Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Thoughts on the User interface

Posts

Thoughts on the User interface

#1

Thoughts on the User interface

Bill Tindall

>I have a need to know how to wire some AR 98LS speakers. I found a Forum for "classic speakers" including my model. My question was the equivalent of whether the plane blade goes in bevel up or down and could have been easily answered by any of the experts that troll the site.

However! First I had realize that I could not post a question until I navigated a tedious and complicated registration process. By a miracle I got registered and then faced a bewildering Forum interface, vastly more complex than WC (but WC seems to be drifting in this direction). It was very difficult to know what to do and find it among the site clutter. It remains to be seen if I did everything correct and can find an answer if I get one.

Bottom line- while I am sure it is a trivial task for the experts on the speaker site to use it, as a new participant I would have not availed myself of the expertise available had I not been highly motivated for an answer.

Bottomest line- A site will be more useful to a potential participant if it is easy to initially get on and then use. This fact means capability must be compromised for ease of use. I find WC easy to use, but less easy to use than it once was. I don't know how a new comer would view the ease of getting on and using the site but this consideration is important for growth and new blood.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#2

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

FredD

>I would agree with most of Bill's post, on the other hand I will go farther then normal to use this particular site , for it is unique among Web sites posing as Woodworking forums.

Dating back to the old AWW chatrooms on AOL, it was always a premise endorsed by JimC that our function was simply , "you have questions, we have answers".

This hallmark is gradually getting lost in the background noise if you will.

At least it seems that way to me.

I have on occasion filled out a long and detailed form for some answers, (this is especially true of some Medical sites) only to find that they charged a fee for the answer.

That is deceiving , I would never have gone to the trouble of filling out their form or agreeing to a survey if they had said so up front.

FredD

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#3

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

Charles in Mtl.

>I still wonder why an upper and lower action bar is required. I may be missing something but wouldn't one reply to message be enough?

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#4

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

Dan Donaldson

>On a short thread, it seems like a waste for two bars, but if there is a long thread, if there were not two, you would have to scroll all the way back up to reply. On the email I use, if I want to forward a message, I have to scroll all the way to the bottom because that is the only place there is a link for that. Royal pain a lot of the time. There can be advantages and disadvantages to either approach.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#5

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

FredD

>Dan,

on my last reply to Nathan I didn't proof read it , so I thought this is a good time to use the edit function.

Though my profile is up and running and the password was entered and then changed to one I always remember, when I hit the edit button and entered the password, I got a "invalid password or no password " reply.

What did I do wrong ?

FredD

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#6

Ellis Walentine

Some messages are long

Ellis Walentine

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#7

Ellis Walentine

Hmm

Ellis Walentine

>Thanks, Bill, for the comments. Your thoughts are duly noted, but, frankly, the only thing that has been the slightest bit different or more difficult here over the transition to the new boards has been the profile process, and that only affected people who retained

profiles, passwords and cookies from our previous messageboards. The reason was purely technical and specific to the back-room workings of my server. One of the key gatekeeper files that should have admitted those old passwords was partially compromised by an arcane operating system bug in a thing called the Berkeley DB engine, specific to the version resident on my server. No newcomer would have experienced any difference in the reading/posting experience at all, with the exception of the viewport being fixed at 1024 pixels. (I'm referring to the fixed-width screen.) If that newcomer had chosen to register a profile, he/she could have done it in minutes, with no effort or confusion. Previously registered users were the ones affected by the profile/cookie conflict, and over the past week I have helped perhaps a hundred or more of them, personally, to re-register successfully. Almost four hundred others have registered in the meantime with no help from me, including many previous members.

So, other than the new and enhanced formatting and uploading features, which are quite intuitive and you only get by registering, the user experience is almost precisely the same, unless I'm missing something, which is entirely possible, but I can't figure it from your post. Maybe you were referring to all the back-and-forth about profiles over the past week.

I'll do my best to keep an eye out for too much complexity, and I'll certainly make note of specific and constructive suggestions. As an editor, I have some experience with page layouts and clear instructions, and our instructions and readability will be continually refined as time goes on and I learn to use some of the additional capabilities of the new software that I never had with the older version of our boards.

Your comments tell me you care about this site and want to keep it user-friendly. So do I, and I'll do everything I can to deliver on that promise.

Ellis

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#8

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

Dan Donaldson

>I don't know. Can you try the password before you changed it and see if by chance it didn't take?

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#9

Re: Hmm

Grant Wilkinson

>Ellis:

I believe that you deliver on that promise completely already. I can appreciate that some members are going through growing pains with the new features. However, for a newbie, I can't see how it could be made any easier. I am a member of several boards and this is the only one on which I can read messages, see pics and go to links without creating a user id and password.

I believe that speaks volumes about the ease of use of WoodCentral.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#10

Agreed!

Rik, WI

>

Grant Wilkinson:

I am a member of several boards and this is the only one on which I can read messages, see pics and go to links without creating a user id and password.

I believe that speaks volumes about the ease of use of WoodCentral.

I agree 100%. I feel this site is very user friendly to both new users and those who don't wish to log on and be tracked. It irks me when I visit other sites that require my logging in to view content such as attached images. I greatly appreciate the lengths that Ellis has gone to, directly or indirectly, to keep the "Badger Pond" feel within this community.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#11

Agree a bit...

John in NM

>Of course I'm on a lot of registration only forums, so I'm mostly comfortable with the Vbulletin software they all seem to use. My least favorites are one that uses a very old version and another that just upgraded to the newest.

The only problem I've had with the upgrade here is the look of the message board. I just can't get used to the lines between the threads, and it made more sense to me in the older format that looked more like an outline from taking class notes. I will no doubt get used to it. Maybe I will finally make a profile and register after 8 years of hanging around. One thing I have always liked about this forum is the open nature of the posting makes it less "clubby" than a lot of forums. I'm glad to see that is retained.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#12

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

FredD

>I not only tried , I reentered it with no problem, except it wil nopt let me doe a message edit.

I know it recognizes me because of the "welcome back greeting" and the row of bells and whistles above this .

FredD

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#13

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

FredD

>it works now Dan, for whatever reason, thanks for your reply

FredD

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#14

to clarify

Bill Tindall

>I don't know if the current WC is too complicated such that it discourages new people that need an answer and just found the site. It would take a new participant to answer that question. I suspect if I asked one of the Classic Speaker veterans whether their site was too complex to get on and use they would answer no. That said, I was unable to log on the site this AM to thank a responder to my question. I could see my answer but my thank you was rejected. I have no idea what the problem is.

The nature of woodworking is such that some of its participants are uncomfortable with dealing with computer complexity and others may just needs a quick answer. By some means be sure the site continues to be readily accessible to these people.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#15

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

Kneale Brownson..Back enjoying CO snow

>Did you click the "save password" button?

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#16

Amen to clubby part

Bill Tindall

>Occasionally I have been directed to some other site for information. The ones that are more social than technical/professional put me off instantly and I don't return.

Not that I mine some socializing, so long as it is not the focus of the site.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#17

ebd

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

ebd

>I hope I'm not misunderstood (again). I have no problem with the format. At first it was slightly disconcerting to have the lines. Now I find I like them a lot.

The biggest problem I see (and Ellis, please know that I emphasize - I did mainframe, mini and micro computer programming and application system development for 35+ years) is the time it takes for a post to display. I'm not sure what is going on, but some very short posts seem to take forever, while some longer posts display quickly and visa-versa. Doesn't seem to correlate with having an image or not either.

I forget the exact metric, but when I took a graduate class in Software Engineering there was a maximum display time that had to be met to keep the user engaged and keep them from being frustrated, but it was SHORT. I've got about 15 Mbps download transfer speed and I find every other board I go to very snappy. It's only on the WoodCentral and WoodCentral turning boards that I see this problem. It doesn't make sense to me.

I know you are doing an enormous amount of work and it IS appreciated. I simply offer this because I would expect DSL and dial-up to be even more problematic. If there is one area to concentrate on I would think it would be this.

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#18

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

>Every time there has been a new update, and I have been around for all of them, I look at things and think to myself, Man, I liked the "old way" better (ok I am kind of an old dog). Then within a week or so I can't even remember what the "old way" was or looked like! I can honestly say I did not have this reaction this time, so WOW. As far as the lines go, Focus on the incredible variety of information available, tune the line out and you won't even notice them.

THANK YOU Ellis

glc

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

#19

Re: Thoughts on the User interface

FredD

>I did all the easy stuff like following directions before I inquired.

It fixed it's self is all I can say , no problem now.

FredD