Results from sharpened Planer Blades
Craig
>May I receive feedback to either confirm or adjust my expectations?
Overview:
I just had my two sets of Delta 15" planer blades professionally resharpened by a local well-known established machine shop who has been doing blade, bit, tool sharpening for many years. I am not satisfied with the cut results after two sharpening attempts with the shop.
Details:
This is the first sharpening for both sets. The Delta 15" X-5 planer was purchased new and has four years of service. Wood being cut is mahogany and douglas fir, VG and Flat Grain. Feed speed is set to SLOW at 16fpm. All alignments on the machine are within 0.0015 tolerance.
Problem:
Cuts 1/32" and under in depth are mirror smooth... anything of greater depth results in tearout, ripout, and gouging of the wood surface feeding WITH or against the grain. Both sets of these blades produced smooth cuts up 1/16"~3/32" before the resharpening; even after two years of service. Also, the mirror quality cut still has two minute blemish lines running the length of the board. If I increase the speed to HIGH at 32fpm everything has sharp little gouges regardless of the depth of cut...
In your experience, is this result typical of "resharpened" blades versus "new, never sharpened" blades?
I took the blades back and requested a second resharpening due to the quality of the cuts. I received the blades back... the quality of the cut is the same and I observed the following blade details upon closer inspection:
Additional blade details after second sharpening (ie. a redo where they took extra time and attention to detail, and measured with a precision flat edge):
a) Each sharpened blade surface has high spots ranging from .001 ~ .003
b) Two blades are now "rockered" - with one end held down the other end rises .007 ~ .013. They tried to get rid of this twice with no success
This is the best they say they can do... Is this what I should expect from "sharpened" blades? My wallet tells me I need to find a new machine shop... my head tells me I am spending more money with the time, frustration, and quality of cut obtain; just purchase new blades.
Thanks in advance!
Craig



