Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

How high should the saw blade be?

Posts

How high should the saw blade be?

#1

How high should the saw blade be?

Bill Tindall

>Last night our club had a program on saw blades given by a person from Freud (who would be delighted to give your club a program).

In addition to providing informative information on how the blades are designed and manufactured there was advice on selection and use.

The tooth angles of Freud blades are designed to be used with half the length of the carbide teeth projecting above the cut.

The blades are designed to be used this way because Freud believes this is the safest way to use a blade-"laceration, not amputation". I agree wholeheartedly. Because Freud blades have adequate side clearance of the teeth they can be used in this configuration without excessive pitch build up.

We were told that the main wear factor is heat which results from dirty blades.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#2

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

Barry Irby

>From my Experience....I have no test data and have done no research on the topic...So, from my experience, I agree.

I use a Forrest WW11 blade most of the time and I generally set it with the teeth just projecting through the top of the cut. There is less exposed blade to get tangled up in and I find my dust collection to be much more effective. I built an enclosure around the blade on my contractors saw and I find it does a much better job of eliminating the sawdust coming off the top of the blade if the blade is low.

Occasionally I run the blade all the way up if I am making a stopped cut to get the end of the cut to be nearly vertical. I suspect this causes the back of the cut piece to try to lift. It obviously exposes enough of the blade to take a finger or hand off in a heartbeat.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#3

Clint Searl

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

Clint Searl

>Safety issue aside, which seems to be more opinion than fact, it seems to me that the lower the blade, the more teeth are in the wood at a time, resulting in the motor having to work harder to cut an effectively thicker piece of wood as well as maximizing the kickback force.

Clint

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#4

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

Jorge Casta�eda

>Bill,

That was the same recommendation I got from John Gardner, a master boat builder and writter, when I was an apprentice at Mystic Seaport, a lifetime ago. When somebody asked how high the saw blade should be, his standard answer was "That depends of how much you want to cut out your hand" Then proceed to recommend only about 1/16".

Jorge

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#5

my mentor offered equivalent advice

Bill Tindall

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#6

Clint, Sometime there are other considerations

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>Next time you are in your shop, why don't you take chisel and see if you can tell any difference between pushing it through the wood at 90� to the grain, or at ~30� or whatever angle the front of the tooth cuts through the wood.

Most of the time, when you make a change to improve one thing, like fewer teeth in the cut, there is a trade off of another aspect. It makes more sense to change to a blade with fewer teeth if that is the goal.

That is my 2�

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#7

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

wilbur

>A quick eyeball measurement shows that for a 40 tooth 10" blade, if you are ripping a 8/4 board, there are 3-4 teeth cutting with the blade raised fully, and about 6 teeth cutting if you have the blade raised so that it just barely cuts through the board. I have a hard time seeing how having 2 less teeth in the kerf is a benefit that's worth the 14 teeth that are going to be exposed with a fully raised blade.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#8

another consideration

Bill Tindall

>We were told that the tooth geometry of the Freud blades, and likely everyone else except Forest, are designed to perform best with half the tooth's carbide sticking above the cut. Seems that should end the discussion of where to put a Freud blade. Forest blades accumulate pitch in this low configuration as a result of a different tooth geometry.

With a low blade setting I am perfectly comfortable ripping as small as 2" face frame strips with my fence between my first and second fingers, my first finger holding the piece down and my thumb pushing the piece (a major advantage of old style narrow fences). Not likely I would saw this way with the blade fully up.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#9

Re: another consideration

Sgian Dubh

>"With a low blade setting I am perfectly comfortable ripping... with my fence between my first and second fingers, my first finger holding the piece down and my thumb pushing the piece (a major advantage of old style narrow fences)."

I don't even begin to understand why you would use that technique Bill. Why not simply pick up a bird's mouth style push stick that is about 14" or 16" long and keep thumb and fingers well away from the blade? In truth, you probably have more control of the wood with this type of push stick than you do with the pad of your thumb.

With a bit of practice the movement of the wood past the blade is as fast using a combination of starting the cut by pushing the wood using two hands, continuing the forward motion with the left while you pick up the stick with your right hand, and finishing the cut using only the push stick in your right hand.

Maybe I'd understand your choice of technique if I was American and brought up using those methods. In truth, even though I lived and worked in the US for ten years, I never could get used to how American woodworkers use woodworking machinery. Slainte.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#10

Re: another consideration

FredD

>Richard,

This is one American that uses a push stick , make my won and like you said practice is the key and I find that I have no trouble starting the rip with the birds mouth holding down the wood.

Still have all of my digits at 72 and counting ;-))

FredD

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#11

simple answer-safest

Bill Tindall

>I consider this way of ripping safest. With the fence between my 1st and second finger my hand is restricted in where it can go. There is no risk of my hand chasing after something unexpected, like the piece dropping off the back of the saw. On a 2" rip cut my thumb is the only digit that can reach the blade, which is only 1/8" above the lumber. Given that the force of the thumb is forward there seems little chance that some event would cause the thumb to travel orthogonal to the direction it is pushing and engage the blade. The lumber passes through with one smooth motion, no hesitation.

Most saw accidents seem to result from lack of control of the lumber being cut. With a finger pressing down and a thumb pushing there is no chance for loss of control. The lumber can't lift (the worse loss of control problem). My left hand NEVER travels past the front table edge. I hang a thumb down to make contact with the table edge so I know it is time to switch complete control to the right hand which is already in position over the fence.

This technique can not be done with the modern wide saw fences and for that reason I have no interest in owning one, nor do I find them in any way superior to the old style Delta fence, which is not only narrow but also has holes through it for ease of attaching things with screws needed for certain saw operations.

Set an inch wide board on edge, engage it deep between your 1st and 2nd fingers and see how secure this arrangement feels. (It might not unless you round the edges a bit!)

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#12

Re: simple answer-safest

Sgian Dubh

>"Given that the force of the thumb is forward there seems little chance that some event would cause the thumb to travel orthogonal to the direction it is pushing and engage the blade. The lumber passes through with one smooth motion, no hesitation."

Bill, I'm afraid that, despite your conviction that the method you describe is the dog's bollox when it comes to safe wood feeding into a saw blade, you'll never hear of me attempting your thumb pad feeding manoeuvre.

As I said in my earlier message, I really don't understand why quite a few American style woodworking machinery techniques are considered 'safe' over there.

Anyway, do please look after that thumb of yours-- I'm still looking for a couple of images of termites when they get active enough to spot going about their business, and you did mention you might be able to get a picture or two for me. I'd hate to think your camera clicking technique could be hampered because of a heavily bandaged thumb, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#13

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

john lucas

>This is interesting. I agree that the less blade that is through the wood the less chance for injury. However I never use my hands anywhere near the blade. I use push sticks exclusively. I'll admit at first it was a little awkward on some cuts but after years doing it it's just like using my hands and I never get near the blade.

Now I get back to the other question. No one has discussed how the blade pushes on the wood. When the blade is higher it cuts more in a downward motion. When it's low it's more of a foward motion pushing the wood back at you. Since the only accident I've had on a table saw in 25 years of using one was a kick back I tend to run the blade a little higher than just the teeth showing. I don't run it up high. Just high enough to pusy more down than forward.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#14

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

John K Jordan

>I read the results of a study once where the author tested actual forces from various blade height/wood thickness geometries. I remember the difference in the vector (direction) of the force was significant. He recommended a higher blade for safety.

You never get kickback from a bandsaw where the cutting force is always straight down.

JKJ

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#15

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I'm with you John. I use the blade gaurd and push sticks. I don't really want my hands near enough to the blade for the amount of tooth sticking up above the wood to make a bit of difference. I do prefer more downward than backward force.

glc

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#16

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

Carol Reed

>In all fairness though, with a band saw, there are no teeth coming back UP the backside of the cut. That's what lifts the board and tosses it back at you.

Push sticks - always, always, always. I like the kind that holds the wood down and pushes it along, not just a stick with a bird's mouth cut. That only pushes.

Pattern in my book, if you're interested.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#17

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

John K Jordan

>>with a band saw, there are no teeth coming back UP the backside of the cut.

You are correct, of course.

A properly aligned table saw, sawing with the guard in place, use of the splitter to keep the kerf from closing from released stress, staying out of the line of fire, safe footing and posture, minimized distractions, hold-downs/feather boards especially for dados and extreme cuts, and using push sticks so the hands are ALWAYS far from the moving blade - the saw can be operated safely.

I very much liked what I read somewhere about pushing wood around any power tool with the hands - always imagine where your hands would go if the wood were to suddenly disappear. !!!

JKJ

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#18

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>John, Back when I was learning woodworking, I probably made every mistake that one can make without loosing digits. Those old tools were not very well tuned, nor did they have any safety gear.

I can tell you first hand, that a high blade kickback does not send the projectile low into the abdomen, but rather higher in the head to shoulder height, relative to the shortness of the object. I was lucky not to have lost an eye or teeth, even though there wasn't much chance of loosing fingers. Fear of loosing fingers was part of the reason leading to the kick-back.

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#19

Long Time Freud Advice

Howard Acheson

>Here is something Freud has been publishing for a number of years.

QuOTE

I feel this one has been rehashed a few times but I must interject again that if you are using the correct Freud blade for the application, the blade should be set so that 1/2 of a tooth is protruding through the material. So, if you are cutting 3" thick material with a 10" blade, the blade would be at full height. The idea is to have 3-5 teeth in the cut when ripping and 5-7 for crosscut and manmade materials. If you cannot acheive this and keep the blade at 1/2 tooth height, you have the wrong blade for the application.

------------------

Charles M

Freud, Inc.

CLOSE QUOTE

Re: How high should the saw blade be?

#20

absolutly right and a recommendation for beginners

Bill Tindall

>Kick back results from loss of control of the material. This is a much greater issue when one is gaining experience on the table saw. Early on I had all sorts of missiles and dents in the wall behind the saw. I haven't had a kickback incident in many many years. I know now what to avoid, for example trying to rip or crosscut small pieces or diddling with small cutoffs bouncing against the blade. And as important I am more comfortable around the saw, especially about using my hands to securely hold stuff down, and against the fence or miter. Trying to nervously push something through the saw with insecure push sticks is a sure way to get a kick back. You are absolutely right, if you are unduly worrying about your hands, you can wind up not worrying enough about control of the piece.

About 3-4 years ago I installed a 7 1/2 very thin kerf blade on the saw for a special purpose and would up leaving it there except for special purposes. An ordinary framing blade works fine and a quality blade some better. There is so little cutting force with such a blade that it may be impossible to get a dangerous kick back. I feel vastly more secure sawing with such a blade. On occasions when I need the full 10" for some special reason it has become intimidating using it. I was ripping 2" frame stock the other day and I felt more at ease with the 7 1/2" blade than if I was using a band saw. The fact that it is so quiet I think is an important factor in its enhanced safety. It is easier to concentrate on the task at hand.