Re: Questions for Grant or Anybody with Experience
Grant in Iowa
>Barry,
My vacuum press, a venturi powered by an air compressor, can pull 28" of mercury. I don't recall the precise math of the matter, but if memory serves, 28" of mercury over one square foot is equivalent to about 1700lbs of force pressing uniformly on that square foot. The key is even pressure.
The radiusses you can bend are really dependent on the thicknesses of your plies and the wood used.
As for the glue joints, they are absolutely even, tight, and well... flawless. Tough to do that with a clamp setup. As tight as the glueline in an edge glued table top... that good.
The real benefit of a vacuum press is over a large surface area. It wouldn't make much sense to invest in one to do something like narrow table skirts, as these are relatively narrow and could be jigged and clamped rather easily other ways. Where the vacuum press really shines is over large surface areas such as the water skis I am working on. Each ski (they are 9" wide and 6 feet long) is 4.5 square feet. If the press can pull 28" of mercury, then you have about 7650 lbs of force evenly distributed over the surface of the glue up. Now that is hard to achieve with even a bunch of heavy clamps, and it would require a more elaborate jig to get that pressure anywhere near as even.
The press I am using isn't air tight. Hose fittings, leaks at the bag closure, and who knows where else. So the pump cycles (it does this automatically) whenever the level of vacuum gets to a user defined point. Air is directed through the venturi and the pumps reservoir of vacuum is replenished. I leave a project in the press overnight. It might cycle every 20 minutes or so while holding a vacuum. The air compressor cycles about every second time the pump cycles. You can set the pressure on the pump as required for your gluing and bending application. Depending on the type of glue and the application, this gives you a great deal of control and repeatability.
Make some notes on your pump and do some research. It is about its volume capacity, duty cycle capability, and max vacuum pressure. The www.joewoodworker.com site is a good place to do some reading and get "edu-ma-cated" on the subject. I think you'll also find some options for using and controlling your pump, along with if it will work for your application.
To be sure, folks do fine work using clamps, cauls, and other means to do bent laminations. I know Ellis has a lot of experience using only clamps and I am sure the quality of the parts he can make is very high. The vacuum press isn't a panacea for all of this type of work. It has its strong points and weak points like anything. I will submit, however, that if you are doing any large surface area type work, or need even pressure (who doesn't want that?), then the technology is well worth a look.
I'll be honest, I have limited laminate bending experience other than with a vacuum press, so if anyone has experience with both and can compare and contrast the results and ease of use, feel free to chime in.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa