We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I just finished rabbiting 16 doors and was thereby reminded how much more fulfilling it is to work with machines than by hand. As I hefted the bit, a sold dense cylinder of pure carbide, I was reminded of the science and engineering that produced this marvel with a hardness of gems and a grain structure as fine as the best steel. I gingerly touched the edge. It made purchase with my skin revealing that it was sharp enough to cut baby-bottom smooth rabbits, no matter the grain. After mounting in the hefty 3 HP router I meticulously adjusted the fence to ensure a perfect cut. I tried the test cut. My digital micrometer told me that I needed to remove another 0.005" for the perfect fit. I loosened the fence and nudged it the required amount then secured the fence to the table. Now to get to work.
I started the dust collection, affixed my ear muffs and stepped on the foot switch. I was rewarded by the satisfying hum of the motor turning at its no-load speed of 18,000 rpm. I picked up the first walnut door panel. I could feel the silky smoothness the well tuned thickness planer with its M42 knives had left on its surface. Each grain orientation left its subtle impression on my finger tips. Secure against the fence I started the cut. At once I could hear the motor respond to the load as I slide the panel along the fence. Too fast and the motor informed me to slow it down; too slow and the sweet smell of hot walnut told me to speed up. How much better the bare walnut felt in my hand that the cold steel of a hand plane.
I could feel the grain changes as the panel slipped through my guiding hand but I had nothing to worry about as the sharp bit sliced gossamer shavings from the panel, no matter the orientation of the grain. This lack of stress only enhanced the enjoyment. These shavings disappeared up the dust collection hose, not under foot, just leaving behind the wonderful smell of freshly machined walnut.
I got to experience each panel as they passed by the spinning bit. Some were more dense, a result of faster growth, while others were light and had rings so close they hardly could be counted. Guided by the muffled hum of the tool I could feed the soft textured panels ever so slightly faster than the dense ones and the end grain still faster. Occasionally, I could detect the sound of a grain reversal and I responded by slowing the feed until the cutting was smooth again. I felt sorry for the hand tool user, the feel of cold steel in their hand and the beckoning wood dogged to the bench, out of touch.
All to soon the task was done. I had considered making two lighter cuts to prolong the experience. The length of this journey was only limited by the number of cuts I decided to make. Eventually I had to move on to the drudgery of hand scraping the panels and hand planing the frame joints flush- more cold steel in the hand and the warm wood out of reach on the bench.
In the end I was satisfied enough that for some parts of the project I got to hold the wood and not the steel, and with the dust collector I didn't need to clean up after.
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfy
Dan Donaldson
>Beautiful writing. I could not begin to write that well, so I modified it just a bit to reflect how it would go for me.
I just finished rabbiting 16 doors and was thereby reminded how much more fulfilling it is to work with machines than by hand. As I hefted the bit, a sold dense cylinder of pure carbide, I was reminded of the science and engineering that produced this marvel with a hardness of gems and a grain structure as fine as the best steel. I gingerly touched the edge. It made purchase with my skin revealing that it was sharp enough to cut baby-bottom smooth rabbits, no matter the grain and the amount of blood that I got from my finger was relatively minor and should not be too hard to get out of the wood. After mounting in the hefty 3 HP router I meticulously adjusted the fence to ensure a perfect cut. I tried the test cut and it didn't take too long to find the test piece from where it was thrown when it caught. After driving into town and getting new batteries, my digital micrometer told me that I needed to remove another 0.005" for the perfect fit. I loosened the fence and nudged it the required amount then secured the fence to the table. Now to get to work.
After a two hour hunt for the remote, I started the dust collection, affixed my ear muffs and stepped on the foot switch. I was rewarded by the satisfying hum of the motor as it blew the breaker. After I fixed the cord where it had been cut the last time I used the router, I plugged it back in and finally heard it turning at its no-load speed of 18,000 rpm. I picked up the first walnut door panel. I could feel the silky smoothness the well tuned thickness planer with its M42 knives had left on its surfaceand ignored the .040 snipe at each end and the tearout (but it was only in a few places). Each grain orientation left its subtle impression on my finger tips and I only got 3 splinters from the tearout from when I forgot and fed it in the wrong way, but they did not bleed much either.. Secure against the fence I started the cut. At once I could hear the motor respond to the load as I slide the panel along the fence until I realized that I had only tightened one side of the fence and the piece moved and was thrown across the shop. It only cut my finger a little, requiring just 6 stitches, now to find the part so I can remake it. Remade the part, fixed the fence and started again. It isn't really too hard to work with the big bandage on my hand from the hospital. If I tried to go too fast, the motor informed me to slow it down (the smoke coming out of the router helped also. It only caught fire twice); too slow and the sweet smell of hot walnut and the burning bit told me to speed up. How much better the bare walnut felt in my hand than the cold steel of a hand plane. Of course, by now, my hands were numb from the vibration and covered by the bandages, so I probably would not have noticed the cold too much.
I could feel the grain changes as the panel slipped through my guiding hand but I had nothing to worry about as the sharp bit sliced gossamer shavings from the panel, no matter the orientation of the grain.There was only a couple of inches of tearout on the ends, but that would not show too much.I wasn't feeling any stress after the 6 beers I drank to kill the pain and the residual anesthetic they injected to numb things. This lack of stress only enhanced the enjoyment. These shavings disappeared up the dust collection hose until the system plugged up and I had to take it apart and clean it out, and only 6 inches or so of the sawdust was under foot, just leaving behind the wonderful smell of freshly machined walnut, electrical fire and charcoal.
I got to experience each panel as they passed by the spinning bit. Some were more dense with a bit more tearout, a result of faster growth, while others were light and had rings so close they hardly could be counted until shredded by the bit. Guided by the muffled hum of the tool I could feed the soft textured panels ever so slightly faster than the dense ones and the end grain still faster. I only had 4 fires, but my extinguisher fixed them easily. Occasionally, I could detect the sound of a grain reversal and I responded by slowing the feed so it didn't throw too many splinters from the tearing until the cutting was smooth again. I felt sorry for the hand tool user, the feel of cold steel in their hand and the beckoning wood dogged to the bench, out of touch, and without the excitement of chasing parts across the shop, visiting the emergency room doctor and putting out the fires..
All to soon the task was done. I had considered making two lighter cuts to prolong the experience and only ruined 6 of the parts in the process. It took 2 hours to remake them, but that was a small price to pay for the enjoyment I was getting.. The length of this journey was only limited by the number of cuts I decided to make, which was cut short because I was running out of wood to make new parts. Eventually I had to move on to the drudgery of hand scraping the panels and hand planing the frame joints flush- more cold steel in the hand and the warm wood out of reach on the bench.
In the end I was satisfied enough that for some parts of the project I got to hold the wood and not the steel (and didn't get too much blood on it), and with the dust collector I didn't need to clean up after except for the minor problem I got when the bag overflowed and blew out emptying itself all over the shop. That was fine because it only took 3 hours to clean that up. Much better than sweeping up those shavings from the plane.
Ducking and running
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfy
charlie belden
>I take it this all occured durng daylight hours - or you don't have any neighbors very nearby.
Try that in a residential area of a city - any time after about 9:30 pm and 9:30 am and I suspect the experience would have been considerably different - and might include a conversation with a law enforcement officer - or a neighbor - carrying a baseball bat.
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
>One can justify one's power tool path with the same themes as the hand tool proponents. Thankfully we don't very often and I will resist ever again attempting it. ......now back to making stuff, an excellent suggestion for both camps, and those in between.
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
>Clearly power tool people have a sense of humor. BTW, I keep band aids on the shelf next to the router bits. I could document this fact with a picture if there is any doubt.
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
>And yes the pun is intended ! That is a wonderful essay on the joys of woodworking. Unfortunately, Dan's version is WAY closer to my skill level or lack thereof.
Thanks for the insight and the laugh !
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfy
charlie belden
>In keeping with FOX New's "Fair And Balanced" policy, the neander version of this sensitive and inspiring tale should include at least a few of the following:
As I watched the quilted maple handled Lie Nielsen bench chisel, sharpened to a scalpel's edge and polished to a mirror finish, roll to the edge of the bench
(pick either - or go with both)
I instinctively tried to catch it - before it hit the concrete floor . . . (followed by the stitches description)
or
and - hurl itself over the edge, landing on the concrete floor, chipping a corner of the cutting edge, bouncing and landing again chipping the other corner, then rolling under my 400 pound workbench where it came to rest in a pile of curlies. While feeling around in the spider web covered mass of curlies that had accumulated under the bench, my fingers encountered a creature that (pick one: a)bit me, b) stung me, c) gave off a horrible odor or d) all of the above).
The emergency room doctor said he'd never a) seen a black mamba bite before - but - fortunately had the anti venom b) was surprised at how elastic skin is and that he'd never seen a whole hand swell THAT much, but assured me the cortisone injection would stop the swelling before the skin tore.
While french polishing the glass smooth cherry surface created by my $3,500 Pink Ivory infill plane, I noticed an odd pattern in the finish. On closer examination it appeared to be the profile of the infill plane. Apparently the Camelia Oil I religiously and lovinigly apply to the metal somehow got on - and into - the wood and contaminated it. Who new shellac wouldn't stick to Camelie Oil?
It never occured to me that a dozuki could cut through bone as quickly - and cleanly - as it does through rock maple. Thankfully it was only the tip of the index finger of my LEFT hand - and I'm a Righty.
The joy and satisfaction hand planing the 8 foot long, 14" wide four quarter timber to a uniform and gloss 3/4" board more than made up for the subsequent chiropractor visits - and cost.
Who knew that that 0.007" corner of the shoulder plane's iron sticking out the side of the body could create such a long - though shallow incision in skin?
.
.
.
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
>Those all happened to me in the past 6 months. Did I ever mention dropping the skew chisel and trying to catch it? A distinct advantage of hand tools though is that I could regrind the skew chisel. Did you know that solid carbide bits shatter on concrete?
Love these "out takes".
Re: Illustrating that power tools are more satisfying
>Writing promo articles for woodworking mags.... I'd swear that's what I was reading! And your first "signature" line of products can be "Tindall's Extra Special Rhapsodic Paste Wax", specially formulated for cast iron.