Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Repair & finish antique panels

Posts

Repair & finish antique panels

#1

Repair & finish antique panels

SlashDev

A local Amish cabinet shop called me for advice this week. They've done some work for me in the past and know I might be familiar with "the old ways..." :D Their client has purchased three antique carved panels (ca. 1860) to be installed with new trim in a Great Room:


A fourth panel is needed, so they purchased some "reclaimed" oak (more on that later...) and found a local carver. They would like some advice on finishing the new panel so it looks like the old panel. A common request, no? Of course, I am reluctant to mess with what appears to be a fine French Wall Panel (Boiserie) without asking around... Help!

First, if I had to reproduce one of these, I'd want to start with the same wood. I'm guessing that it's Brown Oak, quercus robur, from the color and the thickness of the growth rings (3/32" to 1/8" strong). Although "French" Brown Oak might seem like the obvious choice, it supposedly has more defects than I see in this panel (i.e., more knots, pips and checks)... I'd probably order some "English" Brown Oak, also quercus robur.

It has been suggested to me that rift-sawn would be a better choice so that the QS ray fleck does not interfere visually with the carving. That's probably why the frame was QS but the panel is RS.

Now back to the wood they bought: The shop located some "reclaimed" QSWO and shelled out some bucks, but when it arrived, it looked like reg'lar ole QSWO. No nail holes, no stains... just rough lumber. Maybe a little greyer than usual. After a few phone calls, the supplier said it was harvested from "old standing timber," whatever the heck that is. Sounds like a dead oak tree that hadn't fallen over and rotted yet. :/ I told them to get their money back (less shipping, probably) and order the right stuff. He only needs about 20BF for a 22"x85" finished size.

These panels are not a "centerpiece," so the finish should be similar, or at least not "clash" with the rest of the trim. Here's a color sample for the new trim:


I think it's a water-based satin finish with a white glaze. There are three "amounts" of the glaze: a little, a lot, and some (left-to-right). ;) The client has chosen "some." So....

Question 1: Is Brown Oak the way to go, or will they be able to match the QSWO to the old panels and the new trim color?

Perhaps not as important, but I'm curious...

Question 2: what would the original finish would have been?

In 1860, I'm guessing that it might have been shellaced and waxed. BLO, too? I can find no evidence of paint in any of the carving crevices. I think you can see a little white filler left in the pores:


...if you can ignore the glaringly new patch, that is... ;) Perhaps evidence of french polishing? Here's another patch, but I think it's original and was used to increase the height of the acanthus rib:


The second issue is the 1/4" split in the panel. Here's the back:


There are two tapered & dovetailed battens let in to a matching dado. I assumed that only the center was glued, but after examing the panel at the ends of the batten...


...I think it was designed to split. >( After the batten was driven in, the ends were sawed off at the panel edges. Then a 1/4" strip was glued to the edge of the panel, covering the ends of the batten. Why?!? Obviously, the panel shrank, and the batten pushed against the strip, splitting the panel. So....

Question 3: Should the split be repaired, and if so, how?

It has been suggested that I cut the 1/4" strip to free the batten and then squeeze the panel back together.

If that doesn't work, I could use a handsaw to cut the batten through the split, separating the panel into two pieces. Then I'd joint new edges, including across the embedded batten ends. Next I'd use a hide glue rub joint to reassemble the panel. After it dries, I'd route a 6"-long dado or two in the batten and insert a strip (or two) to reinforce the edge joint in the batten.

Any other ideas? Other concerns?

Boy, that was a long one. Thanks for your help!

/dev

Re: Repair & finish antique panels

#2

Ellis Walentine

Some answers

Ellis Walentine

1. Brown oak lumber, whether from the UK or the European continent, is going to be unpredictable in appearance. If you are trying to match an existing panel, you may have to select your lumber personally if you want something similar. And, I wouldn't try matching American white oak to the antique European oak. The color and texture just won't be the same, especially if you're using quartersawn stock.

2. Doors from that time period may have been finished with some kind of spirit varnish -- a mixture of a solvent and one or more resins. I'm not an expert on this so I won't speculate further.

3. Whether to "fix" splits and other damage may depend on how much the doors are worth and whether their value will be diminished by such repairs. Some antiques, such as lowboys and other case pieces of the 18th and 19th centuries, were joined with seeming disregard for expansion and contraction, and the solid board sides often split because of it. The end user and/or the architect in charge of the project should have the final say on repair work, as they are the interested parties here.

FWIW, we have a pair of French doors from the 1700s that are made of brown oak and richly detailed (although not with the type of relief carving you've shown us, which is really quite nice, by the way). The panels on our doors are split in places, plus there's some powder post beetle damage on various parts of the doors, as well as splinters missing -- not to mention that the doors aren't exactly flat anymore. We've never done anything to them, not even refinishing. In our case, the doors are in an upstairs bedroom where they are not focal points of the house. Your customers will probably want to put a nice rich finish on their doors.

I'm sorta grasping at straws here. Maybe a bona fide expert will weigh in. Nice post, by the way. Excellent questions.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Repair & finish antique panels

#3

Some thoughts

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

Excellent post. Plenty of info on the situation. I can�t answer all you questions, unfortunately. Here are a few thoughts ...

Re repairing the crack, I�d leave it up to the client. If it were mine, I�d leave the crack. Your plan for fixing the crack is good.

Re color of new panel, first I would find out if the old panels are to be left as-is or recoated. I think a coat of paste wax on the old panels, perhaps preceded by a minimum of cleaning, would look good. But again, the client should be consulted.

Re: Repair & finish antique panels

#4

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Repair & finish antique panels

Stephen Shepherd

Slash,

In answer to your first question, if you can't get English Brown Oak then substitute American White Oak. You will need to stain it in at least a couple of coats. Stain it Yellow first, then allow to dry then over stain or glaze with burnt umber and finish with shellac. You can also stain the repairs first with yellow then umber. It takes multiple coats to build up the old colors.

Your second question, the answer is probably pigmented varnish either spirit or oil based, all of which is missing. Common method of finishing woodwork in the time period.

In answer of your third question, you should make the repair and of course use hide glue. If you have any further questions please feel free to send me an email or respond here.

Stephen