Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

Posts

What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#1

What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I went to my favorite hardwood lumber yard yesterday to get some Honduras mahogany only to find they don't have any, can't get any and haven't been able to get it for several years.

I made a tv cabinet around 15 years ago and used it for the frame. It was the best planing wood I've ever used. It was the perfect choice for a wine cabinet for my son and DIL. But instead I came home with African mahogany.

What's up with that?

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#2

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

DouginDenver

>I can buy it in Denver. Any thickness to 16/4.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#3

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hey Bruce,

Either try Woodfinder or you have a road trip to Denver.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#4

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I guess so. However, the place I go to, Youngblood Lumber in Mpls is one of the largest hardwood yards anywhere. They told me they can't get it.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#5

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Suggest that they call Doug's Place in Denver :D :D

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#6

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

del schisler

>You have to watch some place's can sell Sapele, also know as Sapelli, Penkwa, Undianuno, or Entandrophragma Cylindricum, a reddish-brown very similar to mahogany, is large African tree It is very good wood You cant tell the difference I use sapele all the time very hard and dense Like i said look's like the honduras I belive they have put a ban on cutting and shipping the honduras mahogny Get some sapele and try it

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#7

Export ban

Bill Tindall

>The last I heard on the topic, about a year ago in WoodShop news.......

Mahogany has not been available from Honduras for many years. Many years ago the government was limiting export to finished articles. The supply of South American mahogany has gotten depleted with the remaining reserves being located in Chili and Brazil. So much lumber was being pirated from these countries that they put a total export ban on logs and lumber. Occasionally some plantation material shows up but it is pale in color and light weight. There is a place in NY that claims to have S. American material ("Irion" lumber of something like that).

The "african" stuff is all over the map. Some is dense and dark red, other is light and much has wild stripey grain.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#8

ah ha!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I was wondering if it wasn't something like that. Well, we can't cut down everything...

Thanks, Bill.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#9

Re: ah ha!

Todd Stock

>Bigleaf mahogany (aka Honduran, South American, Brazilian, etc.) is a CITES App. 2 plant, so by international convention, producing countries may export mahogany, but the wood may not be re-exported in unfinished form. What this means is that the wood can still be imported to the US or any other country, it can be freely sold within that country, but a US vendor cannot sell unfinished wood (as in final product; e.g., turned bowl or guitar) to someone outside the US (no re-exportation).

I suspect the real reason why your vendor has chosen not to carry mahogany is that there are higher profit, less expensive substitutes such as sapele and khaya, and shelf space in a brick and mortar is a constraint.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Why...

Ellis Walentine

>...is a turned bowl or a guitar considered an unfinished object?

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#11

only part correct, conclusion flawed

Bill Tindall

>While the regulations you state are the result of international agreement any country has the authority to control export in any way. What I have read from authoritative sources is that to curtail pirating countries have imposed an export ban. An additional motivation is to keep the species in the home country to support manufacturing in the home country. Honduras traditionally exported logs. Twenty years ago when we carried some mahogany inventory the lumber was, by law, sawed in Honduras to provide jobs in Honduras. I suspect this trend has now extended to making stuff from the sawed mahogany in the home country.

As far as your conclusion, it is simply ridiculous. With mahogany selling for $10 bdft, when it can be found in old inventory, I am certain as a former hardwood supplier that any business would trade some poplar storage for a place to put some S. American mahogany if they could find some. It would not have to be stored very long as there is considerable pent up demand.

With a growing interest in period furniture (note growth of SAPFM membership) these woodworkers are in a bind. The wood essential to make reproductions is disappearing. The substitutes are substitutes and obviously so. With all my contacts I still had a difficult time finding even 100 bdft for a friend 2 years ago. A former supplier that used to import ship loads of mahogany didn't have any source of S. American material.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#12

I miss it!

Tony - Memphis

>Most of everything I built for years was honduran mahogany. I have two 12/4 boards about 8' x 7" left. I'll probabaly use those for leg stock and use sappele for the rest of my projects. I've used the sappele (not sure I spelled that correctly) and it works pretty well. Just bought some makore that looks a lot like some kind of mahogany. I'm anxious to work it and see how it finsihes. I'd love to get some Cuban sometime and build soemthing with it. I've seen pile of it before, but never used any.

Tony

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#13

Well now I wonder

DouginDenver

>I said I can buy it in Denver, although it has been a few months since I have looked - much less than a year though. Now I need to go look again. I have previously purchased it from at least three places here.

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#14

Re: Why...

Todd Stock

>A bowl or guitar is a finished object, so export from US is not an issue. Re-exporting unfinished material is the issue - check any of the folks that do some international business (Luthier's Mercantile, etc.) and you'll see that they will not sell bigleaf lumber, parts, or anything that is in an 'uncompleted' state (e.g., tonewood sets) except for use within the US.

I don't doubt that period furniture guys want the best substitute for Cuban possible, and that's pretty much been bigleaf. The problem is that for every hardcore period furniture builder, there are a couple hundred Joe Woodworkers shopping for wood by general color and texture. Spanish cedar, sapele, khaya, and half a dozen other woods are just dandy with them, and the margin on and availability of these woods is better.

As to the shelf space issue - not so much my opinion as what folks currently in the business are telling me. I have three hardwoods dealers that I hit every few weeks, and all of them have pretty much the same story:

- Nearly all customers are happy with substitutes (most cannot tell the difference in any case...maple is white, cherry is pink, and mahogany is brown)

- Those that insist on bigleaf will usually either wait for a special order from one of the wholesalers or go up to one of the specialty vendors (usually Northland, Irion, Hearn, or others catering to those

Re: What happened to Honduras Mahogany?

#15

Re: only part correct, conclusion flawed

Todd Stock

>A few thousand hobby and small shop woodworkers will keep a couple decent sized shops in business if they all parked themselves in one small city. As it is, assuming every member of the organization does a major piece once a year (can we say doubtful?), that means that the local hardwoods places might sell a 100-200 board feet a year. It's not that period furniture makers, luthiers, and other hobby and small shop specialties are not important to some dealers, but they are simply too small a market to be important to every dealer.

See my other note for more. I hear what you are saying, Bill, but the dog wags the tail for the businesses around here - not the other way around.