Hobby vs Pro
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>There has always seemed to be a certain romance connected with hand tools. I suspect it is, in part, a function of seeking a less complicated life style. Trained as a sculptor, I learned early-on to forge, temper, and sharpen my own stone tools, and I'm very familiar with the direct connection with the material that hand tools provide, whether the material is wood, stone, clay, or metal. I started carving stone with a point and 5-lb & 3-lb hammers. Wood was worked with shaped chisels and mallets of various sizes, and I was proud of the fine control I developed. Proud, that is, until I discovered pneumatically powered reciprocating hand pieces for both stone and wood. Control went up, and tendinitis went away, and productivity at least doubled. Was my work somehow less sculpture because I wasn't beating on the block for weeks? Not so. Did I loose "touch" with the material after my right forearm slowly returned to human size? Not in the least.
Of course, as a sculptor, I was presented with a number of different technologies in which I "needed" to become proficient. Carving, carpentry, welding, moldmaking, casting and foundry, forging.... the list could go on, but all of these processes were needed at one time or another to pursue an idea. The danger, of course, was that the "process" could take over and the aesthetic element would suffer; the idea, that piece I originally saw in my mind, could be lost in the how-to, and the process could easily take over and dictate. In those instances, the piece invariably failed, regardless of its technical prowess.
Hand-tool purists, I believe, have developed a true love of their material and guard against anything which they see as coming between them and what they are doing. "Feeling" the plane or spokeshave peel off semitransparent slices of wood can be sensual to the point of addiction. Their reason for the dedication is obvious. For them, the journey can be far more important than the destination.
Then there are those who want to produce, and seek the fastest, most efficient way to "get-er done." Power tools get the testosterone flowing in an entirely different way, and provide a serious sense of control of the material. Power woodworkers have a different view, and they seem to seek control less than the method. Both groups tend to develop a focus on their respective tools (all woodworkers are notorious gadget-freaks, see any traveling wood "show"), but "powered" people are more prone to the latest gizmo that will make them the next Sam Maloof.
Hobbyists seem to have the time to hone their planes down to atomic levels of sharpness, while the pros, making (or not) a living on how much product goes out the door, don't have such time luxury. Yet each can and do produce items of great craft and finish.
The polarization you mention, I suspect, is the result of the myopia of "process" over "product" and is nothing new. It does, however, seem to get in the way of appreciation of what others do with the material.
Ultimately, whatever means we choose to make the piece is a personal decision. Once it becomes a value judgment on others' choices, we loose part of our appreciation of the craft.