Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT - Tiling question

Posts

OT - Tiling question

#1

OT - Tiling question

Nat Robison

>I've done a couple of tiling jobs (2 floors and a countertop) with good results. I have the opportunity to do another small floor coming up and had a question.

When reading about tiling floors, many sources suggest a layer of thinset between the plywood subfloor and the cement board. What are the general thoughts on this step and its necessity?? I did my kitchen floor without this step and can't see any probs after 5-6 years. Does the thinset really bond the wood and cement board??

Re: OT - Tiling question

#2

Re: OT - Tiling question

jared

>I did a bunch of tile in our house last year. I put the thinset under the cement board. It sure makes a solid base for the tile, especially if there is any variation in the plywood subfloor. Most tile places and resources recommend doing it this way. I did some probably 10 years ago for some people without bonding the durock down and there have been no complaints. So who knows. I think an importent step is to spread a very thin layer of thinset on top of the durock for a scratch coat before you put down the bulk of the thinset with a notched trowel. Just my two cents worth. Jared

Re: OT - Tiling question

#3

Re: OT - Tiling tip

paul in AZ

>No opinion on the thinset but I do have a tip that makes the finishing cleanup easy.

I've done more tiling than i ever wanted to and picked this up from an old timer.

To clean up the floor when done use sawdust, somewhere between damp and a little wet, rubbed around with an old towel. Take a couple of handfulls at a time, wet it and rub. This picks up the grout from the tile faces without damaging the grout lines and can be swept up when done. This beats any other technique for cleaning up the film of grout on tiles.

Re: OT - Tiling question

#4

Re: OT - Tiling question

Dan Donaldson

>I usually do it. The cement board is screwed down, so there is no necessity for bonding if down, but if there are any dips or valleys in the subfloor, it will bridge the gaps and give a good solid foundation. If the cement board has any open gaps under it, it can move slightly with walking weight which will crack the tile or grout lines.

Re: OT - Tiling question

#5

Re: OT - Tiling tip

Justin Szeliga

>If your grout is a bit soft or you press too hard you will embed little bits of sawdust in the grout, a really horrible thought, especially for one who has got a bit of debris on his feet & then onto a tile floor & then started to sponge the floor off. Just a nasty pain in the butt.

Re: OT - Tiling question

#6

Re: OT - Tiling question

Justin Szeliga

>As mentioned the thinset provides for support under the cement board, in addition to bonding the sheets to the plywood & helping to make them act as one big sheet instead of as individual sheets.

Masonry is very strong in compression & weak in tension. That means if there is a solid path to a stable surface the masonry won't move & crack. Any voids between the cement board & the plywood floor allows for an unsupported condition & hence is more susceptible to cracking.

Tile Your World forum is a great place to get information on tilework.

Peace

Justin

Re: OT - Tiling question

#7

Re: OT - Tiling question

Barry Irby

>I have not done a lot of tile, but what I did, I did not use thinset under the tile board and those floors have done fine.

The tile product I don't understand it the waffle sheet you put under the tile over the tile board (something Like Ditrex?). It seems to be designed to isolate the tail from the board and to cushion it. ???? Seems to be the opposite of what I thought you wanted. Anybody got a better grasp?

Re: OT - Tiling question

#8

Re: OT - Tiling question

Justin Szeliga

>Ditra is an isolation membrane, that is it creates a break between the building & the tile surface. It is a plastic sheet with an embossed pattern that gives the thinset something to grab & hold, allowing the sheet to be adhered to the subfloor & the tile to adhere to the sheet. the idea is to isolate the tilework from some of the stresses that the building structure may undergo. I've used another product by the same folks called Kerdi as a waterproofing membrane. Very easy to work with, much less hassle than a pan & wetbed.

Re: OT - Tiling question

#9

Re: OT - Tiling question

Dan Donaldson

>If you have a good subfloor base, then there is no problem. My floors were old and I had to tear off a bunch of stuff to get to the bottom. I did put the thinset under the cement board and it is also working fine. Later, I ended up having to move a 1200 pound safe across the tile floor. It ended up causing no problem at all. Now, had I not put the thinset in, would I have had a problem? I don't know, but I sure felt better about it knowing that it was as solid as I could make it ;)

Re: OT - Tiling question

#10

Re: OT - Tiling question

FredD

>Nat,

lay a level or straight edge across the floor joists and see if you have any sag in the subfloor between the floor joists.

If your lucky you won't, if you do, I would run a heavy bead or two of PL 400 or PL 500 on the subfloor between the joists in the center of the sag, lay down the cement board and let it find it's own level.

When the glue is dry (next day) you can screw the cement board to the subfloor though this would not be necessary because the bond is already there , far stronger then any mechanical fasteners .

This method avoids troweling any messy thinset or a even better product called "FixAll" and eliminates any flexing of the board which is what you want to avoid.

Just so you know , PL 400 for interior work and PL 500 for exterior work is a extremely strong construction adhesive which will bridge gaps up to 3/8ths of a inch.

It comes in large caulking tubes and is available at most building supplies and lumber yards and hardware stores.

Tile stores won't have it because they don't realize the profit they get from other products not nearly as good or efficient in application.

FredD

Re: OT - Tiling question

#11

Re: OT - Tiling question

Barry Irby

>Fred is right about PL 400. I used a lot of it when I was building and it worked perfectly, never had a problem with any of it. On one house the supplier sent me another brand of glue and I used it. I ended up living in that house, (Cooks eat their mistakes, Builders live in them) and that brand X glue failed. Years later, I took out part of the subfloor to make way for some hardwood. The glue had completely separated and did nothing. I still need to replace the rest of it.

If you decide to glue it, use good glue. I strongly recommend BF Goodrich PL400.