WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Posts

Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#1

Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Barry

Does anyone know where I could get info on fluorescent lighting for a shop. I need to know how to determine number and spacing of fixtures to provide a certain number of foot candles. I would also appreciate info on different types of bulbs and fixtures.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#2

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Rick Haverstock

Hello Barry,

When I remodeled my shop (well actually created a new shop out of what was once a basement summer kitchen and stand-up wet bar) the one thing I really wanted was good lighting. There was an excellent article in Fine Woodworking that pretty much covered all your questions. I don't have the FWW collection handy or I'd dig it out for you. It's pretty easy to go to their website and search through their magazine index to find what I'm referring to.

Anyway, I ended up following almost all of the author's suggestions as to layout, using twin tube 40 watt fixtures and the result was a cleanly and evenly lit shop with little or no shadows to contend with. Since most of my tools are on mobile bases, I tend to move things around, especially when I'm working on a large project. Having dedicated task lighting over each machine just wouldn't cut it for me. Based on the author's recommendations, my 20-30 foot shop needed a minimum of twenty fixtures. I ended up buying some inexpensive Lithonia ones on sale at Home Depot and in the past 7 or 8 years all I've done is relamp and clean off the diffusors.

I'm sure that this will generate a lot of discussion as most people do not like the way fluorescents show color (and I agree)and some of the inexpensive fixtures with electronic ballasts tend to hum or buzz (mine don't).

Two other tips: paint the shop walls and ceiling white (semi-gloss is best) and you'll have the benefits of reflected light as well as the downlights from the fixtures. Wire the lighting separately from the tools if possible. If you pop a breaker while using machine it's a lot nicer to be able to see what you're doing while the machine spins down. Not as much fun as standing there in the dark, but I don't need the adrenaline rush in my old age. My wife, upon seeing the new lighting, said that it was bright enough to do brain surgery. Good luck !

Rick Haverstock

4 more inches of snow in Chicago

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#3

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Dan Donaldson

We got close to 7" here in MI. Need to figure out a way to put a snowplow on my Harley. ;)

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#4

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Barry

I have all the FWW mags. Do you remember about when the article appeared.

Thanks.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#5

your local lighting store

Bill Tindall

Go to your local lighting store. They will have a computer program to determine the information you need. You will be amazed how many lamps you need to get 200 ft cd at the bench top, an intensity good for detail work.

The reflectivity of the surrounding area is important. You want the walls, ceiling and floor to be reflective to reflect light back to the work area.

I have 12 4' lamps over my bench to get 200 ft. cd, but I have a dark gray floor, white walls.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#6

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

paul in AZ

I put in Daylight fluorescents [with white walls] when I built the shop. To my eye the colors of woods etc with those bulbs is so close to that in outdoor daylight that I am very happy. Nice lighting.

Outdoor daylight has a color temperature of ~5000k and in some instances higher than that. Most bulbs are now marked for color temperature. I suspect it is the color temperature of the old fashioned 'warm white' and 'cool white' that causes the criticism of fluorescents.

Seems to me that the daylight bulbs are no longer any more expensive than the old types.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#7

Re: FWW 154 Feb 2002 Shop Lighting

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#8

In my 30 x 55 shop

Forrest Addy

Here's my experience in my 30ft x 55ft shop:

I have 12 ft ceilings. I built the shop in 1994 before the R-8 fixtures came down in price. Then, 8 ft double tube fixtured dominated the market so that's what I went with. The lighting guy queried me on the space dimensions, activity, etc. and suggested three 8 ft fixtures in a row with each row on 8 ft centers meaning I have 6 rows. It's really too much light for most things but fortunately I switched alternate rows. I can have three rows on for most things but if I really need shadowless light I switch both banks. With light like that I can find a #8 set-screw hiding in sawdust on the floor.

Cheap glaring fluorescent tubes are their own punishment. I use 4000K tubes with a CR of 93. They're about twice as expensive as the 6000K daylight but not nearly as harsh and eye wearing. The light is gorgeous and well-suited for color critical work. Better than halogen in fact - at least, I think so.

My lighting system is a bit expensive to run. When both banks are on they draw 3.2 KVA. At present rates they cost about $0.30 per hour which adds up to maybe $50 a month of 8/5 operation. Modern T-8 fixtures with electronic ballasts are more economical to operate and they don't buzz (Grrrr!).

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#9

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

wilbur

Here's how I figured out my lighting needs.

1. My goal was 75-100 foot-candles of light at my workspace. This isn't as high as Bill's 200 foot-candles, but my plan was to add task lighting on top of the fluorescents for areas where I need detail lighting. My shop is 10'x20', or 200 square feet.

2. Multiply 75-100 foot-candles by 200 square feet gives me 15000-20000 lumens of light total in my shop.

3. Throw in some fudge factors to account for the distance from the fixture to the work surface and loss of efficiency over time due to dust and aging bulbs, and that essentially doubles to 30000-40000 lumens.

4. I wanted to use 4' "Natural Daylight" T-8 tubes which put out about 2200 lumens apiece, this means I'll need 13-19 fluorescent tubes in my shop, which works out to about 6-10 2 bulb fixtures.

As it turns out, because of how existing plumbing runs across the ceiling of my workshop, I could only put in five fixtures, and I wish I could have another three.

One other tip: spend the extra money and get fixtures that have the bulbs separated by about a foot or so, instead of the fixtures where the bulbs are right next to each other. Spacing apart the bulbs leads to more even light, and will make the room seem brighter. Plus, these fixtures have reflectors that will bounce the light downwards better.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#10

more info- intensity and color

Bill Tindall

Lighting is a complicated subject, as explained to me by my brother-in-law, a lighting engineer who worked for GE lamp division. I have an article in Articles Section that summarizes some of what you need to know. You don't need the same intensity of lighting everywhere, but the ability to see well in an area where detailed work is done is influenced by the light intensity elsewhere. And task lighting can compensate for inadequate light overall. Personally, because of the variety of detail work I do at the bench I found task lighting to boost my intensity inconvenient because I was always diddling with it to get it right for a task.

As far as color, and the perception thereof, there are dozens of lamps available that will replicate about any lighting situation you want. Home Depot will not have but a tiny fraction of what is available. So anyone that complains that the "color" of fluorescent light is unacceptable is probably ignorant of what can be had in fluorescent lamps. Not everyone prefers "daylight" lighting for all shop tasks so you could experiment with lamps with different color balance to see what is preferred.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#11

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Don Orr

I have been doing some research online about fluorescent lighting recently and found some good information on the tubes and fixtures but not really on placement.

In a nutshell-T8 tubes and fixtures use less energy and are as bright or brighter than the older T12 units. T8 uses an electronic balast that starts quickly and doesn't buzz. T8= 1" diameter, T12=1.5" diameter (#of 1/8's of an inch). I put a 4 tube T8 unit in our bathroom and it is a lot brighter than the old T12. I am going to replace all the old T12 units with new T8 units now. More efficient and more light is worth it to us.

We looked in Lowe's and found some inexpensive 2 tube T8 shop lights which my wife wants to put in her pottery studio. About $13 for the fixture and $7 for a pair of T8 tubes. You can get more expensive if you want to.

I have 5 2-tube T12 fixtures in my shop (fairly small) and they seem pretty good. I spread them out fairly evenly with emphasis on high use areas.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

Dick Hines

Dan I am looking for a set of chains that will fit a 250 tire.

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#13

;-)

Dan Donaldson

Re: Fluorescent Shop Lighting

#14

Not particularly tube lighting

Gary Smyth

As has been pointed out, lighting can get very technical. Light is measured in degrees Kelvin (K). Color temperature is measured on the Kelvin scale where the "cooler" the light, the higher the temperature (just the opposite of the Fahrenheit scale). Warm lights are below 3,100 K and cool lights are over 4,000 K; 3,500 K is considered neutral. Do not bother with why, but remember this, daylight standard is 5500 degrees Kelvin. Incandescent bulbs in home lamps are typically 3200 degrees Kelvin. You can get picky about light intensity at latitude, reflectivity of materials, transmittance of light through glass and plastic, and luminescence but keep whatever light you put in on the side of daylight (more blue than orange) and you will be happier. Some tests even have a correlation between daylight vs. artificial light and depression (daylight light reduces it). Also tube lighting pulses. For some people the unnoticable or barely noticable pulse/flicker can put them in a sort of trance. I would recommend that tube lighting not be the exclusive source for long duration critical work.

Architectural standards also recommend foot-candles for tasks. (Amount of light falling on an object at distance--you can get the definition elsewhere. There are foot candle meters available to help. There are lists in various references.

A few are: Operating room; 2000-2500fc, dental, at oral cavity; 1000 fc, detailed drafting and drawing, sewing; 200fc, inspection; 150fc, critical seeing, garages; 100fc, reading; 70fc. For areas, "shops" are listed as 100fc with additional local lighting as required. All of these values come from Time Saver Standards for Architectural Design Data. Two things tell what a light will look like when it's turned on. The color rendering index, or CRI, is measured on a scale of 1 to 100, where 100 represent how colors look in daylight. The higher the number, the more accurately the artificial light will render colors.

The other number measures color temperature (K).

Finally take a look at LEDs. The CRI white light they want to achieve is elusive, but they will last for 20000 hours, they don't fade over time and if you can find a deal and gang them in something to make a light I doubt that you will be disappointed.