Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Results from sharpened Planer Blades

Posts

Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#1

Results from sharpened Planer Blades

Craig

>May I receive feedback to either confirm or adjust my expectations?

Overview:

I just had my two sets of Delta 15" planer blades professionally resharpened by a local well-known established machine shop who has been doing blade, bit, tool sharpening for many years. I am not satisfied with the cut results after two sharpening attempts with the shop.

Details:

This is the first sharpening for both sets. The Delta 15" X-5 planer was purchased new and has four years of service. Wood being cut is mahogany and douglas fir, VG and Flat Grain. Feed speed is set to SLOW at 16fpm. All alignments on the machine are within 0.0015 tolerance.

Problem:

Cuts 1/32" and under in depth are mirror smooth... anything of greater depth results in tearout, ripout, and gouging of the wood surface feeding WITH or against the grain. Both sets of these blades produced smooth cuts up 1/16"~3/32" before the resharpening; even after two years of service. Also, the mirror quality cut still has two minute blemish lines running the length of the board. If I increase the speed to HIGH at 32fpm everything has sharp little gouges regardless of the depth of cut...

In your experience, is this result typical of "resharpened" blades versus "new, never sharpened" blades?

I took the blades back and requested a second resharpening due to the quality of the cuts. I received the blades back... the quality of the cut is the same and I observed the following blade details upon closer inspection:

Additional blade details after second sharpening (ie. a redo where they took extra time and attention to detail, and measured with a precision flat edge):

a) Each sharpened blade surface has high spots ranging from .001 ~ .003

b) Two blades are now "rockered" - with one end held down the other end rises .007 ~ .013. They tried to get rid of this twice with no success

This is the best they say they can do... Is this what I should expect from "sharpened" blades? My wallet tells me I need to find a new machine shop... my head tells me I am spending more money with the time, frustration, and quality of cut obtain; just purchase new blades.

Thanks in advance!

Craig

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#2

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

Grant in Iowa

>Craig,

Let me start by admitting my own similar issue with a smaller DeWalt planer several years ago. Turns out, I was using the knife setting jig incorrectly, and the knives were set too low, causing the knife head itself to impact the workpiece.

I now have the older vesion of your new X5 15" machine, so I know something of how to set those knives as well. Make sure your jig is being used properly per the manual. Not casting stones here, just sharing a common problem with a new(er) owner of a planer....hey, I have been there!

I suggest two additional courses of action after ensuring the knives are set well per the manual:

1. Take the knives to a Delta Dealer who has some in stock and compare them to a new part... angle of sharpening and so on.

2. Inspect closely a board that has gone through the planer with both a light cut and one of your problematic cut depths. Maybe put your planer in high feed rate mode to exaggerate this effect for ease of inspection. Can you see the individual knife marks on both boards? They should look like tiny waves on an ocean, and be evenly spaced. If they look fine in the light pass board, but don't show up in the heavy pass board, then your knives may be set too low. The tiny waves evident on the board should be evenly spaced...any variation in their spacing indicates one or more knives set differently than the others height wise.

And just for sanity's sake, make sure the knives are oriented correctly. The sharp edge should be towards the outfeed side of the planer as you look down at the top of the head. Again, check your manual for a picture representation. Not casting stones, just pointing out a possibility. For another mental image, stand on the gearchange and height adjusting side of your planer and the knife head should rotate clockwise...the knives should point to the right at the top of the head where you can access them.

One more possibility is that (and again I apologise if this is too basic) you aren't setting the knife height and the newly sharpened (and shorter) knives are effectively too low in the head.

I agree, something isn't right...lets rule out the easy stuff first.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#3

I agree

Bill Tindall

>If the knives are sharpened by a place that does knives regularly for the professional trades in the area it is highly unlikely that sharpening is the source of the problems. Presumably these knives are sharpened just like all the others they do. If they feel razor sharp and the edges are fairly straight there isn't anything else that can be a problem with the knives. Double check installation.

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#4

Adding:

Forrest Addy

>Factory knife setting jigs etc are very handy but you have to verify the knives are set to equal height and at least 1/32" above the cutter head and parallel to the machine reference feature, either the planer platen or the jointer's out-feed tablei. The best way to do this is with a dial indicator in a surface gage or the woodworker's equivelent.

It's a PITA but it has to be done at least the first time you replace knives if only to validate the setting jig - and any time you need extra precision or encounter problems like the OP described. Before you accuse the sharpening harp it would be best to objectively eliminate operator error.

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#5

clarify 1/32"

Bill Tindall

>You surely mean the unground part of the knife needs to be at least 1/32" above the cutter head.

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#6

Hey Craig, let us know how you are making out

Grant in Iowa

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#7

Re: Hey Craig, let us know how you are making out

Craig

>Thank you all for the setup information. Yes, setup has been completed as specified in the manual using the Delta knife setting jig as on previous setups. All sharpened knife heights were reset to within 0.001 to the jig. Yes, I can produce both the "little waves" and a mirror finish. But, I will verify the setup again today to ensure I did not miss something.

Thanks!

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#8

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

FredD

>Assume for a minute that your knives are correctly ground and are identical in size and that your planer is set to factory specs.

You can also rely on a much smoother finish cut with a light cut and a slow feed because the number of knife cuts per inch are greatly increased and the lighter cut will have a better journey though the wood tear out wise.

Also if you have a moisture meter , you can check the dryness which if it dips very much below 6% MC, then you can have brittle wood that is prone to tear out and the heavier the cut and the faster the feed the worse the tear out becomes.

Many people assume that the wood they buy in a lumber yard or worse still ,in a big box store is ready to go when they get it home.

Many times the wood will need acclimating to the shop environment before any FINISH planing is done.

I generally plane the wood I get from a sawmill that has a good Kiln operation a initial planing that leaves the wood thicker then I will eventually plane it to.

I buy rough sawn lumber at least 7/8ths to a inch in thickness to plane down to a finish size of 3/4" to 13/16ths for example.

There is always the possibility that one planer knife is doing most of the work which also results in a rougher finish then you have come to expect from your planer.

There are many variables to check and eliminate before you change shops for grinding , though I have seen all levels of grinding come out of one shop, depends somewhat on who did it that day.

One last tip , when you finally get it solved, the next sharpening session is a chance to ask about getting a secondary bevel or micro bevel as it is called in some shops added to the edge.

This is a very narrow steeper by a few degrees bevel added after the initial grind with a stone.

Some can and some don't want to fiddle with it , but it will give you a longer life between sharpenings.

Best of luck

FredD

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#9

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

Craig

>Fred,

Thanks for the great input. I will discuss the secondary bevel with the new the new machine shop. And, the moisture content was a great reminder.

Craig

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

#10

Re: Results from sharpened Planer Blades

Craig

>All,

Thank you for the input and suggestions. I have solved the planer blade / poor quality cut problem.

Yesterday, i again double-checked everything on the machine and blade setup - everything was in spec and as documented in the manual.

So i focused my attention to the DELTA KNIFE SETUP JIG, (ie. that comes with the machine from the factory) with the thought of "what if the height of this jig is off by a couple of thousandths of an inch? ie. higher or lower than what the rest of the machine needs to produce a mirror cut" I assumed higher for the first trial. Reset each blade 0.0015 higher, reassembled the machine, and made test cuts....

Success! A mirror finish up to 3/32" depth of cut. And, at 1/8" maximum depth of cut the tear-out is even much better than before.

Thank you again to everyone.

Craig