Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

Posts

OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#1

OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

riley140

>All,

as always this board is a wealth of advice on all things so I thought you might be able to help with this question. If I have a very steep yard am I better off with a Lawn tractor with the fendor mount manual transmission or a pedal controlled automatic tranny. What I have read leans toward the fender mount manual for better control when mowing the slope. Although my Lawn is undert 3 feet of snow.... I wanted to movew forward with getting a tractor before spring.

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Regards,

Larry

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#2

JL

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

JL

>I have a fair bit of slope to the actual part of my property that I do mow.

I purchased a "preowned" John Deere with a hydrostatic transmission (AKA automatic). I prefer automatic. That way I can "hold on" with both hands and lean as necessary. The only issue is low gear. I'm not really hauling anything with my lawn tractor - I'm mowing. If I were hauling a lot, I might want a manual.

YMMV and other people will have differing opinions.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#3

Lawn and garden tractor WIKI

Grant in Iowa

>Larry,

I have had great interest in lawn and garden tractors for years. Mostly because of my growing up on a farm, but also because I just like to work on them and use them.

First, lets talk of the difference between a lawn tractor and a garden tractor. lawn tractors are designed to mow and tow lighter items such as a lawn cart or fertilizer spreader. They usually don't have a frame (unless we are talking about older machines). They tend to have a lightly built transaxle, might have either hydrostatic or gear drive transmission, and can last a long time so long as they aren't asked to do heavy work. A lawn with a steep hill might be more than they can handle long term. Many of these can accept snow blades, but I wouldn't recommend you do more than scrape a light snow off a drive with one you want to keep very long.

A garden tractor, in contrast, will usually be more heavily built, have a true subframe, and will typically have a more heavily built transaxle. These machines are designed to utilize tillers, snow blades, snowblowers and heavier implements. They often have hydraulic implement lift, and will generally last much longer and be much more repairable than a lawn tractor class machine.

If I were wanting to mow on a steep hill, here's what I'd look for:

A heavy duty machine, generally a garden tractor class machine. Not completely necessary, but the heavier machines will have a lower center of gravity, generally, which will help when navigating hills.

I'd not give the edge to either a hydrostatic or gear drive transmission, but would suggest if you go with a lawn tractor class machine, you get a gear drive machine. Cheap hydrostatic machines tend to have poorly built transaxles.

If you buy one, consider having it equipped with bar lug tires, which will not spin out on damp grass like the turf tires will. I find that spinning turf tires do much more damage than non spinning ag tires in the wet spots or steep hills. It has been my experience that ag style or bar lug style rear tires work well on a lawn, and don't do as much damage as you might think, unless the tractor you buy is over 1000 lbs or so...then I'd stay with turf tires due to soil compaction. If you find a machine that has a locking rear axle pedal (such as some John Deered and Cub Cadets), you might be OK with turf tires, depending on the steepness of your hills.

The dealership might deliver a machine with bar lug tires for the same price. if they want to charge you for the bar lug tires, then request the turf tires be included as well so you can sell them and recoup your cost (somewhat).

Consider having the rear tires filled with fluid, such as used antifreeze (available at any local auto repair place). Another option is calcium chloride, if you live in a rural area with farm implement dealers. The added weight inside the tire will help with center of gravity more than wheel weights will, because the liquid sits in the bottom of the tire, not around its center. Further, the liquid isn't as hard on the drive train when you stop and back up a lot, since it can slosh around and isn't tied to the rotation of the axles like wheel weights. Your first choice for weight to improve traction and center of gravity should be liquid in tires, second choice should be wheel weights, third choice should be suitcase weights on rear of tractor(third only because they tend to remove weight from the front axle).

I would definately NOT recommend a zero turn machine for a steep yard.

I would also go with a major brand machine that has dealerships such as John Deere, Toro, Cub Cadet, Ariens or Kubota. When you are down and need to mow/ move snow, etc. it is nice to have the support of a real dealership. Among the major brands, consider the closest dealership to home as an advantage, too.

There are a few more expensive options that might be worth considering, such as a Steiner(not sure if they are still made), or Kubota BX series and JD 2300 series machines, which are 4WD. There are other machines that are 4WD, but they are very costly. If you plan to have numerouse attachments, then consider the overall cost of machine plus attachments when deciding.

If you give us an idea of the size of your yard, and other tasks you want to do with the machine then we can provide more specifics on models that are good choices. Also tell us if you are considering new or used, and your mechanical experience. Might be good to choose a budget range, too.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#4

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

Galen Vetterick

>Mowed an acre of hill that seemed 45 degree slope. Gear drive John Deere did better than Cub Cadet hydrostatic drive I got later. Puts more power to the wheels for same Hp with gears. Can control downhill better by putting in lower gear. Hydrostatic started to freewheel. To put on the brake on the Cub you basically remove power by stepping on pedal and step on down to brake. It would freewheel so bad in the short time the small washer of a disc brake would not hold anything. Had to defeat the seat switch on both as your weight shifted to feet to brace over and down hill would normally kill the engine.

I agree with other post that turf tires are "slick" on a hill and less traction.

Neither had "high lift" blades as again they take more power from the engine and not needed unless you try to bag grass and I sure did not try on a hill.

Guy next door had a Sears hydrostatic and rolled it down a similar hill as high centered and little down hill control.

These were older models so maybe they have improved brakes you need on a hill.

Galen

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#5

Re: Lawn and garden tractor WIKI

riley140

>Hi Grant,

Thanks for the lesson. My yard is only 3/4 of an acre its the steep slope on one side that has me concerned, I know the previous owner used a "Riding Mower" but I don't have any details. I would guess the slope might be 20 degrees in one area. I know I managed to get my 4x4 f-150 stuck on the hill when I was moiving in and thought I would save myself some walking and backed down the hill to unload some stuff... I did get out though. Because of the hill I was leaning towards a gear drive machine I thought it might give me more control. My main focus will be mowing and maybe light hauling around the yard. I am on a budget I would like ot stay under 1700 no more then 2K. I was looking at the Craftsman mowers based on some recomendations. Here is one specifically: http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_12605_07128925000P?

Its 24 hoursepower Gear drive and weighs about 500 pounds with a cast iron axel. I would certainly value your opinion of this machine. Not sure yet what it would cost to swap out tires.

Thanks,

Larry

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#6

Re: Lawn and garden tractor WIKI

Grant in Iowa

>Larry,

If you want new, and that is your price range then the one you linked to is about the best you will likely be able to do. I have seen issues with the similar Cub Cadet, Toro and John Deere machines. I would think a gear drive machine would work better long term in your described application. That said, a hydraulic machine would be easier to handle trimming around the house and trees. Just know that entry level hydraulic transaxles are unreliable at best.

Depending on how handy you are, you might consider finding a used machine (watch Craigslist for people moving) from John Deere, or Cub Cadet, or Toro. in the same size range as what you posted. Most used machines will require some tinkering to resolve one or two issues upon purchase, but once that is done, you should have a reasonably reliable machine. I would tend to think that a 5 year old machine from JD could easily be found under $2000. If you can get into a garden tractor class machine, all the better.

if you consider yourself REAL handy, then I would suggest an older (80's or older) garden tractor such as a JD 318, Wheel Horse, Snapper, Ariens, Cub Cadet, etc. These are fixable, but will require tinkering on your part now and then.

Don't buy based on engine size alone. Look at tire size, robustness of the frame and transaxle, and build quality of the mower deck.

Generally, all of the machines in that price range that have been built in the past 20 years or so are rather disposable. If I had to buy one new for <$1700, I would likely gravitate towards Sears, since they usually have parts available. Big failure items on them are linkages, belts, and transaxles(transmissions). Companies usually place a larger than necessary engine on a machine, then skimp on the ever important transaxle.

When comparing machines from different manufacturers, look beneath the sheet metal at the rear transaxle. Cast Iron and a drain and fill capability are good things, though they are all but extinct on new machines. Die cast aluminum and no drain/ fill plugs are indicative of entry level disposable machines. They can give good service for the dollar, but judicious use and maintenance will be key. If comparing two machines with an aluminum transaxle, choose the beefier one.

I would not buy a used machine unless you are handy. Repair costs can be steep at repair shops.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#7

And I would add...

Grant in Iowa

>if you can swing it, or find one on clearance/ used... I'd take any GT series craftsman over any YT series... it's all in the build quality...look beneath at the rear end and also at the overall beefiness. larger tires will provide better traction, too (more surface area, or contact patch).

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#8

Great info Grant - second the bar tires

Ray - Middletown, IN

>Also, you can use winter weight winshield washer fluid in the tire for a cheap alternative. Slightly less dense than calcium chloride but less costly.

Ray

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#9

Re: Lawn and garden tractor WIKI

Carol Reed

>Wow! Great info!

I have little grass to cut but bunches of pine needles to haul and right now snow to push out of the way. This winter it came in 12" increments. Hope that is an aberration! Need to also keep my 85 year old neighbor's walk and drive clear.

I only have a half an acre, about to become slightly less if I get the new shop built this summer. But I'd rather haul it in a wagon than carry it, whatever "it" is.

There is one small engine issue that I need to deal with though. I am at 6200 feet. I need a high altitude carburetor or one that is adjustable. Many aren't anymore! Or diesel!

Needs to be small but not too small.

What do you suggest for those tasks?

I am patient and can watch craigslist as long as it takes. And I can tinker, so a fixer is possible.

Thanks for your suggestions.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#10

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

bob murphy

>Hi,

Thanks for the great info. I'm in the market for a tractor, myself. I live in WV so everything about my property is hills.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#11

ebd

Re: And I would add...

ebd

>Are you nuts? Crapsman? Compare the rear end of the Sears and a Wheelhorse. The trans case & axle on the Wheelhorse are vastly more solid than the Sears.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#12

ebd

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

ebd

>One thing to keep in mind - the hydrostatic costs you in effective horsepower ==> more gas less power. A 10-12 HP manual has the effective power of a 16 HP hydrostatic. That from a dealer who has a vested interest in selling the more expensive hydrostatic machines.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#13

Re: Lawn and garden tractor WIKI

Grant in Iowa

>Carol,

I would look for an old garden tractor. Clutch or hydro would be fine, they are both reliable. There were many made up through the 80's that are near bulletproof. They might require some tinkering as I have said to get them in good working order, but they'll last indefinately so long as you know which way to turn a screwdriver and tighten anything that gets loose.

I just recently sold a 1977 Wheel Horse C-160 with all of the attachments because I purchased a Kubota BX2200. It still performed well after 30+ years of regular use. My goal was twofold: something more user friendly so my wife would feel comfy mowing and moving snow when I am out of town. Further, I wanted a larger machine for logs to lumber use, and also a loader.

But I digress. When talking pulling power, it is all about tractor weight, traction, and gearing. You can probably get away with an old lawn tractor, but finding an old garden tractor, regardless of engine size would be a sure bet. many of the machines from the late 60's came with 6-10HP single cylinder engines. This didn't mean they would do less work then modern machines, just not as fast. Today, it is common for 20+ HP engines to be on new machines. The huge horsepower of todays machines does allow one to mow faster, but you often give up drivetrain reliability and build quality elsewhere as a result. It costs little more for a manufacturer to build a 24 Hp engine than one rated at 16HP...same number of parts, just a bit larger...so horsepower creep has made its way to the marketplace.

So, A garden tractor of a common brand available in your area. Older is usually better built, but they'll come with a problem or two that might need resolved before reliable use. Some good machines from the 70's and 80's are: John Deere, Wheel Horse/Toro, Snapper, Cub Cadet, Allis Chalmers, Ford, Ariens... you would do well to visit some local lawn and garden dealerships to see what is common in your area. There are many older lower horsepower gear drive machines that are very simple (translation: easy to fix), and can get the job done.

To tow a yard cart, plow the occasional patch of snow, and mow a smaller lawn, an older lawn tractor would likely do you fine. The lawn tractors of the 80's are usually as well built as the garden tractors available today at the big box stores. A John Deere 260 would be a decent place to start looking.

Try to find one that has been used regularly, instead of one that has been in a shed for years. You don't want bad fuel, dirty carbeurator, rusty cylinder walls, dryrotted tires. One with regular use from the early 80's would be a good bet.

Watch Craigslist under farm and garden and don't jump on the first one you see. Instead, use the first several as a learning opportunity and google that make and model to see what goes wrong with them. I like to google something like "John Deere 110 problem" to see what goes wrong with that model often, so you know what to check when going to look at one.

I am not an expert on your altitude issue, but I do know that almost any engine from the mid eighties or older will have the ability to adjust the carbeurator mixture for your altitude. You are correct that many newer engines don't have that capability.

Again, don't shop on horsepower. Horsepower is a measure of how fast work can be done, not IF it can be done. An 8 horsepower old single cylinder garden tractor from the 70's can drag almost any big-box store 20+ HP twin cylinder machine around by the drawbar. Your challenge is to find one in good working order. Take it for a spin around that yard.

In my area, a machine like I've described can be had for $300-$700 or so pretty regularly. Your mileage may vary in your neck of the woods.

Try to pick a common brand for your area to improve your chances of finding any attachments that fit it later on. Note that a lawn tractor snowblade for a given model will not likely work on another model, and certainly not on a different brand machine.

I should reiterate that these older machines WILL require a certain amount of mechanical ability now and then. Having or knowing someone with a welder can be necessary at times to fix them. There is a HUGE comunity of people online who can help with repairs, parts, etc. Decide for yourself if tinkering now and then is for you and yours. If not, look for a new(er) machine. That said, almost anyone with average reading ability and basic hand tools can expect to maintain one themselves, given the ambition and the desire to learn.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#14

No, I am not nuts, just misread often

Grant in Iowa

>There is absolutely a night and day difference between the two machines. That said, we have to consider the situation:

$1700 to spend. If it were me, I'd buy an old garden tractor with several attachments. But I am an odd farm kid, have too much time on my hands, and like cast iron. I was pretty clear that the older garden tractors are built much better than anything new (at that or even a $5000 price point). There is no argument there.

What was saying, is that if you HAVE to buy new (perhaps not a cash purchase?) at that price point, then bang for buck wise the Craftsman machines are probably as good as any. As has been the case for years, the major brands all share major assemblies with each other. Engines and transaxles all come from major suppliers and not the company who put their name on the machine (at least 90% of the time). Don't think for a minute you'll get more for your $1700 by buying a Sabre or John Deere or Toro/Wheel Horse. They are good machines, just not bang for buck wise.

Again, there is no doubt that mid-80's and earlier garden tractors with a Sundstrand hydro or gear drive rear end are bulletproof major component wise, and that is why I mentioned that as an option for the mechanically inclined. But they can suffer from worn linkages, leaks, tired electrical systems, etc. Not everyone has the ability or wants to tinker with an old machine that has many hours on it. Sure, they are fixable, maintainable, and perform nicely when operating but it just isn't an option for some buyers.

My comment about the Sears machines were perhaps misleading. I should have said "At that price point" and "if you must buy new" in there a few times. Sorry if I wasn't clear.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#15

Thanks, Grant!

Carol Reed

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#16

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Let me see, I think the original question was about a LAWN TRACTOR.

So trying to keep on subject, if you want the last lawn MOWER you will ever need to buy, get a Scag. I have their smallest model with a 19 hp Kawasaki V2 engine and a hydrostatic transmission that does exactly what you ask of it. If you are moving along at 8mph and slam the controls into neutral, you will leave skid marks. It is no light weight, it brings to the table around 1100 lbs. The chassis is made of tubular steel. Oh yes, it is a zero-turning mower. You don't know what you have missed all these years until you have a ZTR machine.

They only come in one color, orange; they are the mowers you see around large businesses with large grassy areas.

Just a happy user,

Ken


Scag mowers

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#17

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

Thomas S Stockton

>Bob,

You didn't say whether you wanted a lawn tractor or something larger, but my experiance with a bigger tractor (26hp diesel) with a HST is that I get no freewheeling when going down steep hills and if you are doing any kind of loader work it makes it really simple and fast to use. In low range the thing will crawl down a hill however slow you want to go.

I looked at lawn tractors years ago and for the same price I ended up with a 1946 Ford 2n and a brush hog type mower for less money. The down side was you need to be handy to keep it running and when it came time for a rebuild on the engine I took the money and used it on a down payment for something new.

Tom

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#18

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

John K Jordan

>Ken, I use a 25 horse Kubota diesel zero turn mower for around my farm (I mow acres, some with nice hills) and would not trade it for anything. Stable, powerful, fast, smooth. With a 60" cut I can mow twice as fast as my smaller 18 horse zero turn and at least eight times as fast than my previous lawn tractor.

However, some here asked about towing trailers or perhaps implements - the zero turn is not much good for this AFAIK. A lawn or garden tractor would be better for towing. What I find best for towing is a run-of-the-mill 4-wheeler.

JKJ

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#19

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

Thomas S Stockton

>as for only coming in orange that's why spray paint was invented.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#20

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

iew

>John Deere Hydrostat is the only way to go. I own 3 of them.

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#21

Re: No, I am not nuts, just misread often

riley140

>Grant,

Thanks for all the info and I understood perfectly. While I am handy I am my new house is a major fixer upper so I don't really have time for the tinkering but I will consider that for the future. For now i'm just going to cut the grass and focus my repair efforts on the inside.

Thanks Again,

Larry

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmision

#22

Re: OT Lawn Tractors - Manual or Automatic transmi

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi John.

You have a real beast at your beck and call.

I looked at the Kubota when I was in the market, but they were more than I was willing to spend. They are a good machines. I am partial to diesel engines. My Bluetec E320 gets in the mid 30s MPG on the highway, and 28 to 30 around town, along with a cool 390 pound-feet of torque off the starting line. :)

I only mow a couple acres. It is nice to be finished when my neighbor is only halfway done on his John Deere.

BTW, DFW airport got 12 1/2 inches of snow yesterday, a new record.

Happy saw dust,

Ken