Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT Photo Manipulation

Posts

OT Photo Manipulation

#1

OT Photo Manipulation

Gary Smyth

>A couple of days ago Mr. Norton asked about photo organization/control. The answers served well but I need the other photo support -- photo manipulation. I've been doing some reading, but I thought I'd ask. I'm looking for software for XP and 7 that will allow me to go further with options than Picasa but (maybe) not have to go as far as full blown Photoshop. I need to be able to correct/change color, convert to a line drawing, expand size to plotter size, eliminate sections of a photo by editing in neutral background, move edited images to other software and locations, as well as crop and layer. Picasa does some of these things, some not well, and some not at all. Photoshop may be the best for what I want but is there anything else (that works, i.e. doesn't hang up and is capable) out there that is less expensive? I'm looking for recommendation AND lowest cost.

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#2

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

Jerry Nicholson

>Photoshop Elements is available for less than $100 and should do what you want but I haven't used it for several years (I have Photoshop CS2). You could also try GIMP (Graphics Image Manipulation Program) from gimp.org. It's a free program that is similar (but definitely not identical) to Photoshop. All these things have a steep learning curve.

Jerry

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#3

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

Ed Beck

>Photoshop Elements 8 might do all that you want, however the photo organizer in Elements 7 was pretty bad, so I ended up getting Lightroom 2.

You can try Elements out for free at http://www.adobe.com/downloads/

I used Elements for a few years, and was quite happy. However I reached a point where I needed more. From your description of what you want to do, you're either there already or you're not far from it.

I ended up buying Photoshop CS4 and am very happy. It sounds like you need a high-end application for business purposes. If you typically have a lot of images that you need to do the same things to, you can save a lot of time with CS4. You can record "actions" with CS4, which just records what you're doing to the image. After recording them you can run them on any image you want. This feature has actually changed the way that I shoot, now I aim for uniform photographs which I can work on in post production.

My workflow is like this:

1. Import photos into Lightroom 2, which has a fantastic tagging system.

2. Use LR2 for triage, decide which images I keep, which I get rid of. This triage is based on compositon more than anything else. LR2 has very good tools to let you do this pretty quickly.

3. With what's left, let LR2 automatically adjust the images. Now I have pretty uniform images.

4. Export a few to CS4 and edit them. This gives me an idea what I want to do with this set of images, things like white balance, color correction, noise reduction, and filters I want to apply, and where and how I want to save the edited images.

5. Record the steps to edit and save them. Usually you want to break this into small chunks so that later you can select which ones you want to run and paste them together.

6. Export a bunch of photos from LR to CS4 and run them all through the recorded steps in a batch. How many I run at a time depends on how large the files are and how many actions I perform. If I select more than 20 at a time it seems to slow things down a lot.

7. Go do something else for a while until the batch is done.

8. Review the output and decide if there are some that need more personal attention.

Elements 8 costs $80 and CS4 costs $700. For me CS4 cost $780 because I decided that I needed CS4 after I had already bought Elements 7. So I have Elements 7 which I never use.

Deciding to go to CS4 is a big bite, but depending on what you do it could save you a lot of time.

And yes, the learning curve is pretty steep with both Elements and CS4. YouTube is a great source of learning how to use them.

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#4

William Falberg

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

William Falberg

>PAINT.NET

It's open source and does pretty much everything the others do - for free. I'm a dummy and it works for me. Good "Help" menu, too.

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#5

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

Jim Dillon

>Gary,

In addition to the excellent suggestions you've already received, Paint Shop Photo Pro X3 is available. Although I don't use it anymore, I've always considered it an excellent value, and far less expensive than Photoshop CS4.

Jim

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#6

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

Bill Howatt

>I also have used Paintshop Pro and it is a program that will offer more features than you'll ever use unless you really get into it. It is not Photoshop but is very close to it for a lot less money.

Bill

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#7

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

David Hay @ Denver

>You might take a look at GIMP (http://www.gimp.org/). It's free and has many of the features of Photoshop. That being said, I have Photoshop Elements 6 and find that it's more than adequate for what I need to do for the moment. At some point I may decide to upgrade to Lightroom and/or CS, but that's much further in the future.

David

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#8

Thanks to all.  Checking out suggestions.

Gary Smyth

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#9

Ellis Walentine

Second Paint Shop Pro

Ellis Walentine

>Paint Shop Pro (PSP) has been my "go to" program for image manipulation for more than ten years (and several versions of the software), even though I also own Photoshop (CS3 version). I trried the X2 version of PSP but found it to be sluggish, especially the organizer, so I went back to v. 9.01 which I've been using successfully ever since it came out. I think 9.x was the last Jasc Software version before they sold out to Corel.

Photoshop will do more things, but I haven't felt the need for the additional capabilities -- or maybe I just don't understand them.

Ellis

Re: OT Photo Manipulation

#10

PSP and photoshop

John K Jordan

>>so I went back to v. 9.01

PSP is my program of choice for certain things, mostly because unlike photoshop it loads very quickly. I'm still using version 4.14!!

I love photoshop for the ultimate power and flexibility (and printing features). If working in the graphics field, photoshop is the program of choice if only because of interaction with others.

I use an old version of ACDSee for viewing, browsing, organizing, often right beside photoshop.

JKJ