Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

Posts

Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#1

Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

Stephen Kirk

>I could have also titled this "The piece or the method - which is more important?" Let me say that I am a woodworker who uses everything at his disposal - hand, power, ordered pieces, farmed out work, etc. I've noticed a bit of a scary trend in woodworking around the power vs hand tool type of work. It seems that these two are becoming very separate, with little or no crossover between the two. Hand tool purists look down on a piece created with any power tools, while power tool users wonder why someone would bother fiddling with a plane. It seems, though, that the craftsmanship of the final piece is not examined.

So, I ask, where do you see quality of a piece of furniture (or what have you)? Is it the quality of the piece, or is it the method, or the shop, or the workbench, etc.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#2

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Chevy vs Ford. Nikon vs. Canon. 9mm vs .45 ACP. These are all arguments taking place on other forums right now. It is the nature of a human being to pick something, and then try to compel everyone else around him (or her) to validate his choice by accepting it also. I use power and hand tools too. I don't care what anyone else thinks about that either. I've got my Chevy and my .45 ready to go. :b Oh yeah, and a Nikon to get the best pictures of the event!

People love to fight, and to argue about what they think is best. I posted asking about chisels for my new Powermatic and got a response telling me why another guy bought a General instead. :( Where did that fit into my question? It didn't, but apparently it had to be expressed. That's why I tend to ask as few questions as I can anymore. It is too hard to wade through the chaff to get to the wheat.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#3

you are hanging around with the wrong crowd

Bill Tindall

>You can't make very much stuff eschewing power tools and you can't get the fit and finish in complex cabinetry with just power tools. These realities drive most all of us to a common middle ground.

There are some that choose a life style of minimizing power tool usage, but this choice has nothing to do with the quality of the product, though some try to market the notion that it does. The all- machine approach is practiced by beginners, carpenters and low margin cabinet makers (kitchen cabinets for example). The vast majority of makers of high quality stuff use what ever tool they own that is best for the task and don't spend time philosophizing about the choices.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#4

Quality is what it is.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Quality is not a method. It is a result. It matters not how one gets there. Quality is comprised of two basic elements....materials and craftsmanship. One can build a quality piece of furniture with hand tools, power tools or any combination.

I'm not sure why you think the two camps are becoming more polarized. I haven't seen much change over the years. And I know plenty of folks who employ the use of both power and hand tools (myself included!)

Tom

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#5

Hobby vs Pro

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There has always seemed to be a certain romance connected with hand tools. I suspect it is, in part, a function of seeking a less complicated life style. Trained as a sculptor, I learned early-on to forge, temper, and sharpen my own stone tools, and I'm very familiar with the direct connection with the material that hand tools provide, whether the material is wood, stone, clay, or metal. I started carving stone with a point and 5-lb & 3-lb hammers. Wood was worked with shaped chisels and mallets of various sizes, and I was proud of the fine control I developed. Proud, that is, until I discovered pneumatically powered reciprocating hand pieces for both stone and wood. Control went up, and tendinitis went away, and productivity at least doubled. Was my work somehow less sculpture because I wasn't beating on the block for weeks? Not so. Did I loose "touch" with the material after my right forearm slowly returned to human size? Not in the least.

Of course, as a sculptor, I was presented with a number of different technologies in which I "needed" to become proficient. Carving, carpentry, welding, moldmaking, casting and foundry, forging.... the list could go on, but all of these processes were needed at one time or another to pursue an idea. The danger, of course, was that the "process" could take over and the aesthetic element would suffer; the idea, that piece I originally saw in my mind, could be lost in the how-to, and the process could easily take over and dictate. In those instances, the piece invariably failed, regardless of its technical prowess.

Hand-tool purists, I believe, have developed a true love of their material and guard against anything which they see as coming between them and what they are doing. "Feeling" the plane or spokeshave peel off semitransparent slices of wood can be sensual to the point of addiction. Their reason for the dedication is obvious. For them, the journey can be far more important than the destination.

Then there are those who want to produce, and seek the fastest, most efficient way to "get-er done." Power tools get the testosterone flowing in an entirely different way, and provide a serious sense of control of the material. Power woodworkers have a different view, and they seem to seek control less than the method. Both groups tend to develop a focus on their respective tools (all woodworkers are notorious gadget-freaks, see any traveling wood "show"), but "powered" people are more prone to the latest gizmo that will make them the next Sam Maloof.

Hobbyists seem to have the time to hone their planes down to atomic levels of sharpness, while the pros, making (or not) a living on how much product goes out the door, don't have such time luxury. Yet each can and do produce items of great craft and finish.

The polarization you mention, I suspect, is the result of the myopia of "process" over "product" and is nothing new. It does, however, seem to get in the way of appreciation of what others do with the material.

Ultimately, whatever means we choose to make the piece is a personal decision. Once it becomes a value judgment on others' choices, we loose part of our appreciation of the craft.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#6

Alternatives begat

Forrest Addy

>Alternatives begat adherants. Adherants begat jesting, rivalry, then friendly convrovery. Any controvery begats percveeptions of "them and us" polarizarion and THAT attract sngle issue radicals. The problem is the single issue radicals not woodworking, politics, whatever which attract them.

Normites and Neanderthals can co-exist and benefit from each other's dedication. The seekers caught in the middle need to be assured and the devisive need to be contained and their pointless controversy scotched. The best approach to quelling hateful polarization is for sensible folks to unite in derisive laughter. Those who profit from polarizing dialog are contemptable be they woodworkers or extremist uicide bombers.

I use all the reources at my disposal. I can cut mortice & tenon joints, dovetails whatever by hand or power and once could make money doing either. Sometimes I do things the hard way just for the challenge. Other times I seek effciency. I'm a sovereign man; who dares to deny me freedom to chooe for myself?

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I don't care...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...whether electrons in copper or flesh provide the motive force behind the blade, but it is an outright sin to apply stain to wood to change its natural, beautiful color. That is, unless you are getting paid to do so. :b :D

I liked both Bill Tindall's and Forrest Addy's posts above, as I share very similar sentiments. There's no question that the largest market out there (and also probably the lowest margin) is best served by a powered, industrial approach. Sustenance and profit flow from volume. At the other end is a perhaps much more discriminating market that wants a product not just of wood but of a process, probably which includes a romantic concept of the intimacy between an artisan and his material of choice. And hobbyists line up at both ends and everywhere in between those two extremes.

Having been exposed to mass production (though not in woodworking) and one-off craftsmanship (I am a painting contractor, after all), I understand both extremes and can enjoy both at times. I, at times, enjoy the cathartic nature of working quietly and unpowered, at one with the hand tool, and also enjoy the grunt and sweat of keeping up with a power tool, like a chainsaw.

Jason

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#8

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

John Lucas

>I'm with you. I try to learn the advantages and disadvantages of each and then use the tool that gets the job done.

The same argument goes on in woodturning. If you do much carving on the piece is it still considered turning. Who cares, it should be about the work, not how it's done.

Carvers argue about hand vs power carving. Although most feel just like me, it's about the quality of the work not how you got there.

Some people just like to fuss. It's probably jealousy. I'll flat out admit that I can't plane some woods. I just don't have enough experience with my planes so I'll go to the planer or even a belt sander or scraper. However I don't fuss about the guy who does use only hand tools.

Actually I wish I had the time to use only hand tools. There's something about the quiet atmosphere and feeling of the shaving coming off those tools that is very relaxing and rewarding. Working a full time job it's just not possible for me rely solely on hand tools to get a job done.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#9

Grandpa & Dad . . .

steve mackay

>(and I think my Mother too !) ALWAYS said "The right tool for the job." My shop is about half & half. Power and hand. (OK, I'll admit to more hand) only because each tool or machine does a given task better than any other. I don't buy the "latest & greatest" nor "vintage" for it's own sake. A mordern table saw rips stock in a neat, timely manner BUT a vintage Stanley #78 makes a sweet, pretty and accurate rabbet. If a craftsman produces (or aims for) high quality work I don't think it matters how they achieve it. As for snobbery between the two worlds I've seen folks brag on and on about the "latest & greatest" but get a Galoot going and you'll be there all day.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#10

No No No!

Jerry Nicholson

>Dodge truck not Chevy! And .357 Magnum :D Of course Nikon!!!!

Jerry

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#11

A couple of thoughts here.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Mark,

You make some good points. But since now I find myself in the "git-er-done" set I find that command of both power tools and hand tools is essential. Perhaps the bulk of my work is power tool oriented. However, I have found that many tasks are far better done with hand tools. Not only for the craftsmanship but for the speed as well.

I agree with not having a lot of time to sparpen and hone but I'm a fool if I don't do it. And even though "time is money", there are moments when I find time to stop and smell the roses...or in this case, stop and admire the curly shavings! Otherwise it would just be a "job". ;-)

Anyway, quality is always the goal...no matter if if the tool I'm using has a tail or not.

Cheers,

Tom

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#12

Case In Point

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'm finishing up a wine cabinet with full inset doors. I have a router jig somewhere that will clamp on the door with which I can rout precise mortises for the hinges, leaving just 2 rounded corners to clean up.

However, in 1/10th of the time it would take me to find and haul out the jig, get the router and bit, and get things set up, I'll cut the 4 mortises with a bench chisel and they'll be just as good as any machine cut.

Now, if I had 25 doors to do for a new kitchen . . . . ;)

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#13

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

Jesse Cloud

>Ah this old war horse again! Always a fun topic.

I have friends who consider using a hand tool a personal shortcoming, and others who not only use hand tools, but make their own hand tools. Both make incredible furniture.

I think it does depend somewhat on the task. Handcut dovetails done well just look better than machine cut ones. Customers have come to expect handcut dovetails on high end work. Pieces with complex curves almost always involve hand tools at some point in time, though the hand tools may be used to true a form or template for machine production.

On the other hand, if you hope to sell in the mid-range market, as most of us do, you better learn how to produce quality crisp work with machines.

Personally, I probably do most projects about 75% with power tools and 25% with hand tools, but there's no strongly held belief system that drives me to do that...

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#14

Yabut, if you were serious about turning,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>you'd have a Stubby! :D

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#15

Re: A couple of thoughts here.

Bill Tindall

>"quality is always the goal...no matter if if the tool I'm using has a tail or not."

And it clearly shows in you work

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#16

Re: Case In Point

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Not to mention the "screw up factor". Power tools are handy for many things but there are some tasks where Murphy's Law takes over (at least with me). Not only the setup time becomes a concern but also the question of how likely will it be for me to screw this up with a power tool? Stop! Grab a chisel (or whatever)and go for the sure thing. That little voice comes from years of lessons from Mr. Murphy's Law Book.

T.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#17

Thanks Bill and....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I appreciate the kind words. I find that quality is judged by two parties....my customers and me. My customers expect quality and they deserve it. However they cannot see inside the joints and other places. Only I know what's hidden beneath. But for me to take an ounce of pride I need to know that what my customers cannot see is as good as they hope it it.

Tom

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#18

JL

Depends on the effect.

JL

>I use draw knives and spoke shaves. I use them on spindles, chairs, legs, etc. I like the effect. I may sometimes use a power sander later - or I may use a card scraper.

It all depends on the effect I'm trying for.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#19

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

Hank Knight

>The subject line and text of Stephen's post suggest that two distinct and communities have arisen in the woodworking world and that a level of animosity is growing between them. Perhaps I am naive, or blind - a distinct possibility in both cases - but I don't see that at all. On this board and others I visit, I see that most people live in both communities and that there are very few "purists" who adhere religiously to one discipline or the other. Even among the purists, I don't find any real derision directed at the other camp - perhaps some good-natured kidding, but nothing I would ever classify as mean spirited. In fact, the vast majority of posts I read show a real appreciation for the work, regardless how it is created and a real interest in learning and developing skills with whatever tool is under discussion. I think most understand that the professional woodworker operates under a different set of imperatives than hobbyists, but I have only seen appreciation and admiration for the work shared on this board, never any derision or criticism based on whether the work was produced by a pro or a hobbyiest or whether the work was accomplished with hand tools or electron burners, or both. If I'm missing something here, I prefer to go on missing it and enjoying my association with other woodworkers, whatever their stripe.

Hank

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#20

The Journey or The Destination

charlie belden

>For some, making a piece is a journey, the resulting piece merely a post card reminder of the trip.

For some, the piece is the destination and how you get to it depends on the means of transportation available.

Using a trip analogy - going from San Francisco to New York City - you can get there in plane - or you can ride cross country - on a bike for example. By plane, your destination is reached much quicker and more predictably and perhaps more comfortably than by bike, especially if you can afford to fly first class.

But by plane, you miss getting a feel for how big this country is, how diverse the intervening landscapes - and people. On the ground you see it, hear it, smell it, feel it and maybe taste it (roadside diners and truck stop food is different from "restaraunt food"). The interstate has reduced what you can see, hear, smell, taste and touch from what you'd experience on the road system before the interstate. You really would have to have traveled Route 66 to understand the difference.

Then theres the rate at which things happen. When Time Is Money the rate of producing is significant to the Bottom Line. And when it comes to making a piece of wood into something - a component of a piece or the whole piece - quick and efficient often requires tools that operate at much higher speeds than our senses - and our reaction times. With a power planer, you can't know that the knives are tearing out wood rather than severing wood fibers until the damage has been done - to the WHOLE board. For squirrley wood, a hand plane will let you know something you don't want happening is happening - on the first pass with it. And if you can't feel the plane tearing rather than cutting, you might see it - before continuing.

Another considerations is WHEN you can use a tool to do something to the wood. With most power tools you're working on pieces of the piece, or making the pieces of the piece. Once the piece is put together, further modfications,refinements are difficult or impossible to do with a power tool. While you can cut dovetails for a drawer with power tools and jigs or with handtools, tuning the fit of a drawer just so ain't a power tool job.

Then there are the AH moments that seem to be unique to hand tool work - when a saw cuts effortlessly and without a hint of stress, or the shoosh sound as a plane iron creates a one sided curly - at midnight when things are quiet.

How you get to the destination isn't important. Missing the experiences of the journey - well that's important to some - of no significance to others.

Now I've got an urge to go fondle my DOMINO ; )

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#21

I prefer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Cohen's Corollary:

"Murphy was an optimist."

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#22

later......

Bill Tindall

>The hidden part "shows up" 50-100 years later.... by not showing up as failed joinery.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#23

Premise of this post

wilbur

>I completely agree with Hank. This thread presumes a split between hand tool and power tool users which I don't see for the most part.

Now if you're talking about whether to cut dovetails pins first or tails first, on the other hand.... ;)

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#24

Amazing replies! Thanks everyone

Stephen Kirk

>I am constantly amazed at all the great attitudes displayed here on WoodCentral.

It seems that many have summed up the same things on my mind. The piece determines the tools/methods to use. I have seen wonderful pieces made completely by hand, and wonderful pieces cranked out of a modern shop. All the craftsmen were great people. I'm in the same boat as many in that I use the right tool for the job and I try to always build the best piece I can. For me, my work is about the finished piece and less about the method.

I wanted to follow by by saying that I don't see enmity between the power and hand tool groups, but I was seeing some "down the nose" glances which were a little off putting. I believe that some of this feeling may stem from there being many people who collect tools yet make very little furniture. However, they know those tools extremely well and are a very valuable resource and often great people. I hope we all continue to work together very well.

In addition, I was thinking that some of the large separation between hand and power tools right now may be generated by vendors, magazines and businesses. Hand tools are big business right now, so of course if people are pushed to work hand tool only, you make money. While I may see things as lopsided towards hand tools right now (as opposed to a power tool central market in years past), it is overall a good thing. When we balance out, I'm hoping we end up with great power and hand tools on the market.

Again, thanks for the great replies, I enjoyed reading them all.

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

#25

Re: Power vs Hand Tool - Has it gone too far?

Bill White

>John Lucas's comments don't count. He has pretty ladies (and one other plain old galoot) in his shop.

SNICKER...............

Way to go John.

Bill