There is a HUGE difference, but
Lee Grindinger
First, let's clear some things up, there are several true mahoganies and the street terms have blurred the distinctions. Honduras mahogany has come to mean Swietenia humilis (Honduras mahogany) and Sweitenia macrophylla (Bigleaf mahogany). It wasn't always so but for this discussion I'll point out that they are lumped together today.
There is a huge variation in the quality of mahogany that has nothing to do with the borders of countries. Honduras was a huge producer way back when so the wood became known as Honduras mahogany.
The best of these woods is grown in higher altitudes, up in the mountains where they grow more slowly and thus are more dense and heavier. Most of the information made available to woodworkers is drawn from samples of this higher altitude lumber. Honestly, the stuff sold today is crap compared to the timber harvested from the mountains a century ago.
I had the great good fortune to meet one of the leading taxonomists and restorers of period furniture in PA. He wouldn't even consider using today's mahogany due to it's low quality and actually went to auctions to buy antiques simply for their value as lumber, to be cannibalized as he restored truly valuable pieces.
Jon Arno, an old friend, used to cite mahogany stats such as specific gravity. He and I both agreed that new data should replace the old since that lumber is not around anymore. I digress.
So, growing conditions have everything to do with the lumber that lands on your bench. Slower is better, just as old growth timber is sought out in North American forests, old growth is the best of the tropical woods. Most of macrophylla now comes from Peru and Central America. I know Brazil exports no macrophylla now but I'm not sure about Honduras. You can be sure illegal logging goes on in those countries though.
The difference between the macrophylla of old and new is astounding, to the point where you'd question if it's the same wood. Newer is half or less the specific gravity of the old, it's very soft compared to the old as well.
Does that answer your question? 
Lee