting the best pays.

To me that either the battery and or the charger went bad. I had a charger that made a "pop" sound in my 12 volt Panasonic, and that was that.

You still have a warranty from manufacturer, so demand a replacement, and do not leave them in the cold or on the heat, both are bad for them.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#13

Something of an update....

Barry Irby

Returned to the job and put the battery in the charger. It started flashing green, indicating it was charging. Supposed to be a 30 minute charge, so I went on with the work.

The building we are working on is a remodel and has no heat yet, and it was cold in there. You could see your breath. Some time later I came back to the charger and it was flashing red. By this time the second battery was dead so I tried the one in the charger. It worked. I tried recharging the dead one. It flashed Red. I left it in the charger over night and will check on it when I get back to the job today.

I read the manual. At least I thought I did. It was one of those things printed in four or five languages and I thought I read everything printed in English. I will look again. I don't recall any clear warnings about Charging at room temp only. I knew they were sensitive to heat but did not anticipate the cold being such a problem. If that is what it is.

Since I bought it on the close out sale I am still wondering if I got one that was returned for having a problem or if I just don't under stand Li-ion batteries and am trying to use them under an adverse situation. I drag my butt down there and work in the cold, I expect no less of my tools.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#14

Love my cordless tools, hate the batteries.

Barry Irby

Re: Lithium Battery question

#15

Battery University Link

Bill Howatt

This is a very good reference for batteries.

http://www.batteryuniversity.com/

Bill

Re: Lithium Battery question

#16

Re: Something of an update....

Jorge Casta�eda

Barry,

You have a bad battery, if this was a recent purchase, even if the store don't take them back, the manufacturer will honor it. Warranty is usually a year, so check on that.

The lithium -ion are really no different than others, except the fact that they do not have "memory", the others do and as you use them their charge capacity gets smaller and smaller, the lithium -ion do no do that, and they work at full force until they suddenly don't, no slowing down, kind of old or nothing.

Mine said "guaranteed for five years or a thousand cycles" that is good enough for me, about three years work.

Re: Lithium Battery question

#17

Re: Something of an update....

John K Jordan

FWIW the Dewalt battery warranty is 2 years, according to a factory rep.