Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Dissolving Mineral Oil

Posts

Dissolving Mineral Oil

#1

Dissolving Mineral Oil

Stephen

Want to find substances, other than turpentine, to dissolve mineral oil. We have old Edison battery plates that are crusted with mineral oi. We used turpentine, which does the job, but want to find other substances to use instead.

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

Clint Searl

It's a petroleum product, so it should be soluble in any lighter distillate: gasoline, kerosene, naptha, mineral spirits, etc. Rinse the plates with cheap mineral spirits then wash them in soapy dish washer detergent.

Clint

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#3

you could try isopropyl

John in NM

Strongest you can find. I've been using it to remove old cutting oil scum (I think it was a vegitable oil of some kind) from machine tools at work.

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#4

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

Stephen

Which is the least toxic? Which dries the quickest?

We are cleaning old Edison Nickel-Iron battery plates and will boil with glycerin to remove any residue.

Thanks for your quick response, Stephen

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#5

Clint Searl

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

Clint Searl

Naptha is what I'd probably go with.

Clint

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#6

Re: you could try isopropyl

Bill Howatt

Yes, it may well be vegetable based and it is referred to as soluble oil since it can be mixed with water and this is why the alcohol will act upon it. Mineral oil is petroleum based and I don't think alcohol will work as well. There is a simple way to find out.

BIll

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#7

That could be it...

John in NM

I've also had it take paint off of some machines - but they're Chinese and could easily have a soy oil based paint.

I do remember my old model paints used ethanol as thinner, but it didn't work too well on dried paint. Once dad turned my on to mineral spirits I never could figure out why they used alcohol. Had to be denatured, selling to minors and all, so it couldn't be safety.... go figure.

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#8

Re: you could try isopropyl

Stephen

Tried Isopropyl and does not work. Paint thinner works well. Do you know which solvent, mineral spirits, paint thinner or naphtha, is the least toxic?

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#9

Re: you could try isopropyl

Dan Donaldson

We have a couple of chemists here that probably will give the correct answer, but I am fairly sure that they are fairly equivalent. In fact, they could sometimes be the same thing under different names. You can look up the msds for each of them to see what health concerns they list.

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#10

Re: you could try isopropyl

Bill Howatt

You need to interpret the MSDS sheets as was suggested.

Paint thinner is very often mineral spirits. Naptha is much more volatile and will evaporate more quickly. It has been called white gas. However, from reading a different (non-WW) forum that has a large international audience, the terms can mean very different things to different people, especially in other parts of the world.

Bill

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#11

Toxic

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

None of it is good to drink :b You should limit skin contact and use with ventilation, however naptha will evaporate far faster. Neither one will leave a residue, but washing with soap and water will remove any traces.

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#12

Toxicity is relative...

John in NM

Especially relative to what you are willing to tolerate. As Mark says, none of the solvents mentioned are anything you want to drink, and for a real answer you should locate and read MSDS sheets for each. Anything else is just going to be someone's interpretation which may or may not be accurate.

Personally, I do not find any of them to be overly hazardous, I use them and some others like alcohols and turpentine with ventilation and a wash of hands afterwards. Skin irritation from loss of oils is the biggest nuisance with these. IIRC, turpentine is considered more hazardous than mineral spirits or naptha, even though it is widely viewed as more "green" being a plant by product.

I used to find pumping gasoline to be worse than using any of these solvents, as even a very brief exposure would give me a headache. I haven't noticed that in years though, perhaps due to better technology for containing fumes and avoiding spills, perhaps due to formulation changes. I still detest the odor though, and will go to greater lengths to avoid exposure to gasoline than say mineral spirits, regardless of which may be more toxic.

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#13

Thank you!

Stephen

This is a wonderful website. You all provided me with good answers. I'm not a woodworker and stumbled upon this dynamic group of exchangers. I build Nickel-Iron batteries for off the grid owners and those concerned with saving energy. Hopefully some of my customers will want some wood crafted items and I will link your site.

Nice to read your comments on this and other threads.

Stephen

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#14

Stephen, could you help me?

Barry Irby

You mentioned building batteries for your Off Grid customers.

I am interested in more information about energy conservation and Solar water heaters and Photovoltaics.

I have done a little searching on line, but it is hard to get past the advertising and the sites that appear to be run by someone that to me appears to be a fanatic with all the answers. Except that they don't have much in the way of answers.

So, can you point me to a primer on photovoltaics and perhaps good basic info on related topics?

Re: Dissolving Mineral Oil

#15

naptha,m.spirits,toluene,xylene,gasoline

bill tindall

gasoline will be cheapest, but most flammable