Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Comparing electric motors?

Posts

Comparing electric motors?

#1

Comparing electric motors?

Joe Pack

>I am looking for a 1725 rpm motor, 1/2 to 3/4 hp TEFC to install on a sander. After a bad experience with used, I am looking at new. Local motor shops offer Dayton, Marathon, GE, Baldor, AO Smith and some others that I don't remember. One offered me a Baldor 1/2hp TEFC for $169. There is an ebay possibility of a new Dayton 3/4hp for +/- $100. I have heard that Baldor is "the" motor, but is it the best buy? How do the brands I have listed compare for my use on a home hobby shop sander that would be run =/- 2 hrs/week?

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#2

Re: Comparing electric motors? *LINK*

Roy Anderson

>IMHO, for home hobby use, they will all be adequate. TEFC, as you probably know, means totally enclosed, fan cooled, which is good 'cause it keeps sawdust out of the windings.

I'm sure an industrially trained electrical engineer can cite you chapter and verse about which has the best specifications for hard duty in a factory. Big deal! I'm an engineer also, and I recently bought A.O. Smith because I got the best price on theirs. Dayton and Leeson also make an extensive line of motors of adequate quality.

There are motors specifically designed for woodworking duty. See the link for an example. Just Google up woodworking electrical motors.


woodworking electrical motors

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#3

Re: Comparing electric motors?

Marvin Horn

>As the above post says, any should work for hobby use. I recently ran across something to watch out for though. My new higher quality (American) 3hp DC fan motor has essentially the same rated FL amps as the old Grizzly (Chinese) 2HP. Never realized that they could vary that much.

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#4

Re: Comparing electric motors?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Baldor is definitely "the motor". Amp draw is usually a good indicator of true horsepower. There are some differences due to efficiency, but there are lots of scams as to HP these days. Heavier weight is a good indicator of quality. More steel and copper means it will take more heat before letting the smoke out. Plant I worked at had three 1 1/2 HP Dayton motors snap their shafts off between the bearing and the pulley. This happened over three days. The Baldor replacement is still running, twelve years later. Previous Dayton motor had lasted ten years in a 115� environment. A Baldor or Leeson should be a lifetime purchase.

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#5

Re: Comparing electric motors?

Barry Irby

>I can't argue with any of the above. Bill had bad luck with Dayton motors. OTOH, I have had a 2hp Dayton TEFC motor on my contractor TS for at least 25 years and it is working perfectly.

The Amps draw is the best thing to use comparing power.

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#6

A Motor by any other name...

Forrest Addy

>A Motor by any other name i still be a motor. I don't know what your bad experiencee was but it' really hard to make a motor fail so long a you keep it dry, feed it the right kind of electricity, and stay within its load ratings.

Induction electrc motors are a product of a century of ndustrial evolution. They are for all practical purpoes a commidity item. There is so much practical experience with induction motors that their design is left to a guy who plugs parameter into a computer and what emetges is complete manufacturing data and detaled drawings.

All the US made brands you mention will serve your simple requirements. TEFC is a good choice for your application because it exclude dut from the wndings and the start switch. Most sanders are easily overloaded. Since the previous motor failed, I suggest you bump up the power of the replacement to 1 HP and seriously consider a 1.15 service factor.

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#7

Re: A Motor by any other name...

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

>I agree with Forrest, the only motors I have had any problems with in the last 10 years were Chinese manufactured. The only real problem with them were two had capacitors (also Chinese made) fail and one had a starting switch that was not adjusted properly. I repaired all under warranty (they sent the parts). I did purchase a new motor for a Powermatic PM-90 lathe I converted to single phase. After much searching, I found the most economical motor with the best specs. was a Leeson Farm duty. I'm not sure what frame size, voltage or RPM you are needing. But a 1 hp Leeson Farm duty capacitor start, TEFC 56 Frame, 115/230 Volt, reversible with a 1.15 service factor runs about $165 new at the one site I checked. May find one cheaper if you do some searching.

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#8

Re: A Motor by any other name...

Jerry Gibbs

>What is a 1.15 service factor?

Re: Comparing electric motors?

#9

1.5 service factor (google)

del schisler

>The service factor - SF - is a measure of periodically overload capacity at which a motor can operate without overload or damage

Sponsored Links

The service factor - SF - is a measure of periodically overload capacity at which a motor can operate without overload or damage. The NEMA (National Electrical Manufacturers Association) standard service factor for totally enclosed motors is 1.0.

A motor operating continuously at a service factor greater than 1 will have a reduced life expectancy compared to operating at at its rated nameplate horsepower.

NEMA Service Factor at Synchronous Speed (RPM) for drip proof motors:

Power

(HP) Service Factor - SF

Synchronous Speed (RPM)

3600 1800 1200 900

1/6, 1/4, 1/3 1.35 1.35 1.35 1.35

1/6 1.25 1.25 1.25 1.25

3/4 1.25 1.25 1.15 1.15

1 1.25 1.15 1.15 1.15

1 1/2 and up 1.115 1.15 1.15 1.15

Example - Service Factor

A 1 HP motor with a Service Factor - SF = 1.15 can operate at

1 HP x 1.15

= 1.15 HP

without overheating or otherwise damaging the motor if rated voltage and frequency are supplied to the motor.

Insulation life and bearings life are reduced by the service factor load.

Sponsored Links

Related Topics

Electrical Amps and electrical wiring, AWG - wire gauge, electrical formulas, motors and units

Related Documents

Torques in Electrical Motors There are some common torques used to describe and classify electrical motors

Power Factor for a Three-Phase Electrical Motor Power Factor definition for a three-phase electrical motor

Electrical Motor Efficiency Calculating electric motor efficiency

Sponsored Links

ToolBox Short List

Difficult to find your favorite ToolBox page? Add links to your favorite pages in your own personal Short List!

� Add this Page! � Delete the ShortList!

Engineering ToolBox - SketchUp Edition - Online 3D modeling!

Engineering ToolBox - SketchUp Edition - enabled for use with the amazing, fun and free Google SketchUp.

Search the ToolBox

Web The Engineering ToolBox

Translate the ToolBox

Arabic - Chinese (Simplified) - Chinese (Traditional) - Dutch - French - German - Italian - Japanese - Korean - Portuguese - Russian - Spanish

About the ToolBox

We appreciate any comments and tips on how to make The Engineering ToolBox a better information source. Please contact us by email

thorfot@yahoo.com

if You find any faults, inaccuracies, or otherwise unacceptable information.

The content in The Engineering ToolBox is copyrighted but can be used with NO WARRANTY or LIABILITY. Important information should always be double checked with alternative sources. All applicable national and local regulations and practices concerning this aspects must be strictly followed and adhered to.

Advertise in the ToolBox

If you want to promote your products or services in this site - please follow this link.

� The Engineering ToolBox 2005

9 12 8