Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Question on curved parts....

Posts

Question on curved parts....

#1

Question on curved parts....

Barry Irby

Thinking of making a bed for my son. Considering a head board with lots of curved "pickets" (?). Sort of a cross between mission style and a sleigh bed.

If you wanted about forty pieces that were about 3/4' x 3/4" and curved in one direction, would you saw them out of flat stock or would you laminate then out of about three or four layers?

I'm thinking walnut, because I have it.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#2

Laminate...

John in NM

I usually buy thick veneer for this sort of thing and laminate with plastic resin glue. I'd probably do a wide piece and rip it to make several slats. If you have to saw the layers, it'd probably be a lot easier to just cut out the curves instead.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#3

Re: Question on curved parts....

mdclor

Barry,

I have never done this so take it for what its worth! :\

I think I would laminate them because sanding out all the band saw marks would drive me to distraction even if I had an oscillating spindle sander. Even if you could gang them together, it would still be tedious. Of course, you might be able to make a pattern and smooth the rough edges on your router table, but they would still need to be sanded and I hate sanding..... You should also consider making a few extra spindles in case Murphy intervenes. :D

Good luck and post pics.

Merle

Re: Question on curved parts....

#4

Re: Question on curved parts....

Dave Paine

I have been practicing for my own project which is a curved front display cabinet. I need to replicate an original piece, which is in dire shape.

I do not want to build a steamer, so have been trying laminate vs cut from stock.

Laminate will work, but you have to allow for some spring back. The thinner the laminates, the less the spring back.

I also cut the curve on the bandsaw. Getting the cut piece to be smooth is the challenge. I would not attempt to sand. Too time consuming. I would spend the time to construct a template and then use a pattern bit of whatever length is needed to get "closer" to final shape. For my curve, I get smooth with the grain, but last portion is against the grain so would need finish sanding after this operation.

If yield was not a concern, I would make from laminates. Cutting thin strips does waste a lot of wood.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#5

Re: Question on curved parts....

Grant in Iowa

I'd laminate them up of resawn 1/8" layers (or thinner/ thicker depending on amount of bend).

I'd make the layers as wide as I could determined by stock and or resaw capabilities. Glue them up on a jig and after they are dry joint one side and use the table saw to rip them to width. Might rip them a bit wider than needed and plane or drum sand to final width for best finish.

I know you followed the vacuum pressing info a few weeks ago, that'd be my #1 choice, but lacking that I'd make a jig up and simply clamp them. Might be able to make a rigid pink styrofoam male and female jig with 3/4" plywood backing and clamp them to dry. Another option is how Ellis has explained using layers of thin Masonite as cauls over a single form to allow even clamping pressure.

If not vacuum pressing, you might want to keep the blanks maybe 4" wide or less to ensure an even bond and tight glue lines.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Question on curved parts....

#6

JL

Is it air-dried?

JL

I have successfully steam bent many a piece of air-dried walnut (and other woods). The big disadvantage is you have to have a LOT of forms. The nice thing is - no visible lines. You could easily do 10-20 at one go - just stagger your entry times. You want about 1 hour an inch for air-dried - maybe a little longer. You'd need a couple of weeks to dry out the wood.

To laminate your 3/4" piece without much spring back, you would need at least 6 (preferably 8) layers. That is a lot of pieces of lumber to keep track off if you want to sort of keep the same grain. You would need a few forms - but you don't have to worry about drying beyond a day or two. You would have to get rid of the glue lines.

Either way should work well. Have fun.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#7

Band saw and template route to clean them up

Phil Joines

Make the templates, two, one for the front and one the back from MDF etc. with the piece on top held by some toggle clamps. Fast and with a good, sharp bit not much sanding.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#8

Re: Question on curved parts....

John McGaw

For that many pieces with that small of a cross section I would certainly consider steam bending before any other alternative. Bandsawing from solid stock would be my last solution given that any serious bend would inevitably yield weakened parts. Guess that leaves laminated glueup as the middle way. If you can make or get access to even a simple steam rig you should be able to bend walnut of that size with no more than an hour of heat and and then an hour in the form. Multiple forms would be simple to make mounted on a single piece of plywood so that you could bend as many pieces as you could steam at one time.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#9

Re: Question on curved parts....

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Evening Barry,

I resaw thicker stock, run it thru my planer over an auxiliary planer bed to remove saw marks, then glue the laminate up over a form using many clamps. I've also band sawed thicker stock to the desired profile, but that is a lot of waste. I've used Titebond II, and it has worked out fine.

George

Re: Question on curved parts....

#10

Every answer generates a question

Barry Irby

I question sawing them out because of the issue of grain. My son and his wife want to lean back on the head board and want it to be comfortable. I am concerned that thin sawn pickets might break, they are concerned about comfort.

Can you steam been that many pieces and have them match nearly perfectly?

I have been reading the Joe Woodworker site about vacuum pressing. what an overwhelming amount of info. I have a pump and have been thinking about it for years, so I might choose that method as a good excuse to build the system. Any comments on vacuum systems would be appreciated. I have a Gast pump that moves about 1.1 CFM. Its old but essentially unused. The idea seems simple and complex at the same time. How about the venturi systems? Was considering using the venturi to quickly evacuate the bag and the little pump to hold it.

Part of the problem is I don't have a plan for the bed. Just a vague idea. King Size. Head board you can lean back on, little or no footboard. So I am trying to find a plan or style that suites the DIL but all I get from her is negative. "No... not that" What then? I don't exactly know. Trying to figure out WHAT and HOW at the same time is not productive.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#11

It reads like no matter what you do

Gary Smyth

it will not be appreciated. The DIL won't know what she wants until she sees it. And then if you spend the time to duplicate what she says she wants no matter how well it is done it will not match the image she had in the first place. Besides, when she does find what she wants, she wants it then--not later. In this instance I'd build a wood box and in it place a check. Let her find what she wants while you do something for someone who will appreciate and be more than satisfied with your effort.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#12

You may be right.....

Barry Irby

My son and I were going to build a bed together for him. Then he got married and got a job three hours away. He wants me to build them a bed as a wedding present but realizes it is she who controls the design. Both of us a gently pressing for some guidance.

Trying to figure out how when you don't know what is troubling.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#13

Do What I Did, Barry

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Barry,

You can imagine how often I've run up against the same considerations in my large family. I decided the best way to keep control of my own tranquility was to have them furnish me with a picture of the item they wanted me to male. Then I had a good idea of what design satisfied individual needs. All I had to do was think up how to do it. Worked for me every time. Good luck.

George

Re: Question on curved parts....

#14

Re: Do What I Did, Barry

Barry Irby

I have gently asked for a design or a picture three or four times. So far, nothing is forth coming. Until I have a good idea of what she wants, nothing will be forth coming from my end either.

Re: Question on curved parts....

#15

I'm doing just that right now

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I offered to make a piece of furniture for my son and his wife for their wedding present. They decided on a wine cabinet. We have gone through at least a half dozen iterations of every conceivable detail, and while it's driven me nuts, and I'm probably driving them nuts coming up with variations. It will give me a great peace of mind to know that what they ultimately get will be what they truly want. I do like George - give me a pic and I figure out how to make it.