Toilet Problem
Jeff
Hi all need some advice on a toilet problem.
Anyone here know alot or a good plumbing forum?
Jeff
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Toilet Problem
Jeff
Hi all need some advice on a toilet problem.
Anyone here know alot or a good plumbing forum?
Jeff
Re: Toilet Problem
Barry Irby
I know a thing or two as do others here. Ask away.
Re: Toilet Problem
DONinSTL
Try Terry Love's plumbing forums at terrylove.com/forums.
I Have Been Using One For Over 75 Years--
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
Re: Toilet Problem
DONinSTL
Try Terry Love's plumbing forums. It covers most plumbing subjects.
http://terrylove.com/forums/
Re: Toilet Problem
del schisler
i didn't see a question ask I am sure their are lot's of ANSWARE's here Ask and see what come's up
OK Barry, here goes...
Jeff
I use an American Standard one piece toilet, full flush, not a low flow.
I've cleaned the toilet, run a snake thru the pipe a few times, checked the fill height, and checked the small holes where the water enters the bowl.
Yet, when I flush, about half the time it works great, and the other half it doesnt get enough draw to empty fully.
The amount of waste and paper makes no differance.
This toilet has worked great for 20 years and started doing this a few years ago. So, that's when I cleaned and checked eveything.
Any ideas on what I should look for?
Jeff
Re: I Have Been Using One For Over 75 Years--
Howard Norman
I have been around for more than 75 years but the first nine years we had an outhouse.
Re: OK Barry, here goes...
Dan Donaldson
Have you checked the stack vent? If the vent is not clear, that can cause flushing problems.
ROFL ! . . .
steve mackay
I was snaking the roots in the front yard from inside the house (anual event around here) and, somehow, managed to send the darn thing up the vent stack. I actually ran outside and found the thing sticking out across the roof ! There was also a good sized wad of what was probably bird nest laying there. When I was done, low & behold, toilet and drains all seemed to work better. Go figure. I'd have never thunk anyone would build in there but . . .
Agreed
Nat Robison
My amateur plumber opinion is that it's a venting problem.....if you've eliminated everything else. I put these PVC grates in the end of my vent stacks.....basically eliminates anything bigger than a marble from getting in the pipe but doesn't impede airflow. Last winter, the toilet wasn't evacuating like it should. Turns out, snow was piled up on the grate and wasn't letting air in. I decided to only put the grates in once winter is over.
I don't know all the particulars of your area and problem but venting would be my first guess.
A few thoughts... kind of long
Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon
First try this test, get a bucket that holds about as much water as your tank, dump the water in the bowl quickly and and see if the toilet flushes that way consistantly. If it does the problem is in the tank and guts of the toilet (make sure after the bowl empties you add enough water to refill the bowl back to the normal water line). If the bowl empties inconcistently the problem is in outlet side of the toilet. Note this testing should be done through normal use and "products" juyst using water several times can be inconclusive. Here are some possibilties gleaned from few years in building maintenance and homeownership. Toilet empties with bucket:
A former spouse, thought she would conserve water (remember the brick int the toilet "craze") and put a plastic cider jug full of rocks in the tank. The glue on the plasticized label finally released and the label exited the tank and cover (intermittently) the hole that starts the "syphon jet" Intermittent coplete flushes, second problem same spouse, we were having problems with the flapper chain ,and she had the lid off while flushing. A clear plastic safety cover form some kind of bottle went down the hole in the tank, same results Toilet does not empty with bucket: You have a foreign object in the trap system, one that can be moved to the side by a snake or water flow, objects may include but not be limted to A. a Harry Potter doll B. A tooth brush C. Sunglasses D. A Credit card E. and my personal favorite, a camera. I wondered what they were taking pictures of. Every one of these fixes involved removing the toilet from the floor and using various tools to see up the trap way from the bottom or tank removal to see down from the top.
good luck
glc
Re: OK Barry, here goes...
Barry Irby
Ok, Follow the advice of the others. I certainly would check the vent and make sure it is not stopped up. In some climates it is cold enough for the vent stack to freeze itself shut. (Humid air going up the stack condenses, forms frost and eventually seals the pipe.) So, if your climate is really cold right now, that could be it. But you mentioned it has been happening for several years, so unless you are living in Antarctica it is unlikely it has been frozen all that time.
If you have other toilets and they are working well it is unlikely it is the main sewer line or the vent stack.
I have seen several toilets partially blocked by interesting things. One was a Juice Box. Had to remove the toilet to get it out.
In addition to what others have said there are two things I would check. Does the flapper open and "float" as it should during the flush? Does it flush better if you stand there and hold the handle down? If it is intermittent you might try shortening the chain a link or two to make it remain open reliably.
The other is to look at the 1/4" filler tube off the fill valve that should be putting water down the over flow pipe and into the bowl. I find many of these that have come loose or have been purposely redirected to dump the water into the tank. (People think the water is going down the drain and being wasted, thus they move it to save water.) The tube serves two purposes, Its a syphon break and it refills the bowl. The bowl usually has to have a fairly deep level of water in it to work correctly. This is the "Good flush/Bad Flush" effect. If the water level in the bowl is low when you flush, it fails to syphon as it should and leaves a lot of water (and stuff) in the bowl. Then you flush again and because the bowl is "full" it flushes well, but leaves the water level low, because the tube is dumping water in the tank, not into the bowl.
So, flush the toilet several times and watch. Does the flapper work as it should? Does the bowl empty and refill as it should? Does the bowl refill each time to a proper and consistent level? Is the fill tube properly positioned into the overflow tube?
Let us know if you figure this out and what it was.
Great ideas, now to start testing.
Jeff
Re: Agreed
FredD
Nat , get a couple of fittings and some pipe and glue a U-Turn on the top end of your vent , saves a lot of climbing up and down to put and take out the grates.
FredD