Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT Car Questions

Posts

OT Car Questions

#1

OT Car Questions

Barry Irby

Am I the only one who does not want a car that can park itself?

The idea that I am stepping on a gas peddle that is really a switch that is telling the computer that i would like some more gas is pretty scary. The steering wheel is really just telling the computer that I would like to go to the right. So, now the computer actually controls the gas, the brakes and the steering. Not just in the power assist mode, but can actually steer. Suppose HAL shows up and decides I really need to go to Kansas Or it wants to go back to Dearborn or Yokohama or where ever it was born and in a real hurry?

Maybe I am turning into an old fuddy duddy but I am considering taking the elephant gun with me in case I have to shoot the engine.

Re: OT Car Questions

#2

Re: OT Car Questions

Dan Donaldson

Just make sure it is not running Windows as the OS. A BSOD would not be too much fun driving down the road at 70. ;)

Re: OT Car Questions

#3

Re: OT Car Questions

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Barry,

I prided myself on my ability to park by eye. I had several big Ford/Merc Wagons and Vans and never made contact with other cars while parking/squeezing into a small space. Up until a couple months ago I had an old '93 Mazda Pick-up with four highly visable bounderies.

That was then.

My wife's Honda is very hard to park because I can't see where her car ends and the next car begins. My new car is even more obstinate at revealing its rear end limitations in a parallel park situation. I'd welcome a device which would let me park with confidence.

George


Re: OT Car Questions

#4

Re: OT Car Questions

Dave (PacNW)

If you get stopped for speeding, is "the computer did it!" a a realistic defense?

Re: OT Car Questions

#5

There was a story in today's paper

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

about a guy who was charged with manslaughter and found guilty after his Toyota rammed someone on a freeway onramp. He asserted that he had his foot on the brake but the car kept accelerating. The DA is reopening the case after the recent information on Toyota's problems. So, yes, it sounds like it may be a defense.

The old mechanical connections had their problems, too; but their workings are more obvious and intuitive, and it's usually easier to see when there's a problem.

Re: OT Car Questions

#6

In my opinion

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I sure wouldn't pay for that option. I was taught how to parallel park and had to practice it to pass my drivers test. The test they administer to day is basically a written test right from the book and a short drive through town. You rarely hear of anyone not passing. Driving is taught by parents, not professionals, so the lack of skills and bad habits gets passed along. What used to be common rules of the road aren't taught and aren't practiced by the majority of new drivers so we see progressively worse driving.

If you want to see something scary go to a busy intersection when the power has failed and see what drivers do as they come up to the non-functioning light. It is complete chaos since the majority don't know that you are supposed to stop and then go when the way is clear or how to let cars proceed who arrived at the intersection at the smae time or ahead of you.

Lee

Re: OT Car Questions

#7

it's like that for airplanes

Chris Friesen

Most airplanes are flown by computers now (although there are usually more than one).

I don't care about automated parking, but the computers in cars are pretty much required in order to meet the emissions controls, fuel economy, etc. as well as enabling traction control and such. You start getting into the higher-end vehicles and they do things like computerized dry clutches that can shift far faster than any human.

Re: OT Car Questions

#8

That's why I drive a '91 Suburban

Phil Joines

Re: OT Car Questions

#9

Re: it's like that for airplanes

Dan Donaldson

I used to design that stuff and what you said is basically true. There is a bit of difference between that and having no mechanical connection between the steering wheel or the brakes and the car.

Re: OT Car Questions

#10

Re: OT Car Questions

AZ in Colorado Springs

We had a van that would accellerate for a moment when you stepped on the brake pedal. It turned out to be a bad relay. Fortunately it was not an outrageous "behavior" and did not cause any accidents before we got it to a shop.

Many airplanes are "fly by wire" as was stated (I couldn't imagine trying to pull a control cable twice the length of a 747), but they also have a rigorous maintenance and inspection schedule that most airlines adhere to. Many of the cars on the road haven't been to a mechanic in ages.

Re: OT Car Questions

#11

Re: OT Car Questions

John in NM

I don't want that either! I'd been considering replacing my two old vehicles, the younger is now sneaking up on 200K and they're both showing the wear. But the '87 Toyota pickup still has a carb, and both have relatively simple computers that have never given a hint of trouble.

Ironically, I would replace the pickup with a newer used one, but whenever I check there are no used Toyota trucks older than 2003 or so for sale within 500 miles.

I may even have to hang on to the horrible old truck (1975 D500 flatbed) - another with a carb that is positively sexy if you like that sort of thing.

Re: OT Car Questions

#12

Darn, just when I'd made up my mind!

John in NM

Now I kinda like the idea of computer controlled accelerators....

nah..... not worth it even to get out of a ticket or two :D

I'm surprised that braking wouldn't override the accelerator in the computer, even after the fact, I don't think its at all unreasonable to expect the programmer to think of that, kind of obvious like not dividing by zero!

Re: OT Car Questions

#13

Re: OT Car Questions

John McGaw

I love to drive. That is why I've had a Mazda Miata since 1991. But given the lack of skills and outright stupidity of many (sometimes most) of the other drivers on the road it would probably be better to have even a defective computer in control of the cars. At least the computer can be programmed to understand the rules of the road, won't talk on the cellphone while applying makeup, eating lunch, and reading paperwork while behind the wheel.

Within weeks after buying my latest Miata I was almost run off the road on the interstate in West Virginia by an Ichabod Crane-lookalike with a soup bowl haircut who was reading the bible while careening wildly across the lanes in a beat up minivan. Give me a computer any day. I understand computers. I don't understand idiots.

Re: OT Car Questions

#14

Not Steer by wire

davhamm

I don't think any mass produced cars are steer by wire.......yet...

Re: OT Car Questions

#15

Question

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

What does "steer by wire" mean? I thought it meant, literally, steering by wires connected to the rudder, wheels, control surfaces, etc. I understood that computer controlled was called "electronic control".

Re: OT Car Questions

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Question

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Fly-by-wire, steer-by-wire, drive-by-wire, etc. all mean that the physical input on the controls of the driver/pilot does not directly affect the throttle, ailerons, rudders, steering and so on. It is merely a "suggestion" to the computer, which then moves the control surfaces according to all inputs, often with safety parameters applied (particularly on jets) to keep the pilot from doing something immediately harmful to himself or the jet.

Like davhamm said above, I don't think there are any mass-produced, wheeled vehicles that have true steer-by-wire, even those that have the capability to park themselves. I believe that feature is simply a servo motor that piggybacks onto the steering column or in the steering gearbox. Many also have variable magnetic (I think) dampeners that change the steering feel according to speed, so that it's harder to make large adjustments at higher speeds (a good thing, IMO).

Jason

Re: OT Car Questions

#17

Re: OT Car Questions

Alexander Grigoriev

George,

One can install a rearview camera, though the installation might be expensive.

Or just drive different style of car.

Re: OT Car Questions

#18

Re: There was a story in today's paper

Alexander Grigoriev

His was 98 Camry, which could have cruise control problems. Even though those have old mechanical throttle control, the cruise control motor overrides the pedal.

Re: OT Car Questions

#20

Re: OT Car Questions

john lucas

Barry I'm just completely fed up with all the electronic BS in the new cars. Their fine when they work but you can't find people to repair them successfully. The expense is rediculous and you can't repair the stuff yourself. They have priced new cars completely out of my reach. I don't need electronic door locks. A key works just fine. I sure as hell don't need a car that parks itself.

Re: OT Car Questions

#21

Re: OT Car Questions

Barry Irby

Well they may not be fly by wire Robert, but they (At least two) do have something that can steer the car. Mercedes advertises it has lane avoidance or some such thing that can keep you in your lane and somebody else has a car that parks itself. Thus, It must be able to turn the wheel.

Somehow there is a difference between "power assist" that multiplies the force you put on the brake or the steering and something that applies the brake on command from the computer.

Many cars now have some sort of "black box" that they can pull out and read to tell some information about what was going on. I don't think it records more than a minute or two of information, unlike the ones on planes that records about half an hour or more. The thing that bothers me about this is it has been used against people. They have pulled them out of wrecks and said, "Aha, you were speeding". I have never heard of a case where anyone has used it to defend themselves. Part of the problem is that the driver has no control over the box. Lets say you get a speeding ticket. If you drive away after receiving the ticket, the data would be overwritten by the next minute and you would have no way to prove that you really were going 50 and the exact moment the cop said you were going 70 or what ever. I wonder if that guy that is in jail for ramming someone with his Toyota wishes they would have read his black box? If he really did have his feet on the brake, he might be a free man today. Of course, if the computer is willing to apply the gas when you say brake, it probably would lie to the recorder too. Some how, If I can not be compelled to testify against myself, I want the car I paid for to not testify against me either, especially if it will never testify for me.

This is getting to be too much like driving a video game, for real.

Re: OT Car Questions

#22

Jesper, Denmark

No, Barry, you are not, but.....

Jesper, Denmark

Modern vehicles do not work without the computers installed. I am 5000 miles into a new Skoda Yeti - nearest equivalent in USA would be A VW Tiguan.

Steering and brakes are directly mechanical with some very complex servo assists, which handle various situations. Park assist is an option, where the vehicle itself finds a suitable space between two parked cars and then handles the steering and tells the driver when to go forward and when to reverse. Dustance to hard objects is with sensors in front and rear bumpers.

I did not choose this option, but the sensors would have helped, as the rear window is too high to see the front of the car behind.

The other electronics do work extremely well so far. The engine is quite complicated diesel, witch turbocharger, intercooler, EGR and Diesel Particle filter. All electronically controlled to provide excellent power (170 HP from 2.0 liters, 4 cyl, twin overhead cams, piezo electric injectors @30,000 psig) while at the same time providing excellent fuel mileage at 40 mpg.

Full time 4WD with Haldex 4 contrlling the front - rear split and electronically controlled limited slip rear. Speed sensors on each wheel manages the ESP and ABS and several other acronyms, including hill hold and downhill descent control.

So far everything works as advertized - and then some. This relatively small vehicle is as well behaved in some very different circumstances as any other car I have ever owned. Stable at high speed - 90+ mph on expressways is OK here, handy in the mountains here in Andalucia with some hairraisingly narrow and twisty roads, very capable in snow with the right tires, but really not an off-roader.

Without car computers and finite element design tools, this would not be possible.

Re: OT Car Questions

#23

braking shouldn't always override

Chris Friesen

There are various circumstances where you might want to use the brake and accelerator pedal at the same time...heel-and-toe or left-foot-braking are two of them. Generally they're more advanced techniques that most people will never use though.

Re: OT Car Questions

#24

As you say...

John in NM

The average person will not need the ability to use both at once. One of the supposed advantages of software implimentation is that it should be easy to provide specialized versions for specialized applications.

For what its worth, I've absolutely never needed to apply the brake and gas at the same time. But then I've mostly driven vehicles with standard transmissions, so such situations would come up even more rarely.

Re: OT Car Questions

#25

Re: OT Car Questions

jerry roberts

A few years ago my wife and I leased a Lincoln to drive to a funeral in Maryland from Florida . The Lincoln was the only car the agency had left > normally drive a Honda. That Lincoln has more options than one can imagine. Unknowing to me, one option was bringing the gas pedal up even with the brake pedal. Wow, what a mistake that was! Im the kind of guy that drives with one foot. The right one.. It operates the gas and the brake. The left one just goes along for the ride. A couple times when i went to stop I didnt know it but the foot went part way on the gas and part on the brake. Only about and inch seperates the two pedals. The harder I pushed to stop the faster it went.. I did stop but just barely. I can certainly understand when I hear of older people running into buildings and such. What a dumb option for a car but I guess its for people that drive with two feet.