Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Stair Railing - code check

Posts

Stair Railing - code check

#1

Stair Railing - code check

Kevin

>Was wondering if anyone could just give me a sanity check to make sure there is nothing majorly wrong with this plan. It wasn't my first choice... but some of what I wanted to do apparently wouldn't be allowed by code. The Railings are in Red. They should be acceptible right?

I tried to get the city to approve this before I buy and install $800 worth of custom railing... but they just photocopied the page out of the code book and said "here make sure it follows this" (as I stood there looking dumbstruck with a piece of sample railing and plan for them to approve in my hand)


img

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#2

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Barry Irby

>Kevin, I'm afraid I can't decipher your drawing enough to help you.

Are their three levels? Stairs in between? Just not enough detail for me.

You mentioned Custom Railings. Is someone fabricating the railings for you? If so, and they are in the railing business, they should be able to assure you they will pass the local Code inspection.

It might also help for us to know where you are.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#3

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Bill Houghton

>Yes to what Barry said - if you're getting them fabricated, you should make the railing folks certify the code-ness to you. If you're making them yourself, that's a different problem.

Your drawing's not very clear to me, either; nor is it clear whether you're talking about hand rails (grip as you go up and down stairs) or balustrades (at the edge of open areas on a building to keep you from falling off).

Some general stuff, from what I've seen in our town, below. NOTE: I AM NOT A CONTRACTOR OR A LAWYER. TAKE THIS FOR WHAT IT'S WORTH, WHICH IS ONE PERSON'S LIMITED OBSERVATIONS. You'll be responsible for the outcome; this is intended only to give an idea, from my experiences, of the things you need to think about.

Hand rails

1. Railing height matters. It was 36" for a long time, and I believe it still is.

2. Hand rails need to extend beyond the top and bottom steps. The rule of thumb seems to be that, if you're standing on the platform at top or bottom - not yet on the steps, that is - you should be able to reach out sideways and grip the rail. Your code may have more specific rules.

3. At the top and bottom, the rail needs to be closed when it ends, looping around to the wall or post. Older rails would just terminate, leaving a stub that was great for catching sleeves on shirts and coats and causing the person caught to fall down.

4. Railings must be of a shape that can be gripped. Locally, this translates to round railings of a certain maximum diameter that now escapes me. Of course, the stores all sell railings of various patterns that somehow get installed, but they're apparently not code.

Balustrades Generally, any stair over a certain number of steps and any deck over a certain height must have a balustrade on any open side.

1. Technically, a balustrade consists of a railing with balusters under it. There are so many other solutions out there - glass panels, cables, etc. - that this can be difficult to interpret, but it's good to think of it as a railing with something under it.

2. Again, height matters. This used to be 36" around here, but I understand it's been bumped up to 42". Your code book will control.

3. The railing needs to be strong enough and fastened strongly enough to withstand weight. Your code book may have a definition; inspectors are unlikely to require engineering signoff unless you're doing something strange.

4. The maximum opening between the deck and the railing must be unable to accept a 4" sphere (again: your code may have a different size max; this was the traditional size). This is to prevent a child from wiggling through and getting caught by the head. If the balustrade on the steps does not come down to the level of each step - if there's a railing running above the steps - there's a similar requirement in the triangle formed by the bottom of the balustrade and each step. If I recall correctly, this uses a smaller sphere as the test.

I'm sure there are things I've forgotten - again, no way am I an expert - but I hope these will help you think about the questions you'll need to answer when the inspector shows up.

Two side comments:

1. These tensioned-cable systems are really popular now for "balusters," with thin metal cable running horizontally through the posts and tensioned at each end. If we'd had a three-story structure with that kind of system on it, I would not have an older son, because he would have climbed the railing and tried out his flying skills. If children are ever on your property, I personally wouldn't recommend installing that kind of system.

2. If there's anything I've learned from 36 going on 37 years of struggling with this house, it's a) that over-building is a good thing, and b) that asking lots of questions is another good thing.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#4

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Kevin

>Barry,

Thanks for looking at it.

I've updated the image where I have it hosted, so unless it's cached for you, the revised version should show. I added some more explanation to the image, orange dotted lines to show how the different layers relate to each other. Also some description below. I'm located in Newport News Virginia. Yukon Lumber in Norfolk is making the railings for me, but they seem to put the burden of making sure it's in code on the customer.

Yes it is 3 levels.

Going from 1st to 2nd floor, starts out with a wall on the right, open to the left. Make the turn at the landing, and is still wall on the right, open to the left for a little bit, then become captured between two walls. The stairs narrow down at that point by about 8 inches. (from 58" wide to about 50" wide)

On the 2nd floor there is a wall on the right, with a landing/balcony that overlooks the stairs below, and the stairs and landing to the 3rd floor are both open the the stairs below. After you make the turn, there is a wall on the left all the way up. On the right, it starts out captured but there is a balcony on the 3rd floor that looks down on stairs.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#5

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Kevin

>Bill thanks so much for your input.

I've updated that image with hopefully enough info to make is useful. Having seen it in person... it all makes sense to me. :-) So Please let me know if I can clarify more.

I found a handy document on stairways.org that is a "Visual Interpretation of the 2006 International residential code" It seems to be pretty accurate to the code, but there are some parts it doesn't cover.

It agrees with everything you listed... so it's nice to hear the same thing from multiple sources.

1. Railings on Stairs must be between 34-38"

Railings must be 36 or greater on Balconies >30" from the ground below

2. Railings must extend 12" past the top and bottom tread inless terminating in a newel post

3. If not terminating in a newel post, must be returned into the wall.

4. Lots of specs on railings depending Type 1 (perimeter 6 1/4")

One odd thing it lists. That 4" sphere thing is for balconies... baluster on stairs apparently at 4 3/8" sphere can't pass... Not sure why the difference, but I'll stick with the 4" just to be safe.

I agree with you completely about the pretty tensioned cable systems. I would have climbed them as a child. Our first is on the way, due in April, so no way I'm going there. Plan is to do 1 1/8- 1 1/4 square ballisters from the underside of the railing, all the way to the floor/tread.

I guess I was kind of vague about my questions. Let's see if I can be more specific.

Going from the 1st floor to the 2nd floor. I start with the railing on the LEFT side. Then, once I get to the landing, I have a continuous railing from the landing to the 2nd floor on the RIGHT side. Does it matter that I changed sides?

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#6

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Kevin

>The Other issue that is troubling me.

The Code book appears to read that from the wall to the inside edge of the railing, there must be a Minimum of 1 1/2" of space. But the Maximum the outside edge of the railing can protrude from the wall is 4 1/2"

Now, the maximum allowed width of the crown (the graspable part on the top of the railing) of a Type 2 railing is 2 3/4"

So if your railing is that max allowed, you've only got 1/4" of fudge factor in mounting that railing to be within those min and max allowances.

What happens if you have a piece of trim on the wall, that the railing crosses on it's what up the stairs? The gap between that piece of trim and the railing is going to be less than the minimum 1 1/2". But you move the railing out to maintain that minimum, you've now exceeded the 4 1/2" maximum!

What's the solution?

Going from the 2nd floor to the 3rd floor.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#7

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Chris Friesen

>I've got a couple comments. Not a pro, but I'm doing my own stairs right now and have been reading up on it.

1) If I were the one going down the stairs I'd prefer to have the first floor handrail be continuous along the left side rather than having to switch halfway along. It may be allowable by code, but its certainly not convenient. Think about going up/down the stairs with something heavy/awkward in your other hand. Yes this adds one or two bends to the cost but it saves a length of railing.

2) Consider extending the railing on the stairs going down from the third floor along the wall on the landing to meet up with the other railing. That way a person descending the stairs can hold onto a railing the whole way.

Basically, design it so that my 94 year old grandmother can go up and down with a cane in one hand while holding on to the rail with the other. :)

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#8

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Barry Irby

>I think you have gotten good advice. Stick with the 4" sphere rule between vertical balusters. I think they permit an opening under the rails on the stairs (the triangle) to not permit the passage of a 6" diameter sphere, but I am not sure. The minimum diameter of the grip rail is 1 1/4" if it is a "pipe" and 2 1/4" if it is not round in cross section. The rail on the steps is required to be 34" to 38" above the nose of the tread. I like 34" but I am on the short side. It is strongly encouraged that the grip rail be continuous from top to bottom and that means it has to be on the same side.

You clearly understand why horizontal rails are frowned upon if not completely disallowed. All of the boys and most of the girls would climb right over them.

Although I am a Home Inspector in VA. (near Richmond), I am putting in the standard disclaimer. Do not rely on my information or any other you get on the Internet without double checking with the local Code Authority. And, the people making your rails are the Pro's here. You should make it clear that no matter what you tell them about what you want, you are mot expert in the Code and their work must pass the Code Inspection or you will not pay them until it does. There is much more to this than we have discussed. For example there are requirements that the rails support a certain amount of weight and resist people falling against them.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#9

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Kirk (KC) Constable

>Part of his problem to begin with is that his local 'code authority' wants him to figure it out on his own...

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#10

Re: Stair Railing - code check

George Koch

>Kevin, I agree with Barry that there is much more to this than we have discussed. Questions that come to my mind are, is this a commercial or multi- unit building or a single dwelling? Is the handrail manufacturer going to do the installation? And also, was there a certified engineer or architect approval needed for the permits for this project? These are somethings that would help determine liability for getting the building department approval.

My 2 cents, George

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#11

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Bill Houghton

>Kevin,

How big is your city building inspection department? Is it possible to talk with another inspector and try to find one with a better customer (and, in particular, homeowner) service attitude? Or, as you develop the idea more precisely, could you present drawings with more detail - measurements and so on - and ask them to approve them?

It's my impression, though I could be wrong, that if you present a drawing of what you propose with enough detail to look like an architectural drawing, the city kind of has to review it, rather than leaving you in the gotcha position of being all on your own. It's possible that you didn't present sufficient detail for them to feel they could review it.

Building inspection departments vary all over the place, of course. Our town (7,000 or so people) is small enough that the building inspection department is one guy and his admin assistant, who (the admin assistant) is shared with the fire department. The current inspector is great for a homeowner - he loves to work with homeowner-remodelers like me. Some of his predecessors were pretty hard to work with.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#12

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Barry Irby

>He has gotten stuck in the middle. The Codes people don't want to help much and the fabricators are ducking.

My point is he should not have to reinvent the wheel. The fabricators earn their living building the rails in this town and are regularly inspected by these people. So, his position should be "I want you to build rails that look like I want them generally and specifically meet the requirements of the Code Enforcement people". Make it clear that he may have to be a little forgiving on the design from a cosmetic standing to make it meet the Code requirements and that he understands that. He is the customer of both of these groups, he pays for the permit and he pays for the rails. It might be better is he could get the rail fabricator to buy the permit.

Re: Stair Railing - code check

#13

Re: Stair Railing - code check

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>In my county, You take a set of detailed drawings in and apply for a permit, the drawing come back when you get permit approval with red circles and section numbers from the code book if there is something not quite right. This process can take a few days. It is up to me (or my builder if I were using one) to look up the appropirate section in the code and modify my plan to fit. Once I have the modification figured out I can go back to the planning office and ask to see a plans reviewer and get an answer about my specific question. "Yes you can hang the stairway off that beam, no you don't have to re-draw you plans. I will note it in your file" type of thing. If I walked in to our county or city planning office with a piece of railing, and a set of drawing without much detail and expected an answer from a planning clerk I probablly wouldn't get much more help. Our planning clerks can't answer a question like that nor would I expcet then to really. Your planning department may only have one do it all person, I don't know. On the other hand have gotten good response from the plans reviewer about very specific questions, The inspector has come out and made courtesy inspections, again to answer questions before doing certain tasks, (no one wants to do things wrong and have to do the over). I would expect a railing supplier to be able to insure that the product them sell meets code.

glc