Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Up For Discussion*

Posts

Up For Discussion*

#1

Up For Discussion*

David Yoho

I had a thought that I wanted to pose to everyone to get a gauge of the prevailing sentiment here. I don't know that there is a right or wrong answer. I'm just looking for some discussion that could lend itself to some good information for us as well as new visitors.

As woodworkers, we started out the journey in different ways or different paths. Most of us learned and acquired different skills along the way. Most are not schooled formally as woodworkers or designers and yet the work I see displayed here in the messageboards as well as all the Shop Shots I've edited tells me there are many talented and accomplished people here.

So, here's the question/s -


For those that build either by altering an existing plan (putting your own spin on it) or their own custom design, did you learn design before woodworking? If so, do you think it's made you a better woodworker? If not, do you think it's made you a better woodworker?

I'm not looking to start another "Pins Or Tails" war with this. I'm really just curious to see what our folks out there have to say. Personally, I started working wood first but almost always built from what I wanted or an altered plan. As time went by, I built from my own plans almost all the time. However, I don't profess to knowing anything about design other than what looks good to me. Design is something I still struggle with and wish I knew more about. It doesn't mean I'm a bad woodworker. It just means I'm not much of a designer - yet!

So, what say you?

Re: Up For Discussion*

#2

Re: Up For Discussion*

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

Most of my profesional life has been spent as a modelmaker-patternmaker-display builder. I have never had any formal design training but do feel working with engineers, archetects, designers and artists, some design technigues have been absorbed. The people mentioned had ideas and thought I should be able to create their dreams with minimal information. Sometimes I lucked out.

My woodworking is now very limited, but every once in a while I will see something that interests me and I will make my own version of it.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#3

Re: Up For Discussion*

steve mackay

Oh boy ! This could go into "inherant or taught" in a bad way. I think some folks are natural engineers and designers. Problem solvers and trouble junkies. Yes, yes, it CAN be taught but who were the really really succesfull ones ? Personally, I always thought everyone could look at a print or picture and "see" it in "3D". Took a long time before I realized very few can. I think its the folks who CAN visualize this that "stray from the common", alter plans to suit them and create their owm designs. After that its just a choice of medium. Wood, paint, stone, architecture, music.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#4

Re: Up For Discussion*

Barry Irby

I started wood working as a teenager. Couldn't wait to take shop in the eighth grade. I'm 60 now and have been accumulating skills and tools ever since. So, I know HOW. I can build most anything I want to. My problem is the design part. I struggle with WHAT to build or at least what style. I have some design skills and know a few things about proportion, I lack inspiration. It would thrill me to death if somebody (some of them post here) would send me design sketches and say, here, build this. I see many things posted and think "I could have built that" but would never have thought of it. And when I do think of stuff to build I often look at it and think "that should have been better". If I steal a design but change it enough to avoid the feeling of directly copying I am usually disappointed in the changes.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#5

JL

Re: Up For Discussion*

JL

A lot the time I see a picture in a book, catalog or whatever. I think about it, I then draw up plans (either sketches or on graph paper).

In those cases, I see what I'm doing as "adapting" rather than designing.

Upon occasion, I'll start with just pencil and paper. I then draw out my design and go from there. I also do a similar thing with legs and leg patterns. It takes a bit longer as I don't really have a "picture" of what I want. Most of the time the proportions work out. Sometimes they don't. But the thrift stores are happy to accept anything :D .

Re: Up For Discussion*

#6

Hen - Egg situation

Jorge Casta�eda

What was first?

Dave,

My Dad initiated me in woodwork , at age 9, one thing stuck with me since, to be able to build, you need to see it on your mind first, and making a drawing of it helps to do that and shows pitfalls or leads to different solutions,

so to me design is first, never built furniture to anybody else design.

Jorge

Re: Up For Discussion*

#7

Re: Up For Discussion*

Dan Donaldson

I am like you, except that I started later. I can copy just about anything, but I have a real problem with getting a good design. Maybe I should take some kind of a class. I can visualize things in my head, but I guess my head has no imagination to create the really cool pieces like some do on the boards.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#8

Re: Up For Discussion*

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Well, this is interesting. I remember watching my Mother taking down the family cradle using a piece of glass (picture of cradle in shop shots). I was about 5 then. Later she taught me how to refinish. I have been interested in "banging around" with wood since I was a small boy and have ruined many tools through misuse and ignorance. I also have many years of art training either at the Arts Assoc in Marblehead, Mass, or at the MFA in Boston and later on in Milwaukee. I took every Art course I could in school.

I was taught the basics of design by my Mother who was taught them by her Father who was a builder.

Now, which came first? I think there was a "together".

Robert

Re: Up For Discussion*

#9

Wish I had thought of that!

Barry Irby

Many pieces I see here and other places get the Wow! Wish I had thought of that response from me.

OTOH, some of them get the NOPE, I would not have done that response too. And, I'm glad nobody asked me to build some of it. Although, with the economy being the way it is I would build most anything for a buck.

There is a furniture store near by Called La Difference or La Diff for short. Different in the Richmond VA area means not traditional or colonial. They have lots of modern stuff. They feature some attractive stuff in commercials. I went to the store and wandered around looking for inspiration. It was an amazing experience. Apparently the five or ten pieces they put in the commercials was about the only attractive stuff they had in all five floors.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#10

David Barnett

Design 1st, WWing 2nd, plans, no, influences, yes.

David Barnett

I've had formal training in both design and woodworking. Design did not so much make me a better woodworker as informed my aesthetics, focused my construction methods and to a certain extent, my tool preferences. Woodworking is a means to fulfilling my design goals. This is not to say that I don't love the craft, practice and materials of woodworking, but my primary interest has always been design.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#11

Re: Up For Discussion*

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

My dad was a carpenter, my favorite toy at 3 was a hammer, so I have been "playing" with wood all my life. I'm not sure if I have ever built a cabinet or furniture type piece from someone elses plans. Ideas yes, plans no. The stuff I build is generally based on what I need to accomplish a task and pretty utilitarian. As Steve mentioned, I look at flat and see 3D, I'm pretty good at being given a problem and figuring out a solution, but I sure don't know how to do fancy. I look at the pieces Tommy, Chico, Lee and many others here have produced with awe and envy. Where do the ideas come from for such wonderful work. Those folks exhibt artistry, I think all I will ever have is some level of technical skill and compared to others here not much of that.

glc

Re: Up For Discussion*

#12

Re: Up For Discussion*

Gary Smyth

I like to think that I�m creative, but the more I learn the less creative I am. I think often of how much knowledge has been lost over a death, or someone guarding a �secret�, or sometimes simply no one asking the person who did something unique. More than several times I thought that I �created� a design and /or methodology but found out later that it was thought of before, and many times, with greater ingenuity than my own. The same applies to techniques or adapting a tool. So, as many have stated above, mostly I copy and then I tweak to a particular situation. In the process of doing that I learn how others struggled with and solved the same problem. With practice comes shorter time to solve and better workmanship.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#13

Re: Up For Discussion*

Dave Paine

I have never built anything from a plan. I have been inspired by seeing something, elther live or in a picture.

I normally start with an idea, perhaps jot down some dimensions on a piece of paper, but typically I let the idea evolve. Sometimes due to not having the ideal materials on hand, sometimes not having the equipment, sometimes not wanting to perform a difficult operation single handed.

I do not consider myself a "designer". I am an engineer, and so some aspects of my creations are due to my form/fit/function training.

I try to consider width vs length, etc. so that it feels good to me, but I do not worry about "golden ratio" or formal aspect ratio's.

The engineer in my pays a lot of attention to yield from a board. Many times the design evolves to minimize waste.

I also try to highlight the wood properties, perhaps grain pattern, or just the colour.

Caring about how the piece looks is part of being a woodworker. Does it also mean we have to be a designer? I do not think so, but any piece we make is going to have aspects of various roles - designer, engineer, woodworker, janitor, gopher, etc.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#14

Re: Up For Discussion*

Jesse Cloud

Interesting question. I learned woodworking first, still working on getting the basics of design. Design seems much harder. I took a design course in the Fine Woodworking program at our local community college last term and learned a lot, but am still pretty much in a fog.

One technique that seems to help me is to sit down and just start sketching, not stopping until I have maybe 20 variations on the chair leg or whatever is puzzling me. After a while, you begin to see qualities you like in some of the sketches and try to integrate them. Its hard work and my creativity runs dry after about 20 minutes, so a hard problem may take a few sessions.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#15

Re: Up For Discussion*

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon David,

I thinnk my personal background with design, planning, woodworking was a happy combination of study, observation, emulation, and prasctical experience. Although I always worked wood--model airplanes from plans and drawings, my furniture efforts eresulted from hands-on opportunity. I was hired by a couple antique dealers to perform minor (and sometimes major)repairs so that stock could be retailed. This meant disassembly and parts duplication of many designs, and showed some of the limitations of each. Overlay that on the influence of Norm and Scott and Dave Marks, my willingness to tackle more complex projects was assured. I'm not so sure my skill at using tools increased by the same degree as my understanding of how things should look and go together.

George

Re: Up For Discussion*

#16

Re: Up For Discussion*

John K Jordan

Steve,

I think you hit the nail - invention and design seems to come naturally for some people. The ability to visualize things from algorithms to structures to rhythms seems to be one key.

Whether people were born with this or it was learned as a child or later is another question. From my own children and many others I've worked with over the years I've come to believe the best creative designers are born that way. For example, my architect son showed many early signs of this aptitude (even when younger than 2 years old).

I'm sure much can be learned, or more likely, developed by training. But if you ain't got it, I'm not sure training can change that. I've seen too many people in a variety of fields (e.g. architecture, visual arts, music, writing, engineering, software design, even landscaping) who with education were quite competent but frankly were stilted and inflexible when faced with creating something new.

A recent example reminded me of this - an expert pianist told me that although she could play almost anything set before her she was unable to improvise even very simple things. But it was so easy for me to write out some "improv" she needed for one performance. She said she noticed this in her students - some were always making up things but others couldn't stray from the written music, no way, no how.

I see the same in wood. I once did a lathe demo for a group and afterward one gentleman wanted to borrow some of my pieces to take home and copy. Although he did great work on the lathe and could probably make a beautiful copy of anything, he said that after years he realized he was simply incapable of coming up with his own designs.

JKJ

Re: Up For Discussion*

#17

Re: Up For Discussion*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Spent the first twenty adult years building with lumber yard stuff. If it did not fit, change it until it did. I spent ten years as a 2-D CAD person at work, this did not change 99% of WWork.Now that I mostly turn, the individual piece of wood often dictates the design.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#18

Re: Up For Discussion*

FredD

"For those that build either by altering an existing plan (putting your own spin on it) or their own custom design, did you learn design before woodworking? If so, do you think it's made you a better woodworker? If not, do you think it's made you a better woodworker?"

What a question Dave... here goes

I would say for me that the design comes before the execution of it if I am talking about my career as a Carpenter , Cabinet Maker and Builder.

While I was never a Architect or Registered Building designer I developed the plans for many a Kitchen , Room addition , and so on , which always entailed conforming to Code requirements, Property lines and like that.

Approval and execution of these plans or designs were always subject to review and inspection of a Code Authority.

After thousands of hours looking at Architect generated floor plans, Structural detail and Elevations, I became proficient at seeing the finished product in my mind, rooms, walls, roof lines , furniture placement etc. before any ground was broke .

This enabled me to make a highly accurate cost analysis of the project if I was bidding on it.

How all of that translates into what most do here , I guess its like Music.

Composers write it , Arrangers interpret it and Musicians play it.

Some can do all three and some can't. But the final approval comes from the audience.

A very good question that probably is a slippery slope for definitive answers.

FredD

Re: Up For Discussion*

#19

Re: Up For Discussion*

Carol Reed

My ww abilities took a quantum leap when I took an art composition class. And I took it for the purpose to learn the elements of design. How shapes and color go together or clash is elementary if you plan to design.

I have never been one to faithfully follow plans. Now I hardly even look them. That one class gave me the courage to turn the designer in me loose.

Then comes the fun part - figuring out how to build what I have designed!

Re: Up For Discussion*

#20

Re: Up For Discussion*

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I can honestly say that from the very first woodworking project I ever built until now, I have never worked from a plan or from somebody else's design. Why? I have no idea other than my stubborn independence when it comes to design.

So where did I learn to design? My first college degree was in Fine Art and design. In addition, I have had a long interested in furniture and I have studied it.

While fine art is not a common approach in woodworking I feel it has helped me immemnsely for designing furniture with less traditional forms. I think most any field of design can benefit from a good understanding of the basic elements of good design. Form, balance, contrast, texture etc. are not only important in art but in furniture as well. I use those tools with everything I design.

Tom

Re: Up For Discussion*

#21

Re: Up For Discussion*

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

I don't know that I ever learned either design or woodworking! ;-) But I suppose I did. My Dad was a carpenter, and even as a youngster he was teaching me to look at what needed to be done, and then use my brain and skills to meet that need. Almost everything I have built has been as a result of having a need, and then building to meet that need. So designing to meet a specific need was the first step in the process. Even when I have built furniture pieces on a particular design, I have always built it to my specifications rather than to any plan. And because of how my Dad did things, my plan is most generally a rough drawing on a plain piece of paper, just so I can remember what dimensions I wanted.

Re: Up For Discussion*

#22

Great Responses - - My Conclusion

David Yoho

Thanks to everyone for their input. It confirms what I suspected, which is that we all have a sense of what looks good and work from that. However, Carol and Tom really hit on where my thinking centered and I think it does make a difference in the end.

Case in Point - my younger son just graduated from college in December with a degree in Fine Art. When he first started school he had the raw talent for graphic design. Throughout his four years he learned much about the elements of good design. I believe this is what turned his natural talent into the finely honed tool he now uses. The difference shows in the work he did before and now.

So, while I think many of us do well with our natural ability, as pointed out in Carol's and Tom's responses I think at the very least having some type of formal training in basic design takes things to a whole new level.

The funny thing is that I used to think that finishing was the elusive skill I would be forever chasing but nowadays I'm realizing it's more about design skills! :\

David