Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

one for the books

Posts

one for the books

#1

one for the books

FredD

>I have heard of Engineered Obsolescence, but this is ridiculous.

I have two Bosch 1617 routers ,one variable speed that I use exclusively for dovetails, one for pins and one for tails.

The last time I made some drawers (last month) when I turned them off after the last cut for each, they set unused for three weeks.

I tried to use one and then the other two weeks ago and they were both dead.

Got them back from Mid-Kansas Tool today and when I asked what was wrong , they said both switches had failed".

They too were amazed when I told them how I used them and they said ,

"must be a coincidence" ;-))

FredD

Re: one for the books

#2

Re: one for the books

Jim Shaver

>That is too bad, I think they are decent routers, I amn sure replacing the switches is not that much.... but then again, you never know.. sometimes the price is not worth the pain, I chased a bad choice once and it cost me thousands!!

Your's was just a switch, mine just sounded like one :)

LOL

What a waste of time that was!

Take care,

Jim

Re: one for the books

#3

Clint Searl

Re: one for the books

Clint Searl

>Had a similar experience with a PC router. Switch wire came loose.

Clint

Re: one for the books

#4

Re: one for the books

mdclor

>Fred,

I have also had a bad switch or a loose wire on a Bosch router. It was very frustrating because I had problems with 2 other Bosch tools the same day. :( I subsequently dumped a Bosch sander in favor of a Festool although I still have the router. It was just too much of a coincidence for me.

Good luck,

Merle

Re: one for the books

#5

Re: one for the books

FredD

>Merle, I started woodworking with Stanley routers and bits.

Then Bosch bought them and discontinued the cantilevered base Stanely which I always thought a neat design.

They kept the router bit fabrication line which is a premium bit .

I have no problem with staying with Bosch, I replaced some Stanley switches too.

I just thought two switches , same day same use , one year difference in the routers age was unusual to say the least and now you seem to have had a similar problem.

Maybe Bosch needs a new switch supplier.

FredD

Re: one for the books

#6

Re: one for the books

fred in ct

>I have that same router and I have to go to bat for Bosch. Mine had the magnesium base which was plagued by corrosion, I sent it back and they replaced it with the new aluminum base and I think they also replaced the switch at no cost. My only cost was shipping to send it back.

Re: one for the books

#7

Re: one for the books

Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey

>I, too, think it's ridiculous. I have found that the switch on my 1617 fails due to the well known dust problem regularly and surprsingly often. I bought a new switch from Bosch after reading that they finally began using new dust proof switches on the 1617, but the one they sent me was exactly the same as the old one. So now I just remove the clogged switch when it fails and replace it with the spare. I clean out the clogged one and put it aside until it's time to change it again. It's easy and pretty quick after you've done it a couple times. But sheesh, I never expected this when I shelled out the cash for an otherwise really nice router.