Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Posts

OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#1

OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>With all the snow that fell over the last couple days and the freeze/melt cycle going on my house has developed a problem with ice dams occurring along the roof gutters. The melt water is running down the side of my house and causing water to leak into the sill of my sliding glass door.

Now I know there is more than one issue here. The sliding glass door was installed by the idiotic former owner. I believe that he neglected to use the proper molding for the upper sill and probably never installed flashing. I swear that guy could screw up a two sandwich picnic. I've had to fix more of his home handyman repair time bombs than I'd care to mention. Needless to say as soon as the weather breaks this is going to be my next project.

I looked on the Internet and found this article: What is an ice dam? . In reading it I found the following information:


Dealing with ice dams

Immediate action:

Remove snow from the roof. This eliminates one of the ingredients necessary for the formation of an ice dam. A "roof rake" and push broom can be used to remove snow, but may damage the roofing materials.

In an emergency situation where water is flowing into the house structure, making channels through the ice dam allows the water behind the dam to drain off the roof. Hosing with tap water on a warm day will do this job. Work upward from the lower edge of the dam. The channel will become ineffective within days and is only a temporary solution to ice dam damage.

Long-term action:

First, make the ceiling air tight so no warm, moist air can flow from the house into the attic space.

After sealing air leakage paths between the house and attic space, consider increasing the ceiling/roof insulation to cut down on heat loss by conduction

I need to know what ELSE to do in order to prevent these ice dams from forming. I'd rather NOT run some kind of heat trace up there since any kind of electrical solution would be problematic. The attic below this room is insulated with that shredded paper that was so popular in the 80s. Would replacing this with fiberglass be an improvement? Also would those "gutter guards" help?

Thanks,

Dominic

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#2

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters(Long)

Tom MacGregor

>I used to work on older structures in Vermont. Proper ventilation is the key to solving ice dam problems. Ice dams are caused by heat melting snow on the upper part of a roof which refreezes when it reaches a cold spot. Insulation slows heat transmition but does not stop it. No amount of insulation will prevent ice dams if ventilation is not provided above it to keep the entire roof cold. The heat that makes it through the insulation must be able to exhast from convection provided by soffit vents, an air space over the insulation and gable or ridge vents. Each structure presents unique problems, especially if insulation has already been installed improperly. Find someone who understands that a roof is part of a system, not just a cover for your house and insulation. Perhaps a local Weatherization program? I repeat - from years of experience and many successful ice dam repairs - A cold roof = no ice dams. This is what the combination of insulation and ventilation must provide.

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#3

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Barry Irby

>I did not go read the article, so forgive me if I repeat something already in the article.

I am a Home Inspector so I know something about this. OTOH, Ice damming is not much of an issue in the Richmond Va area, so I don't have tremendous experience with it personally. (How's that for a disclaimer?)

Ice damming occurs under a fairly narrow set of conditions. There as to be snow on the roof and enough heat escaping from the house to melt it. What happens is the heat melts the snow. The heat rises pretty much straight up. So the snow above the living space melts, but the overhangs don't have the warmth coming up under them, so the water refreezes on the overhang, causing an ice dam. Water backs up above the dam and finds its way through the shingles and drools down near the outer wall of the house.

So, there is a bunch of stuff going on that is very temperature dependant. If the outside temperature is really cold, the warmth from the house is not enough to melt the snow. If the outside is too warm, the water does not refreeze. The color of the roof will have an impact. The sun will shine through a layer of snow and if the roofing below is black or a dark color the phenomenon will occur at a different air temperature than if the roofing is white or light colored.

For a quick (Relatively) fix you could set up a heat lamp and melt the dam. If you had a blower heater you might be able to melt the dam with that. Be Careful with a heat gun or what ever. You could try the water thing but I am sure I would flood my house doing that.

Keep this in mind. This is LEAK 101. Every leak has three parts. A HOLE for the water to go through, a FORCE that makes the water go through the hole, and ..... WATER. Take away any one of the three and the problem goes away.

So, In the long run there are several things you can do. When you replace the roofing, you could install an impervious barrier under the bottom three feet of shingles. The local code now requires it. Not sure about your Code. WR Grace makes Ice and Water shield for this purpose. There are several other brands. Its a sticky backed roll of rubbery material. The idea is that it is gooey and seals around the shaft of the nails. So, even with water standing above the dam, it most likely would not leak in. (It seals the HOLE.)

Another thing to do is to improve the attic insulation. I actually like the shredded paper stuff, but there is nothing wrong with adding fiberglass over it if that suits you better. Install baffles along the eaves to keep the insulation from touching the underside of the roof sheeting and yet be as deep as possible at the eave. The baffles also keep the insulation from falling out into the soffit and help to keep it from blowing around in the attic like snow drifts. (Baffles are made of cardboard or thin foam like egg cartons and are available at the borgs or from insulation suppliers.) Add more insulation. Go for R-38 or more. Also improve the soffit ventilation.

The idea is to keep the warmth in the house. (A good idea for other reasons as well.) And to let cold air flow under the bottom of the roof sheeting. This eliminates the temperature difference between the overhang and the roofing above the living space. This way, when mother nature melts the snow from the outside, it all melts at the same time and drools off the eave. (This eliminates the WATER standing above the dam seeking the holes.)

Would you like for me to describe what is wrong with your patio door and suggest how to fix it? Try Googling flashing a window or door. Check out a device called a Jamsill Guard.

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#4

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

>Tom is correct, it is a ventilation problem in conjunction with heat escaping from the house. I live in NW PA , we get lots of snow, and we had ice dams the first year we lived in out house. The next summer, I removed the peak vents and opened up the sheathing behind them so there was actual air flow occurring; no more ice dams for 25 years. My kids used to ask why our house never got ice sickles. Then about 5 years ago we had the roof and siding redone on our house. They put in a ridge vent the full length of the roof and decorative vents in the peaks. That very first winter we had ice dams every time we got more than an inch or two of snow over the roof vent. As soon as the ridge vent is partially clear the ice formation stops. The decorative vents have now been converted to functional vents in addition to the ridge vent so again we do not get ice dams or ice sickles.

Ventilation is the key. You have to keep the underside of the roof as cold above the heated area of the house as it is on the eaves.

Lee

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#5

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Barry,

You wrote:

"Would you like for me to describe what is wrong with your patio door and suggest how to fix it? Try Googling flashing a window or door. Check out a device called a Jamsill Guard."

Please do! :D

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#6

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Bill Howatt

>As others have said the proper fix is good insulation, very good ventilation and when you do the roof make sure you have impervious membrane installed as per the code which I think covers the first 3' or so from the eave.

Heating cable made for the purpose does work and while not visually ideal, it is a solution.

Using a roof-rake also helps but if you have a sizeable dam it won't fix that - you have to provide "drain holes" to let the water flow off the roof. I have chopped them with a hatchet but you must be very careful you don't cut the shingles and when the ice breaks up it can be stuck to a shingle and take part of it with the ice. Never bother to chop the ice when it is very cold, that is, it isn't melting which would help loosen the ice from the shingles.

The formation of dams and how your solutions deal with them is very dependent on the weather.

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#7

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Barry Irby

>Sometimes I feel like I babble on about this stuff and I'm not sure people want to know or read it.

You are right about your door. Its not flashed or not flashed well enough to do the job.

I don't have a sketch program, but you can Google how to flash a window or door to get pictures. I just check and the Jamsill Guard people are still there. I am not affiliated, but I have used their products several times and was happy with them. I have also made my own sill flashings on several occasions.

The sill flashing is basically a three sided tray or box the door sits in. Visualize the box a man's tie or maybe a necklace comes in. Stretch it out long enough that your door would sit in the box. Cut the two outside corners and fold that side down. So now you have a box six feet long (?) about four inches wide and an inch deep, with a lip hanging down on one side.

The store bought ones come in three pieces and over lap with a joint long enough that you can open them up or close them down a little to adjust the length to fit the door. the last one I bought was about 430, but that was long time ago. The plastic appears to be ABS, like black plumbing pipe. You glue the joints. One feature is that it has an internal sub sill with drainage grooves underneath.

So, remove the door, frame and all. If it has been leaking there may be rot under it. Repair the rot as necessary. This can be anywhere for nothing to terrific structural damage. If you find significant rot hit me up again. You should make the repairs with pressure treated wood so that if your flashing is less than perfect it won't rot again.

Once the repairs are made wrap the frame with impervious material. This is available at the borgs and other places. Its sold as window and door flashing. The last I bought was about ten inches wide and its similar to the Ice and water shield I described above. I found it a little tricky to handle with getting it stuck to itself. (It has a peel off paper backing like a bumper sticker, but it is very soft and flimsy once the paper is removed. I found it easier to put it on in relatively small pieces. I wrapped the sill before in set the sill flashing in place. I sued three pieces. One folded up each corner and one to fill in the center. Then set the sill flashing in place. Then one up each side lapping down to the inside of the sill flashing. And two or three across the top.

I don't know what type of siding you have, but the further this goes back onto the wall at the sides and the higher it goes above the door, the better. Keep the shingle concept in mind. The upper pieces lap over the lower pieces. Below the sill, pay attention to where the water goes. It must go past the framing and onto the foundation. If there is a deck, maybe you can use a flashing to send the water over the band board of the deck to the outside, not behind it.

When you reinstall the door you should put a Drip Cap type flashing above the door trim. More sticky flashing should go over the drip cap.

If you decide to foam the door into the opens, use the low pressure type foam designed for this application. DO NOT use the stuff in the red can. DAMHIKT.

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#8

PS

Barry Irby

>As you have gathered by now, keeping the heat form the house form getting to the underside of the roof sheathing is critical. the traditional approach has been to insulate the ceiling very well and use excellent attic ventilation to allow cold air to sweep up the under side of the roof and escape at the top. Continuous soffit vents coupled with good high vents are best. Locally ridge vents are considered the best, but in snow country I wonder?

I am wondering is insulating the under side of the roof deck would serve the same purpose. Supposedly the coming this is to spray foam on the under side of the roof. This keeps heat out in the summer. I have my doubts about this but it will be interesting to watch. I am concerned that spotting roof leaks would be tough. This will be fun to watch.

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#9

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Barry,

You wrote:

"Sometimes I feel like I babble on about this stuff and I'm not sure people want to know or read it."

I, for one, love reading your posts (including the OT's). You have a wealth of knowledge and experience to pass along and I appreciate you sharing it with me.

Al

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#10

Thanks Al, I appreciate that.

Barry Irby

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#11

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

>A couple of questions, is all the ice damming on the roof and eaves area or is the gutter full or both. If it is just on the roof the maintaining a "cold" roof will probably cure your problem. If you are getting a gutter full of ice and then backing it up on to the roof the cold roof will again probably slove the problem by not letting the snow melt in the first place. While I know you stated you dind't want to get involved with heat trace, If the gutter is involved I would run heat trace in the gutter and down the downspouts. I don't think leaf gaurds would help at all, water would still get in the gutter. I have found that heat in the gutters also helps slow down ice formation on the eaves of one of my buildings where I can not maintain a cold roof deck. A side note, heat trace can be installed anytime you can get the gutter clear enough to lay it in or even on top of the ice and let it melt itself in.

glc

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

#12

Re: OT: Preventing Ice dams on roof gutters

mark nowicki

>http://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/en/co/maho/gemare/gemare_001.cfm

Mark