Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

Posts

Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#1

Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

Nathan

>I tried and failed to flatten my oilstones by rubbing them on the side of a large grinding wheel, and I'm reluctant to shell out the dough for a diamond stone. FredD mentioned a "diamond strop" but so far I haven't found anything matching that description. At this point I'm considering rubbing the stones on a cast iron or glass plate charged with a water-based grinding paste.

I guess my first question is: does this stand a chance of working at all? (I don't pretend to know what I'm talking about.)

Assuming it could work, here where I live (in Europe), cast iron plates are fairly easy to come by. However, I'm wondering if regular float glass could be used, since it's so much cheaper than a cast iron plate.

Could someone "enlighten" me concerning the advantage of cast iron over glass, if any? Remember, all I'm looking to do (at this point) is true up oilstones using a coarse grinding paste.

Thanks in advance.

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#2

Maybe I found the answer *LINK*

Nathan

>Using the new search function here on WoodCentral I came up with this 2003 message from Russel Seaton.

The gist of it is that the grinding particles will roll around on the glass plate and abrade it, whereas on cast iron they become embedded and stay in one place.

Very interesting.


Russel Seaton's clarification message from 2003

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#3

Found it, thanks to Bill Tindall

Nathan

>I think I found the answer in a message Bill Tindall posted in 2008; I quote:

"The cast iron works best with the small grits. Acrylic (Plexiglas) works best for coarse grits as they embed better."

So I'm off to get a piece of acrylic. By the way, I'm very intrigued by Bill Tindall's "bench grinder to cast iron lapping plate charged with 1-micron diamond paste" technique and intend to try it if/when I get tired of the oilstones. I've been practicing my hollow-grinding technique...

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#4

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

Ron Bauman

>About every two or three years I flatten my stones en mass. I go to a local plate glass store and have them cut me a section that fits into a rectangular baking pan, I have a supply of #60 grit abrasive that will last forever. Using water and the abrasive I make a slurry and then it's grinding using a figure 8 pattern until the stones are flat. I've got 8 or 10 stones, but it doesn't take very long. I think the guy charged me $5 last time for the glass. Even the hard arkansas don't take long.

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#5

disclaimer

Bill Tindall

>The acrylic worked well when abrading a piece of steel. I am not certain that this will be a good choice for flattening a stone. Do let us know how it works out. The principal is clear though. You want the softer material to be what the diamond goes on so it stays fixed in place and the harder material that which is moved across the abrasive to be abraded.

If the stone is porous you will trap a lot of diamond particles in the stone. This result could be beneficial or not. Definitely not if a coarse diamond particle gets trapped in a fine particle stone. If the stone has a soft bond then these trapped diamonds will quickly wash away with the grinding gunge, but on a hard oil stone that are there forever.

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#6

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

FredD

>Nathan , I was not clear enough I see about using diamonds to flatten oilstones, which is far and away the fastest , most efficient way of doing it.

DMT makes a flat strop , using Monocrystaline Diamonds bonded to a Nickel backing and fixed to a steel plate.

They also make Diamond paste for really fine honing.

These products are available at Lie-Neilsen TOOLWORKS along with a DVD of how to go about it by Larry Williams who you will readily see is a expert at grinding and honing profile plane irons and turning chisels.

By doing this simple thing, you will be enlightened in a manner of speaking. ;-))

Don't make things woodworking harder then they need to be.

Happy trails

FredD

FredD

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#7

Follow-up question: Coarse or extra coarse

Nathan

>Hi Fred:

I already ordered Larry's DVD. I'm cheap by nature so I'd rather spend days or weeks searching than just buy a ready-made product. But in the end I will probably break down and get the DMT strop. Do you recommend coarse or extra coarse for flattening oilstones?

I read somewhere that coarser grits might score the finer oilstones, which might cause a temporary performance loss.

Nathan

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#8

Re: Follow-up question: Coarse or extra coarse

FredD

>Nathan, sometime I get the feeling that flattening oilstones is being over thought.

If you buy a good grad of Arrkansas or or man man made like Norton anjd pay attention to the way you use it, resurfacing it should not be constant thing you need to do.

I have among other stones a three stone combination in a rotating case by Norton and I have never used the medium and coarse grit stones.

I go directly from the grinder to the fine stone and using figure eight lapping patterns I have yet to need to flatten it and I do sharpening and honing often .

In a shop teaching environment where many use the oilstone, I certainly can see the need for more frequent surfacing of the stones.

In Larry williams DvD you will that he has formed the habit of stroking the oilstone once or twice every time with the Diamond strop before using it, this ensures that it never gets worn unevenly , but I suspect many would not .

My habit is more like touching up the plane irons and chisels before any extensive use and I hollow grind those edges, which makes keeping then sharp longer between grindings easier and faster to hone the edge ,

This is a subject of much debate, so you may want to experiment between hollow grind and factory ground bezels.

FredD

Re: Cast iron or glass for stone flattening

#9

220 grit carbide (black) sandpaper on glass

Alexandre Grigoriev