Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

vertical movement in frame and panel?

Posts

vertical movement in frame and panel?

#1

vertical movement in frame and panel?

MARTIN

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi all, I Need some advise here.

I will build a frame and panel back for a dovetailed carcase cabinet. The frame and panel back will be glued into the carcase rabbet. The stiles will run the full height of the frame. To minimize stress on the carcase, I need to consider the overall seasonal movement of the f&p.

To minimize the overall F&P movement in width, I will use QS stiles no larger than 2 inch. That should keep the overall movement below 3/64 for maple.

Where I get puzzled, is for the vertical movement. Will there be any?

Since the stiles will run full height of the frame and I will use mortise and tenon joinery with no allowance for movement. Because there is no movement length wise for the stiles, I suspect that the joint with keep the vertical movement to nil.

The width of the rails will be about 2� for the top and 3 1/2 for the bottom Rail.

thanks for comments

Martin

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#2

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

With the dimensions you have gien I wouldn't worry about movement of the frame. The panel is the only concern. Make sure it can move, expand and contract properly in the frame and you should be fine.

T.

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#3

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

John McGaw

Wood actually does move along the grain with moisture changes but the effect is so small that you would be hard pressed to measure it. I've never seen any design which took lengthening into account. Cross-grain size changes are several orders of magnitude larger and they are what can cause the big problems Some woods are far worse than others in this regard.

Example: I've got a small kitchen table which has a 32X32 top made from two bookmatched sycamore boards. Concerned about warping I foolishly added breadboard ends to it. Now I find that for part of the year the table overhangs the end boards by nearly 1/4" at each edge; for part of the year the situation is reversed. I don't recall seeing them come out even since building the table.

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#4

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

charlie belden

G&G and Stickley solved your breadboard ends expansion and contraction issue - SPLINES - ebony splines. The part of the spline in the breadboard end rides in a slot in the breadboard end. The other end of the spline is glued in a slot in the sides of the table top at the joint.

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#5

Bread board end with splines

charlie belden


Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#6

Ellis Walentine

Question about your drawings

Ellis Walentine

Did you just happen to have those dwgs lying around, or did you comp them up for this one response? What program do you use? How long did it take you to make up that post?

Nice job, Charlie.

Ellis

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#7

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

John McGaw

I must admit that I never though of doing it that way. This is such a simple humble piece of furniture that proud ebony tongues sticking out seem excessive. But they would certainly serve the purpose of softening the results of the expansion and contraction.


img

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#8

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

AZ, Colorado Springs

This is a cool idea. I'm working this weekend on the lid for a blanket chest (the lid incorporates breadboard ends) and I think I'll use this. The drawing was really helpful. I re-read the first post several times and couldn't visualize it (I kept picturing a spline that would run in the place of the tenon).

Thanks

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#9

Re: Question about your drawings *LINK*

charlie belden

You're not going to believe it - but all my line drawing illustrations are done with an old Mac app called Aldus SuperPaint, the latest version of which is - wait for it - 1993.\

Aldus was an Adobe competitor - with SuperPaint going head to head with Illustrator - at a quarter the price - and far more intuitive to use. SO - Adobe bought Aldus - and shelved all their products.

Five years later, SuperPaint users approached Adobe asking that the now out of date and "obsolete" SuperPaint source code be made public domain in the open source world. Adobe's response "Send us a check for $10,000 and when the check clears we'll have our lawyers sit down with your lawyers to begin negotiating a licensing rights contract. That ended that.

Apparently, Adobe Illustrator will read SuperPaint files and can then operate on the objects in the file - incuding Text objects.

As to how I do the drawings - pretty much the way I learned to do Mechanical Drawings as a high school freshman.

Alas, Mac OS 10 won't run the SuperPaint software I've been using with all their previous OS, going back to OS7.6. So, while I've upgraded my other apps to new versions that'll run on Mac OSX, I've kept my old computer that still runs SuperPaint. With years of experience with SuperPaint I know it like the back of my hand and can practically make it talk.

I'm playing with SketchUp and could do the splined breadboard end illustration in a quarter of the time it took to do in SuperPaint - but adding annotation and colors, patterning etc. I still do in SuperPaint by bringing in a GIF image from SU.


SuperPaint Screen Shot

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

#10

Re: vertical movement in frame and panel?

charlie belden

Illustrations sure help convey ideas that's tricky to get acrossed with words.

As for the splines on the ends of the breadboard ends - nothing says they have to be ebony - they could be the same wood as the breadboard end and boards making up the table top. The advantage of using a very stabile wood is that they're less apt to bind in their slots.