Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT Question on TV sound

Posts

OT Question on TV sound

#1

OT Question on TV sound

Barry Irby

>I have tried to watch several shows on TV lately where the music or background sound was so loud I had trouble picking out the dialog. These were not news shows but shows on various channels about something like volcanoes. Don't remember exactly because they were so unpleasant I changed channels. I am beginning to wonder about my hearing. So the question is does anyone else notice this? Is Comcast fiddling with the broad cast or are these shows just poorly recorded?

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#2

I've noticed the same thing

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and have no clue as to the answer. For instance, the live broadcast of the Olympic opening ceremonies were just about impossible to make sense of because of that disparity in volume. We had the same problem with the Super Bowl, too.

We're on Mediacom, but I haven't talked with customer service.

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#3

William A. Roland

Re: I've noticed the same thing

William A. Roland

>Do you have surround sound? I had this problem before I installed a surround system.

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#4

Re: I've noticed the same thing

Barry Irby

>Are you suggesting they are garbling the sound so that the rest of us will be driven to buy surround sound?

I notice that they are formatting the picture to fit the newer rectangular screens and on some shows I don't get to see the edges. Are they pushing me to a new TV also?

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#5

Re: I've noticed the same thing

Bill Howatt

>No, but the sound encoded for surround sound doesn't work as nice without it. I have read some articles about sound issues on TV broadcasts pertaining to volume changes etc. They have a million excuses about how complicated an issue it is from the original source through the different networks, satellites, different stations. They can put a man on the moon, send a problem a zillion miles into space and receive data from it but they can't get the audio right! They should suspend any Emmys or other awards for sound until they get it fixed. I find movies suffer from the save problem. Excessive background levels and low dialog levels. They also think it is artsy to make an whisper the actor does to be inaudible to the audience as well.

They certainly seem to have jacking the volume up on TV commercials down pat though. BTW, they say they don't increase the volume level. What I think they do is fudge the compression so it sounds louder. Same effect though.

Bill

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#6

Re: OT Question on TV sound

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I, too, have noticed this over the past few years.Another thing I have peeves about is: people using the expressions: "like", "I mean", "you know" and so many others too. But, have you noticed the people cannot speak without waving their arms and hands to emphacize their speech? This is so distracting I sometimes just change the channels to another.... but it is everywhere...

Think about this....do you do it???

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#7

Re: OT Question on TV sound

Chris Friesen

>This could happen if you have the signal going through a surround-sound system that is set up incorrectly. The other thing to do would be to double-check that your speakers are wired up in phase with each other. If you're using the speakers in the TV itself then double-check your TV audio settings and the settings in the cable box (if you have one).

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#8

Re: OT Question on TV sound

Dave (PacNW)

>The current problem with the back ground sound level is real and only controlled by the power switch or the MUTE button (hug! the inventor for me). I believe that the problem has become much worse since the writers started depending on special effects, instead of acting and directing. 99% of the Hollywood actors can't act their way out of a plastic bag and the directors wouldn't know if they did!

Just a 6 cent rant (adjusted for inflation)

Dave (PacNW)

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#9

Re: OT Question on TV sound

Dan Mitchell

>"Another thing I have peeves about is: people using the expressions: "like", "I mean", "you know" and so many others too."

Joe - You know one that drives me nuts, and this is a little more on topic for this forum, is the gardener guy on "Ask this Old House", with his "Take and". "Take and spread the mulch", "Take and wrap the trunk", "Take and set the stones", "Take and THROW THE REMOTE AT THE BLOODY TV" ;-) Does the guy actually TALK like that, or is it just a "folksy" affectation for TV??? Plus, I'd much rather hear from Tommy on there anyway... ;-)

And don't even get me STARTED on the issue of jiggly camera work you see on so many shows! Nauseating! When is THAT fad going to wear off???

Y' don't 'spose we're just a bunch of Olde Fartes on here do you??? ;-)

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#10

Re: OT Question on TV sound

Frank House

>In the UK, as mentioned elsewhere in this thread, the volume "is not increased during advertisements" -- yes, and all politicians are honest!

Documentaries made by the BBC often have the words drowned by the music. News reports given by a reporter in the street outside a building slightly associated with the topic, obliterated by traffic noise. That organisation is regarded (at least by itself) as having very high production standards.

A pet peeve logically related to the sound problem is the enthusiasm for showing people's faces in closeup, even when they are demonstrating a technique with their hands, sometimes while describing it, but often when silent. You see the expression of concentration for most of the shot, then a brief glimpse of the hands when the process they are demonstrating is almost complete.

I have even seen this sort of foolishness on broadcast material made for the Open University. Glad I didn't try to learn woodworking (or any other practical skill) that way.

Frank (old and grumpy).

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Facial Close-ups...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I agree that videographers need to increasingly get away from this particular technique. With hi-def becoming much more common, facial close-ups of ordinary people being interviewed on the street is often less than appealing, and I'm sure that the interviewees don't much appreciate it, either. Save the close-ups for the heavily-made-up, in-studio personnel and actors. I don't need to be able to count pimples and nose-hairs of people on the street--that's not why I got hi-def TV.

As for the sound, one take I heard is that (in the U.S., per the FCC), a commercial's sound level cannot exceed the peak sound level of the program during which it airs. Unfortunately, that means that while the program may hit that peak occasionally, with a much lower average, the commercial producers try to get the sound level average as close to the peak as they can. Locally, we have a couple commercials that are downright obnoxious in terms of the sound level (even though the commercials themselves are not).

Jason

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#12

Re: Facial Close-ups...

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I agree, Jason. And another irritating issue for me is the commercial time alloted. I have counted 34 commercials one right after another during a movie watch. I know they have to "earn" income from them, but this issue is getting out of hand....seems to me that radio, tv, and other venues are just another way for the business to get their ads out for us to view and buy something from them.

And again seeing the same commercial several times over and over during the same movie or show is also disgusting. I am so glad to have the Mute button at times.

Re: OT Question on TV sound

#13

Re: OT Question on TV sound

xeddog

>My biggest pet peeve at the present time is the constant misuse of the word "myself". You hear supposedly educated people using it like - "As for myself . . .", or "Joe and myself . .", or "those people and myself . . .".

The english language is doomed.

xeddog