Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Cutting a large arc

Posts

Cutting a large arc

#1

Cutting a large arc

David Frame

>Hi Friends,

I'd like to know if there is a way to cut an arc with a 26 foot radius without freehanding the cut.

The elliptcal jigs I know of can cut smaller arcs, but is it possible to make a jig to to cut such a large radius. I'm not talking about making a 26 foot I-Beam with a pivot point.

Thanks,

David

Re: Cutting a large arc

#3

How long does the cut need to be?

Phil Joines

Re: Cutting a large arc

#4

Re: Cutting a large arc

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

>I would draw the arc on MDF and make a template using a freehand roughcut plus hand sanding. Once the template is to your staisfaction, use a router with a pattern bit to make your final cut

Re: Cutting a large arc

#5

Re: Cutting a large arc

Barry Irby

>David, I had to cut a large arc a few years ago and I did not want to set up a pivot. I had a friend with Auto Desk (I think, a very powerful drawing program, by what ever name) draw it up for me. He drew a straight line that subtended the arc with verticals from the base line to the arc every six inches and those lines were labeled with their length. So I just drew a line and using a square set up the verticals and then used a spline to fair the curve from point to point. Then I cut the line and touched it up with a belt sander. Actually, I was making a form for bending a bunch of laminated arches. Once I had one piece, I used a pattern bit to make more.

Come to think of it, my arc was a section of an ellipse and I could not have used a pivot.

Re: Cutting a large arc

#6

Re: Cutting a large arc

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>David, I have done this before, and it wasn't too hard. Even though my shop is pretty large, finding room for a 30' arc was a challenge for space.

So what I did was get out on my parking lot and drove a 1/2" pipe into the asphalt, then pieced together the arm from shorter scrap. I then nailed some 1/4" MDF to the asphalt along the path of the various arcs that I need for all the parts of this reception desk with a transaction top.

With a guide bushing in the base of my router, I could just drop it into a new hole to change the various arc radii for my templates, which were then used to guide the router for the finish cuts on the actual work parts.

Re: Cutting a large arc

#7

Ellis Walentine

To what degree of accuracy?

Ellis Walentine

>If you need it to be nigh-on perfect for some reason, you might want to follow Barry's suggestion and have someone tile it together for you in AutoDesk or calculate the height at increments of the length as he did. If it merely needs to be close, there is an equation that gives you the height of the section of the circle of a particular radius and a chord of a particular length. I don't have the energy to look it up, but if you can just draw a chord the length you want and figure the height at the midpoint, you can approximate the curve with a long thin batten held at the ends and center point.

Ellis

Re: Cutting a large arc

#8

Clint Searl

Re: Cutting a large arc

Clint Searl

>Give me "L" or "H" and I'll give you all the little "h's" to whatever tolerance you want.

Clint


Re: Cutting a large arc

#10

Re: Cutting a large arc

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#11

Re: How long does the cut need to be?

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#12

Re: To what degree of accuracy?

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#13

Re: Cutting a large arc

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#14

Re: To what degree of accuracy?

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#15

Re: Cutting a large arc

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#16

Re: Cutting a large arc

David Frame

>Hi all,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

The small tool from Lee Valey that was suggested, won't do for the job at hand. I guess you already knew that though. Nor do I want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#17

David, I think you are over thinking this.....

Barry Irby

>Clint can send you the numbers and Ray has already drawn it out for you. If I understand your response post you already have AutoCad, so you could plot it for yourself.

The over thinking part is, to me, this is a case of if it looks good, it is good. You get to choose. No one is coming behind you measure the arc and critiquing it, saying something like "this is mot a perfect segment of a 26' arc."

I would use the drawing done by Ray, or one you do yourself to make a half pattern (half of one edge). I would convert that into a full pattern. Then I would use that to route both edges of the table. I might use a patterning bit or any bit in my router and just run the base of the router along the pattern. Who cares if it is a 26" 3" radius rather than 26'? Am I missing something?

Re: Cutting a large arc

#18

Re: Here ya go

David Frame

>Hi Ray,

Everyone had excellent suggestions on how to cut a 26' arc- radius with a 30 degree downward edge. After drafting it in AutoCAD 2000 at the time and looking at it the tabletop, the arc- radius seemed correct.

I don't want to use a long piece of aluminum flat bar. It does not have the accuracy I need or want.

In the past, I used a 27' piece if small iron I-Beam and attached 1/2" plywood to it. I then fastened an angle jig to it and set it at 30 degrees. The tabletop was 26' away, and it was in the street of my neighborhood. At 26' mark on the I-Beam, I drilled a hole in the lower center of it. I had to cut away a little over 1' of the center of the I-Beam to accept this hole. I then clamped a 2 pieces of 3/4"plywood to my tablesaw and screwed the I-Beam to the 1 1/2" plywood as a pivot point.

After a few adjustments to make sure the tabletop and the tablesaw were parallel and that the I-Beam was perpendicular or square to the correct points, I made the cuts, one side at a time. There has to be a better way.

If you look inside Patrich Spielman's book, "Router Jigs and Techniques", assuming you have a copy, on pp. 229 thru 239, he has made a elliptical jig to cut Ovals and ellipses. Rather than this jig having 2 dovetailed cross members, I was thinking of making a T styled jig. A wide piece of aluminum channel at the top, horizontally, and a long aluminum channel from top to bottom, vertically. This way, one block, that connects to a long plastic router jig, inside the aluminum channel at the top horizontal and the same block for the lower vertical. The aluminum channel is going to be covered by a strip of wood with a slot the length of the channel so that the blocks do not come out.

The table I refer to can be seen in ShopShots #910 on WoodCentral. I have another job coming up in the near future and the top will be similar. That's why I was looking for a new way to cut these arcs.

When I draft my work on my new AutoCAD 2009 and Inventor Suite, both 2D and full 3D programs, It will give me the radius of arcs, length, height and depth of lines, and a tons of more information.

Thanks for your time, patience and input,

David Frame

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Cutting a large arc

#19

Far out suggestion

Ray - Middletown, IN

>Go ahead and model a section of the profile you want, say a 12" segment. Then send it to a prototype shop and have them make an SLA or SLS master from the model, it will be within a few thousands of an inch of your model. Finish the master and make a silicone mold from it that you can cast multiple sections that you can butt together using the witness marks on the side you put in the model, making any length segment you want. Then use a pattern bit in a router following the segment length you just put together. No I-beams required, just cash for the master.

Ray

Re: Cutting a large arc

#20

Re: Cutting a large arc

Keith Mealy

>Here is an article I wrote on how to make large arcs. (scroll down to "Method B"). While 26' is still a large arc, using these techniques, you can easily bisect the arc into two or more and accomplish the feat with a couple of 8' boards, a router (in the place of a pencil), and a few nails.

http://www.carrscorner.com/printit/printpage_images.php?page=../yabbse/Newsletter/12-06.php