Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

Posts

Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#1

Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

>I am evaluating options for an upgrade of my dust collection system, and was wondering if anyone could offer opinions on the Penn State Industries cylcone dust collectors? Specifically I am considering the 3.5HP cyclone:

http://www.pennstateind.com/store/TEMP1535S.html

I currently have a 1.5HP JET with a cartridge, and have considered three options 1) upgrading to a 3HP "double cartridge" model 2) building a cyclone and 3) buying a cyclone

Based on my research I feel like the price point for the Penn State cyclone is low enough to make me not want to go through the hassle of building my own cyclone. My main reservation is that I dont want to buy a piece of junk just because the price is right

Opinions?

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#2

JL

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

JL

>I presume you have already looked at the Grizzly G0441. I think that it is worthy of consideration. I also think the Clear Vue is worth looking at.

That being said - I've had mixed luck with PSI (and their former sister company MLSC) products. Some have been very reasonable. Others have not.

I've seen and "thumped" a number of Grizzly products. I've been reasonably impressed by most of them.

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#3

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

>I have looked at the Grizzly, and it is also a candidate for my shop. Once you add a remote control to the PSI the price is similar. I have not looked at Clear Vue

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#4

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

larry in kansas

>Have you looked at Oneida. I have had the 3HP for over 5 years, and very happy with it. I can`t tell you anything about PSI, but when I was looking, I wasn`t very happy with the person I talked to at the time. Have you goen to Bill Penz site? If not you should, it`s the best place to go and learn about DC. Larry

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#5

Penn State: poor support

John M in Mid Mich

>I have a bunch of Penn State clamps. Several have broken. Penn State says, "we don't sell them any more, you are out of luck: no warranty, no parts, no nothin'". Are you prepared for that? I don't buy there any more. YMMV.

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#6

JL

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

JL

>I have the Oneida 2 hp unit by the way. I've been happy with it. It is more expensive though.

The Clear Vue unit is a reasonable alternative - and you get to SEE the sawdust :D . Not that anyone would ever forget to check the drum and empty it before starting to plane a whole bunch of ash and red oak :O.

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#7

Re: Penn State: poor support

BilWil

>I'm of the same opinion re: their support. If you know what you want, and are willing to risk having to search for parts when repair time comes then I'd consider them when an item is on a really good sale.

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#8

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey

>I can't speak specifically about the cyclone. But, a fews years ago I worked just down the road from their location in NE Philly. They had a small showroom where you could look over some of the products they carried. In my opinion, most was of marginal quality. I was about to purchase a small dust collector from them and inquired about picking it up at their warehouse to avoid shipping costs. No way, that was way too much hassle for them to deal with. Needless to say, I dont' buy anything from them any more.

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#9

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

andy nistock

>I have used an Oneida for 3 years. Yes they are more expensive but the quality is worth the price. Mine has a Baldor motor and Oneida has been doing this for years. You may notice with the other brands that they all try to copy the oneida. Also Oneida is US made in Syracuse New york. Remember in many cases you get what you pay for. Good luck. Support USA made products, the job you save may be your own. Andy

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

#10

Re: Penn State Tempest cyclone opinions

Rick

>I have a 2.5 HP Tempest and have been perfectly happy with it.