Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

Posts

Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#1

Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

John in NM

>I'm looking at doing some laminations and got interested in these. I have plenty of compressor I think, 8 cfm at 100psi. Seems like any time there's fluid engineering involved in building a product, the results can be extremely variable, so I'd like to hear from anyone who has experience with this type of vacuum set up rather than a displacement pump.

Thanks!

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#2

I use one

McKay

>I have a venturi at the home shop and find that it will turn on more than I like. Ties up the compressor for the time that you are clamped. Compared to the Vaccusystems unit I do not like the venturi as well, but then it is a whole lot cheaper and works very well. :)

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#3

Yep, Using a V2 premium from Joewoodworker

Grant in Iowa

>I am using an air compressor rated at 90 psi at 7 cfm to run a JoeWoodworker V2 premium venturi system on 5'x8' bag with no issues. The key is size your vacuum press reservoir small enough so that your compressor won't run out of air before the press "satisfies".

I built my own setup from the kit available at www.JoeWoodworker.com or www. Veneersupplies.com (sister sites). I also bought their heavy duty vinyl bag and closure and that also works great.

Works great. I have been gluing up 6' long waterskis in the setup. When closing the bag, try to squeeze out most of the air before sealing the end and pumping...it just goes faster that way, even though the venturi pump can do the job.

I think $235 buys the pump kit and instructions, and then you need a bag to fit your planned projects and some basic homecenter items. I bought an oversized bag, thinking I might add a smaller bag later for smaller projects, but haven't needed to. You just roll up the part you aren't going to use and it sits nicely on the bench out of the way. Don't even bother trying to use visqueen and duct tape...miserable failure!. I think my bag was $160 also from Joe Woodworker.

If you have any doubt about what you need, call him up. Nice guy and very helpful. Small mom and pop operation, but pretty much an expert on the subject.

Heres a shot of the "pump" setup as i built it. Probably not as elegant as some would want, but it serves the purpose:


Heres a laminate bending project in the bag. Note the waxed paper around the part to prevent glue from getting on the bag. The form is simply Owens Corning Pink rigid builders styrofoam (the high density version) Cut to shape at the bandsaw, and covered in Duct tape. Adhere it to a backer board larger than the form for both ease of use and rigidity. If we wanted to bend a tighter radius, or a full circle, we'd put the part in the bag, begin drawing a vacuum a little at a time and then bend the bag and part over the form (form outside the bag, secured by clamps). unlike a clamps only approach, this method allows the flawlessly tight glue lines, while allowing an oddly shaped part.


And here's a shot of what we used that glueup for (ripped it and used it for curved table legs). Nice tight glue joints.. NO gaps...strong, flawless parts thanks to the wonders of vacuum pressing! Pay no attention to that cluttered shop in the background.


Regards,

Grant in Iowa<---getting ready to make 5 more slalom skis...have the laminations cut, just need to glue them up in the press.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#4

A foam form!  Thanks Grant!

John in NM

>I'd never thought of using that pink foam - that's going to save me sooooo much time! :D

I'm probably going with a small bag, my experience with vacuum pressing is that more bag than you need can be awkward. Of course both shops where we did this we were still building heavy plywood or mdf forms....

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#5

Foam works good, but...

Grant in Iowa

>If your form will need to be made of several thicknesses, pick up some 3M spray adhesive rated for use with foam (check the label). Also, make sure you use the higher density of the two verieties. You want the one rated for use beneath concrete, sometimes blue or green in color.

Finally, make sure if your form is not very thick, you'll want to be sure to stick it to a sheet of plywood to resist the bending forces placed upon it by your laminates. Size the form at least an inch or so wider than your workpiece. Size the plywood maybe an inch or two wider and longer than your foam form, and roundover that sheet of ply to protect your bag.

You'll need to draw the vacuum slowly(I have a valve on the output side of my venturi pump so I can regulate the flow), and pull the bag out from beneath the workpiece or else the vacuum will suck a fold of bag material beneath the workpiece. it is best to make your plies thin enough such that a helper can hold them to the form shape while you evacuate the bag to prevent the bag from pulling under the workpiece.

If you need to "fair" your mold after cutting it to shape on a bandsaw, you can use coarse sandpaper stuck to a bendable board to smooth its shape. I have also used body filler to correct mistakes. If your form will be used for several parts, it may be worth while to cover it with formica, or maybe some thin Melamine covered board....something slick and hard, yet bendable. As a minimum, layer strips of duct tape over the foam to give it some protection and mold release tendencies.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#6

Re: Foam works good, but...

Jesse Cloud

>Hey John,

Interesting idea, foam forms! Will have to give that a try.

Here's another tip: I've struggled with keeping big bags open while trying to slide the glue-up in without messing anything up, until I saw a picture of a guy holding his bag open with a clothespin on the end of a string nailed to the ceiling...

So what are you making that will use laminations?

Jess

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#7

Re: Foam works good, but...

John in NM

>What I'm up to is trying to substitute two thin laminated parts for one large chunk and a whole lot of carving on a two piece gunstock. It may work, it may not. I'm also thinking of making a form by casting the back of the piece in polyurethane resin and forming around that.

I still have a clamp form for making a 42" semi circle if you ever need such a thing. All that work for one door jamb, couldn't bear to toss the form so I've been lugging it around for 6 or 7 years (and its mdf too). I figured it would be perfect if I ever want to make a skirt for a 48" round table - hasn't happened yet :D

If I ever get the shop built, I really have to get back to furniture. There were a lot of curved ideas I wanted to mess with when we packed up and moved from AZ, so I figure its time to get a bag and get back into it (in anticipation of the shop being done that is :D )

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#8

Questions for Grant or Anybody with Experience

Barry Irby

>I have made a number of curved laminations, but never with a vacuum press.

Are you saying the laminations are tighter?more reliable with a vacuum press than with clamps?

How tick are those laminations? Can you give me some idea of the radius of the bends.

I have wanted to make a press but never have. It just seems to me that it couldn't be that powerful. Am I wrong? I have a small Gast pump. Would that work?

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#9

Something to think about

Dan Donaldson

>Atmospheric pressure is somewhere in the neighborhood of 14 pounds per square inch depending on altitude and a few other things. Assuming that you cannot pull a perfect vacuum, say you could get 12 psi. (You can probably get more, but let's be conservative)

In that case, if you put something a foot square in the bag and pulled 12 psi of vacuum, that is the equivalent of putting a 1728 pound weight on that square foot piece. Probably enough to clamp it ;)

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#10

An example *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>The attached video is of a 55 gallon drum being sealed then cooled which lowers the pressure inside. The amount of vacuum formed in this case is likely significantly less than you can get in a good bag press, but look at the results.


Vacuum Power

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#11

Re: Questions for Grant or Anybody with Experience

Grant in Iowa

>Barry,

My vacuum press, a venturi powered by an air compressor, can pull 28" of mercury. I don't recall the precise math of the matter, but if memory serves, 28" of mercury over one square foot is equivalent to about 1700lbs of force pressing uniformly on that square foot. The key is even pressure.

The radiusses you can bend are really dependent on the thicknesses of your plies and the wood used.

As for the glue joints, they are absolutely even, tight, and well... flawless. Tough to do that with a clamp setup. As tight as the glueline in an edge glued table top... that good.

The real benefit of a vacuum press is over a large surface area. It wouldn't make much sense to invest in one to do something like narrow table skirts, as these are relatively narrow and could be jigged and clamped rather easily other ways. Where the vacuum press really shines is over large surface areas such as the water skis I am working on. Each ski (they are 9" wide and 6 feet long) is 4.5 square feet. If the press can pull 28" of mercury, then you have about 7650 lbs of force evenly distributed over the surface of the glue up. Now that is hard to achieve with even a bunch of heavy clamps, and it would require a more elaborate jig to get that pressure anywhere near as even.

The press I am using isn't air tight. Hose fittings, leaks at the bag closure, and who knows where else. So the pump cycles (it does this automatically) whenever the level of vacuum gets to a user defined point. Air is directed through the venturi and the pumps reservoir of vacuum is replenished. I leave a project in the press overnight. It might cycle every 20 minutes or so while holding a vacuum. The air compressor cycles about every second time the pump cycles. You can set the pressure on the pump as required for your gluing and bending application. Depending on the type of glue and the application, this gives you a great deal of control and repeatability.

Make some notes on your pump and do some research. It is about its volume capacity, duty cycle capability, and max vacuum pressure. The www.joewoodworker.com site is a good place to do some reading and get "edu-ma-cated" on the subject. I think you'll also find some options for using and controlling your pump, along with if it will work for your application.

To be sure, folks do fine work using clamps, cauls, and other means to do bent laminations. I know Ellis has a lot of experience using only clamps and I am sure the quality of the parts he can make is very high. The vacuum press isn't a panacea for all of this type of work. It has its strong points and weak points like anything. I will submit, however, that if you are doing any large surface area type work, or need even pressure (who doesn't want that?), then the technology is well worth a look.

I'll be honest, I have limited laminate bending experience other than with a vacuum press, so if anyone has experience with both and can compare and contrast the results and ease of use, feel free to chime in.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#12

Re: An example

Barry Irby

>Dan, I've actually seen stuff like that before. I guess what I don't know is how much pressure have I been applying with clamps? How does clamping pressure come appear to what you can do with vacuum?

It's a b***ch being broke. If times weren't so tough I would buy the stuff and try it out.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#13

Re: Questions for Grant or Anybody with Experience

Barry Irby

>Thanks. Somehow it never occurred to me that the results could be that good. I guess I need to play with it and watch it work to get a good grasp of the potential.

Those skis you are making are huge. You could go really slow on skis that big. You might no even need a boat, just a really good paddle.

I have been daydreaming about a vacuum press for years. As I said above, this economy is a bi**ch. I hate being broke.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#14

Re: An example

Dan Donaldson

>In a localized area, you will have more pressure with a clamp. The advantage of the vacuum is that you can get pressure evenly across the entire piece and the sum total of pressure can be as great or greater than you can get with the clamp.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#15

Barry, you need to get on with it.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>If you already have a pump, there is not much expense after that.

I have never really looked at that venturi system, but just keep asking myself why anyone would bother with it. If you have a standard compressor like most small shops, all you have to do, is open the tank drain, then buy a plumbing fitting that screws onto the filter intake, usually 3/4" pipe thread, to 1/2" hose barb, and your compressor becomes a vacuum pump.

I have been using several found, free pumps from old walk-in cooler, or grocery isle freezers for many years. They pull ~ 28" hg, which is about -14 psi, X 144 sq. in. per sq. ft = 2016 #.

Barry, I have done projects where I had 80,000 # of clamping pressure, like on curved stair stringers. How many clamps would you need to get that? Any of these various pumps can live under a workbench, and the vinyl rolled up on a tube on a shelf, not taking up much shop space.

Anybody that can make coffee, or mix two amounts of ingredients, can use epoxy or other bagging glue. This is not rocket science.

The last time I taught a class on it for basic woodworkers for the local club, I started by showing how to plumb a compressor, into a cheap plastic drum-liner where anybody could start out for under $20. I later found out that most of them were either working or retired Phd's who could afford to buy the best out there for their hobbies.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#16

I'm surprised...

John in NM

>I would never have guessed that an air compressor could be an efficient enough pump for most bagging applications - ring and valve materials are not designed for it and they have a fixed pumping speed, which I'd understood really limits their ability to pull much vacuum.

Have you done much laminating with one?

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#17

Re: I'm surprised...

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>John, I have been bagging for around 25 years, and have done some pretty challenging projects through the years.

I have to ask, why you would think a piston type pump, which has no problem going to +125, would have a problem only going to -14 psi.

In that range, the motor is under virtually no load. And if you understand how air-conditioners work, where heat is transferred simply by compressing or stretching a gas. Most of the heat normally generated in the pump, is generated by compressing air at a given temperature into a much smaller space, which has the effect of increasing the temperature of that same air in a smaller volume. Thus, the compressor doesn't generate heat like it does when compressing the same air.

After the air is all removed, there is obviously heat due to friction, so anyone trying their compressor for the first time, should take the tube which connects the pump to the tank loose, then put a cup with a paper towel in it, to watch for oil. If your rings were bad, I guess you could loose the oil and damage the pump, but it has never been a problem for me.

I can't claim that all compressors will work this way. I don't own the oil-less, but I did try one of those once, and it would NOT work.

Also, let me state, I have never used the venturi type arrangement, but I can't imagine how it could be as efficient as the same pump simply pulling air into the space of a piston moving down a cylinder.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#18

Re: Barry, you need to get on with it.

Barry Irby

>Thanks for the encouraging words. You are right. Time to get on with it. Next time the opportunity arises I will give it a try.

What do you recommend for a bag. I seem to recall there are two materials out there. Which would you go for?

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#19

Re: I'm surprised...

John in NM

>I understand that piston vacuum pumps range from about 1/100 atm to 1/2 atm, so I'm really more curious about what the capabilities of a converted air compressor would be relative to that. Even 1/2 atm is going to be around 1000 # per square foot, and could be quite useful, so it is a very interesting idea.

Don't under-estimate the ability of the venturi effect to do practical work - that's why airplanes fly after all.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#20

Re: Barry, you need to get on with it.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>Barry, I have always built my own bags using vinyl from the auto upholstery supply that is just down the street from here. They also sell the glue, which works like contact cement. I think 20 ga. is what I use. Thinner tears easier, and 30 is harder to handle, and wrinkles become a problem on curved parts.

I just fold it back onto itself, then glue the outside 1.5" along both edges. I bring a 1/2" hose in the bottom corner about a foot, then tape an old shirtsleeve onto the end, which needs to make contact with the edge of the object in the bag, or other bleeder fabric or rope which surrounds the object.

I smush a wad of rope caulk around where the hose exits the bag, then leave about six inches on the outside, which I then use a double ended hose barb to connect to the hose going to the pump.

I close the open end of the bag by folding it over 1/2" rigid copper, then slide a slit 3/4" PVC over that, then roll it a couple of turns, and clamp it with a spring clamp to keep it from unrolling. You can also get a good seal by simply folding it over a lath, then placing another on top of the first, then roll the two over a couple of turns, then spring clamp them together.

You can use this method with plastic trash bags, or for long skinny parts, get the open ended tubing which is sold to be clipped to length for many miscellaneous parts through packaging supply. Some of these packaging materials are pretty tough, but toughness is not really necessary if you are careful and don't tear whatever you use.

Re: Is anyone using a venturi vacuum press?

#21

Re: Barry, you need to get on with it.

Dan Donaldson

>The two kinds are vinyl and polyurethane. The poly bags are tougher, but much more expensive and probably not needed unless you plan to do a lot of vacuum work.