Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Doug Fir and Furniture

Posts

Doug Fir and Furniture

#1

Doug Fir and Furniture

Bob Boswood

>Sometime ago, I acquired a pile of old growth doug fir from an old high school gym being refurbished. It comes to my attention that I am not going to outlast that pile of wood so I better get started on some projects. A bedroom set and some display cabinets comes to mind. Lots of panel construction. In previous quests in search of knowlege about various techniques, I learned how much strengthg can be achieved by gluing 1/4" plywood in door and frame panels. I can find no plywood in my area to match what I have. So my question is, given I have qtr sawn 45 yr old lumber,and a lot of 5/8 stock to work with, can I glue solid wood panels inot frame and door panels. Plan is to resaw 5/8 and glue up 1/4 " panels. Will I be asking for trouble? I can modify joinery to create stronger panels. Trying to avoid so many M&T's, more grooves and rabbets. Also any oppinions on even using fir for furniture would be appreciated.

Bob in AK.

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#2

There is a book

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>called "Solid-Wood Cabinet Construction" by Franz Karg that is mostly a picture book but also shows some construction details that you need to look at. One of the reasons I recommend it is that it highlights furniture and cabinets made from fir. It's largely European in design, and I would surmise from it and other comments that the Europeans are less married to the notion of making everything from hardwoods that we are.

I have that book and draw a lot of inspiration from both the designs and the possibilities that are expressed within.

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#3

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Bob - a lot of my earlier furniture was built with fir because it was cheap. Still going strong, though, even 30 years later.

Old growth fir is beautiful wood and finishes nicely; I wouldn't be adverse to using it now.

One thing I would advise against, though, would be glueing solid wood panels in any frame and panel construction. Even quarter sawn wood moves, it's a law of nature. A spot of glue on two sides will keep the panel from moving and allow it to expand and contract.

Have fun with your projects.

Doug

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#4

Lee Grindinger

Terminology may be the problem

Lee Grindinger

>Ask for vertical grain veneered sheet goods. Quarter sawn fir is called vertical grain, or VG fir. It was hugely popular and I'd be very surprised if it was not easily available from a decent hardwoods lumberyard.

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#5

Solid Wood Door Panels? Takes Balls *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"Space Balls" that is. You do NOT glue those panels in on the long grain, just a few spots in the top center of each panel, then the balls along the sides. Keeps the panels nice and rattle-free.


Link

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#6

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

Jesse Cloud

>You see a lot of Doug Fir furniture and fixtures out West. All of our doors, exterior and interior are Doug Fir. The panels are not glued, though, and they do move.

The doors have held up very well, though DF is fairly soft and will dent if mistreated. I love the long straight grain.

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#7

Thanks, Mark, but I've never liked Spaceballs

doug f, san clemente, ca

>For me they are a PITA to position and I've found they often take up too much room side to side. I put a drop of glue at the top and bottom in the middle and so far no problems. I know of several panels that I've built that have been around for almost 40 years and no splits yet.

Each of us has a favorite method because in woodworking there's almost always more than one way to make it work.

Doug

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#8

Re: Terminology may be the problem

Bob Boswood

>Once again I learned some thing today. Never heard of vertical grain, makes sense though, excellent description. I went to library picked up suggested book. At first I thought, way out of my style, after third look, I began to see what the author had to offer. That is what I like about woodworking. There is always another way to make a joint as well a different interpretation of the what you think the end product should look like. Once in awhile we hit with something that is at least to us, spectacular. I only wish I could have started this journey 40 years ago. Hope this site stays as pure to woodworking as it has been for short time I have been participating. Googles rec woodworking was good at first, but then became contaminated wuth people that had a lot more than woodworking on their minds. I have no idea how these sights work, but from what I can perceive, there is one person behind this great site and whatever that person is doing to keep the dumb---s from posting here,might I just say thanks for this sight. I do support a lot of the vendors represented. If there is someway to support them and have you make a buck, sign me up. Let me know please, it is knd of like being a good tipper for receiving good service.

Bob in AK

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#9

Many ways to support WC

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Bob - go to the upper left corner and click on "Home", the click on "Support WC." It outlines a number of ways to support the site.

The webmaster here, Ellis Walentine" does an outstanding job of keeping the content friendly, useful and concentrated on woodworking (well,... most of the time). ;)

One of the easiest ways to support the site is simply to contribute to the discussions and ask lots of questions. You'll be amazed at the depth of knowledge and experience you'll find.

Doug

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#10

take a step back......

Bill Tindall

>I am a wood oriented sort of woodworker so this advice is colored by this fact. I believe that some tree that took 500 years to grow beautiful wood deserves to become some well made and attractive piece of furniture.

I sat next to someone at our last club meeting and they were complaining about what a poor wood cherry was to work. They had built a table for their daughter. The top warped severely and they complained that the wood had numerous knots. Further discussion revealed that they had acquired the lumber from a local saw mill. Clearly, it was not dry and who knows what grade they may have bought. Also, clearly, this person was reaching too far to build something he had not yet acquired the skills to build. The result was failure and frustration.

You have some wood on hand that you will likely never be able to replace. This fact should be the main concern in determining what to do next. This wood is not the place to learn to do woodworking, though you may be close to being ready to use it. Step 1 should be to determine what you want to build. Step 2 is to learn what kind of skills it will take to build it. Step 3 is to acquire those skills and then practice them to be proficient. A class or a mentor can carry you through step 3 quickly. If there is a woodworking club in your area join it, make friends, and learn from them. Next build something that uses these skills where you will make mistakes and learn from them. Then use the fir to make some heirloom furniture.

Panels are not glued into frame and panel doors. Frames are made sufficiently strong that the panel is not necessary for strength, though it offers rigidity. Stuff is made the way it's made because during the last several hundred years of making stuff it has been determined what lasts and what doesn't. Don't try to invent new ways of building stuff, at least not yet.

There are lots of reliable ways to make a frame and panel door that mainly depend on the tools you have available. Most are not hard to learn. You will have to learn enough to pick a way that will result in a lasting door. Fitting and hinging the door will be harder to learn and should be practiced first. Again, a class or mentor will save years of trying to learn by trial and error.

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#11

The Splitz

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Never had a split, but I hate it when panels rattle when the door's bumped. Like when the door closes with a solid sound.

Positioning them is simple if you have a touch of CA glue. Just a spot in the mortise and press the ball in; stays put.

Re: Doug Fir and Furniture

#12

I've used that foam backer rod....

John in NM

>The stuff you put in big gaps before caulking to control shrinkage. Trickiest part is finding it small enough to use without having to quarter it first. Works great and has more compressive give than them balls.