Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Is MDF wood ?

Posts

Is MDF wood ?

#1

Is MDF wood ?

Yonak

>I have a customer for whom I make a consumer product out of MDF board. He advertises it as being, "all wood" .. I suppose, as opposed to being plastic. One of his customers has complained that since it's MDF it can't be identified as "all wood". Now, certainly MDF is more wood product than resin, but how honestly can my customer advertise it as "all wood", without going into a lot of explanation in the ad ? Do you consider MDF as wood ?

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#2

Re: Is MDF wood ? *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>For myself, I don't conser MDF to be wood.

I think it is called a 'wood product' which means it's made from wood, so if it's made from wood, it must be wood, right?

Bob in NJ's opinion, worth slightly less than you paid for it.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medium-density_fibreboard

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#3

Re: Is MDF wood ?

Nat Robison

>I have no prob with MDF as a material but I wouldn't consider something that used MDF to be "all-wood".......just like I wouldn't consider something using OSB or particleboard to be "all-wood". I wouldn't, however, have a problem calling cabinetry "all-wood" that used plywood.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#4

Re: Is MDF wood ?

John McGaw

>But isn't it just a matter of proportions then? Plywood = wood + resin. MDF = wood + resin. The proportions and the form are different but the contents are the same.

I don't set a lot of store by advertising. It is permissible for a company to claim that something is "made from" a material. This is totally different from "made with". I've probably never made any wood working project that is "all wood". Invariably there is glue and some sort of finish and almost always some sort of hardware even if it is just a few screws.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#5

Re: Is MDF wood ?

Gil

>What if it's a cabinet and the door panel is MDF with wood veneer on either side? Seems like a great way to get a stable door panel that won't have much movement. In order to call it all wood would I have to replace the MDF with 1/4" ply with a veneer laminated on it? As a consumer I always hope that all wood means no MDF. I certainly hope that "solid wood" means no MDF.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#6

Two All Beef Patties......

Barry Irby

>Is hamburger beef? I know some of it has extenders in it but if its all beef is it still beef. Sure there is a difference between a sirloin or a chuck roast and a hamburger or a Salisbury steak.

As far as I know some hamburger really is all beef, does not even have a binder in it. So does the resin or glue in the MDF disqualify it?

My father bought a picnic table that was 100% redwood. Yep, Pine studs stained red.

There is a lot of puffery in advertising and calling MDF wood is not the most egregious example I can think of.

I don't know if there is an accepted definition of "all wood".

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#7

Re: Is MDF wood ?

Thomas S Stockton

>I think your client is using advertising jargon in calling it "all wood" I personally wouldn't say it was, but I don't think he is wrong.

To me MDF is a sheet good no different from plywood or particleboard, yes it's wood but it is a manufactured material which some how makes it different in our minds.

I think the problem is someone called him on his jargon, is this your problem, did you call it all wood? I think probably not. If he came up with the jargon he needs to own it and either come up with another term or deal with the occasional fall out.

Tom

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#8

Re: Is MDF wood ?

Yonak

>Well, the issue is definitely owned by my customer, as he chose the language to describe the item on the packaging without asking my opinion at the time, but he did ask my opinion and advice now. My immediate response to him was, "Is a Pringles a potato chip ? Would it be considered 'all potato" ? .. however, after reflection, that may not be the best comparison.

My wife had a good response however. She asked what is the makeup of the resin ?" She said since it's almost certainly wood resin, you could rightfully claim it's all wood. Of course she also said, "A rose is a rose is a rose," so I'm just as confused as ever.

I think I'm going to advise my customer to say it's made of all wood product, should he decide to change the packaging.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#9

Re: Is MDF wood ?

FredD

>MDF is to wood , like a Brick is to stone, it doesn't look like wood , doesn't perform like wood , you can't stain it to any different look, it flashes off Formaldehyde, wood doesn't , it doesn't hold fasteners like wood does, or nails for that matter.

So given the above where does the comparison match.

The term for it is a Engineered wood product, which is kinda of like saying "genuine wood grain Vinyl"

FredD

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#10

Re: Is MDF wood ?

Alexander Grigoriev

>Schmul and Moshe came to a rabbi.

"Rabbi, tell me, is white a color?"

"I'm not entirely sure, but I'd rather say so, yes, white is a color"

"Rabbi, tell me, is black a color?"

"I'm not entirely sure, but I'd rather say so, yes, black is a color"

"See, Schmul, I sold you a color TV"

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#11

Cherry pies

Neal in San Jose

>Back when I was in college, I paid for a lot of it by working for the college's Agricultural Engineering Dept. and the state's Agricultural Extenson. While working there, I learned that if you want to sell a pie in Indiana and call it a "Cherry Pie", the state has a definition that includes how many whole cherries it must have per ounce of pie, how many partial cherries are allowed, and a whole lot of other requirements. If you want to sell "lobster" in your restaurant, they have regulations around that as well. If, however, you choose to call your pie a "cherry flavored" pie, or your lobster a "finger lobster", you could make it out of anything you wanted to.

There may very well be definitions that have to be met to call something "all wood" or "solid wood", and if you don't follow these to the letter, the state Attorney General could get interested. I don't have a good suggestion as to where to start looking for definitions like that, but your client may well have opened a can of worms.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#12

terminology

Chris Friesen

>I think the current terminology is "solid wood" for real actual wood, vs "all wood" for MDF, particleboard, plywood, OSB, etc. Some places use "all wood" for plywood, and "wood products" for the others.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#13

Re: terminology

Paul Blackwell

>I recently purchased a corner TV stand for my new wide screen HDTV. The ad said "solid wood", but when it arrived, it was mostly MDF. I called customer service, and after lots of hemming and hawing, he really couldn't come up with a satisfactory answer. The stand actually looks nice, and fits my requirements, so I ended up keeping it, but felt somehow cheated.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#14

Re: terminology

Bill White

>I don't get too tangled in semantics. What's paper? All wood, wood-based product????

If the application works, and the price/value relationship is there, let it go. He's selling. You're building. Get paid for your work and smile.

Bill

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#15

Re: Is MDF wood ?

AZ in Colorado Springs

>As several posts have pointed out, you can quickly get bogged down in terminology (for good and bad reasons).

It seems the thrust of the problem is whether or not the advertizing is meant to mis-lead. I think most consumers value solid wood, perceiving it to last longer, and thus be of "higher quality." While MDF and other man made wood products might serve just as well, and in many cases be preferred (such as stable panels in frame & panel construction), I think MDF, particle board, and other "man-made" products are viewed more as opportunities to recycle waste products.

I don't know what consumer item you're producing, but it seems that the ultimate issue is not chemistry but ethics.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#16

Advertising = lying

Phil Joines

>Except for a few places like Lee Valley I don't believe any advertising. There used to be truth in advertising laws but if they still exist they aren't enforced. Anything for a buck.

Re: Is MDF wood ?

#17

Re: Advertising = lying

steve mackay

>Boy, you REALLY hit a button on me there ! The last couple weeks the Borg Pizza Giant has been claiming false advertising against P. J.'s. I've never had a P.J.'s pizza but I've never heard him pick on any others either. AND I'll bet the Borg Pizza is STILL cardboard. Sorry . . . OT . . .