Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

Posts

OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#1

OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

wilbur

>We had an issue with water backing up in the drain pipe that carries away water from our washing machine this week. (All I can say that I was really happy we have one of those high effieciency washers, otherwise a lot more water would have been involved.) After cleaning up, I traced the drain pipe. It goes down to the basement, and hooks up into the main drain pipe pretty close to where it leaves the house, just before the main drain trap. I opened up the drain trap, and took out a large soap plug. It looked like the plug had completely blocked the trap on the far end of it. I don't know exactly how big the plug was, but I filled up over half of a two quart bucket with the soap plug that I pulled out. Once I cleared the blockage, the drains work just fine now.

My question is, since this happened at the main drain trap, how worried to I have to be that there's blockage in the drain pipe outside the house leading to the sewer line? I can see a soap plug forming over time in a trap, but I don't want any more surprises due to a blockage I can't see.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#2

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Wilbur,

If you have 4" main lines, you should not have a soap plug problem. Enough flow in a main line to keep it relatively free. I just cleaned out a 3' long plug in a 1 & 1/2 drain from my kitchen sink. It was confined to that one line. The 2" lateral from there was clean as a whistle.

John

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#3

What is a soap plug

Bill Tindall

>I thought I have had every plumbing malady but this is a new one. I don't see anything about soap that could possibly make a solid material. Grease and hair/lint balls are the main line plugging culprits, other than the creative things children can put down drains.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#4

Daytime T.V. commercial

Neal in San Jose

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#5

I'm with Bill on this....

Barry Irby

>I have been doing Home Inspections for 25 years and have never heard of a soap plug.

Locally we don't use a main trap. Are you saying there was a glob of something in the trap on your main sewer where it exited the house?

Like Bill, I doubt the plug was soap. If so, you are dumping way too much soap in the washer. I doubt it will matter much in a plumbing sense, but you should be using the HE soap and use the minimum that will do the job. Even with all the stress on High Efficiency soap they are still selling soap. They tend to suggest the maximum amount the washer will flush away. Try cutting the soap by a third or a half and see if the clothes don't get just as clean.

It's more likely the plug was some sort of grease. Are you dumping grease or greasy food waste down the drain? Not a good idea, but if you do, you should use cold water. Hot water tends to warm the pipes and the grease and let them stick to each other. Cold water tends to make the grease coagulate and go down the drain as globules.

The slopes on pipes are fairly critical. I have wondered if the change to low flow toilets and washers that use less water was going to affect older plumbing.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#6

Re: What is a soap plug

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>My plug wasn't really soap, it just looked like solid white soap. It was calcium deposits from hard water working with grease from kitchen waste. It was the consistency of soft plaster of paris. I had to dismantle part of my drain line and ream the pipe out. The line was a little flat and I rerouted it to provide better flow.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#7

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

Don Evans

>Hi Wilbur:

Just curious, you don't indicate what size the drain for the washer is? If it doesn't enlarge immediately where it comes into the basement, that could be a problem. Most of these drains are 1 1/2" which should be large enough unless they are too long.

Your high efficient washer is good thing but it could help cause the problem as not enough water on the rinse to really clear out the line to the main.

Also if this drain is a "home run" from washer to main with nothing else getting in there where you cleaned it (no grease) then it could be several things.

Hard water will result in people adding much more soap than needed because they don't see bubbles. Hard water also has more calcium in it so combination of more soap than recommended and calcium could be the problem.

It would be interesting to also know how much soap, how long you had the house, how long you had the washer verse old system that used more water.

Lot to consider.

Don

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#8

My thoughts from limited experience

Bill Houghton

>I suspect what Wilbur is describing as a soap plug could more accurately be described as a gunk plug. From what I've seen in our house (originally cast iron drain lines with a few galvanized pipes for small run, then a mix of ABS, galvanized, and cast iron, now migrating entirely to ABS as we do remodels), the basic condition necessary for these is something that will allow hair, laundry lint, or other fibrous waste to accumulate at a point in the system. This then collects passing particulates and, ultimately, soap scum, ferments it, and generates a gross mess.

This could be a very slight roughness in the pipe, an issue with cast iron pipe; a rough joint, very much an issue with cast iron but possible with ABS if the installer was liberal enough with the cement; a spot in the line in which the slope of the line or sweep of the corner was insufficient. Any number of possible causes. The small galvanized pipe that drained our bathtub and bathroom sink appeared to have enough slope but had accumulated so much sediment in the bottom that the inner diameter of the pipe had about half the area of the nominal pipe size.

Wilbur, I wouldn't fret too much about issues down the line from the gunk you pulled out, unless you're seeing slow drainage issues generally. If there is a spot down the line in which another plug is a-forming, you're going to want to bring in a pro with the equipment to ream it out without digging up the pipe, unless you're eager to learn about roto-rooting equipment from your rental yard.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#9

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

Galen Vetterick

>Wilber:

I have not seen a u-trap on a main line going out of a home but in this townhome there is a main cleanout and about 3 feet beyond is the main check valve. The metal seated swing check stuck just partially open so that it slowed the water flow and allowed more "gunk" to collect in the pipe. There is enough volumn in the long run across the floor to the washer it could handle the water but you could hear it back up to the standpipe.

Cooking grease, shaving cream, bath oils and products all add to the clogs.

You did not say how long the sytem has been in use but I'd say a good while.

I would check to see if there is a check valve in the main and if it is stuck slowing the flow.

With the poor building practices here you have to sound on the concrete to find the normal metal box cover that should allow access to the check valve. Mine had 1/2" of concrete on the top.

Just my story.

Galen

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#10

Clarifications

wilbur

>Thanks for all the input. To address some of the questions/comments:

-- I didn't measure the main line, but it is probably 4".

-- I called it a "soap plug" because that's what the plumbing book I was using called it. (I was reading the Black & Decker Complete Guide to Home Plumbing.) Thinking it through, it's most likely a plug of grease/calcium/whatever, and seemed like what John Veerkamp described -- a soft white glob that was kind of like soft butter in consistency. I shall refer to it as the Big WHite Glob from here on out.

-- As Barry Irby surmised, the Big White Glob was in the far side of the trap on my main sewer where it exited the house. The sewer line as it exits the house is old cast iron. The trap is ABS, and is obviously newer. My book says that this sort of trap, although not common in newer homes, was sometimes used in older houses, which mine certainly is.

-- My guess is that our water is pretty hard. We get more calcium buildup around faucets than other places that I have lived.

-- The drain line with this issue carries water away from the washer, dishwasher, and kitchen sink. (The other bathrooms in the house use a separate drain line exiting the house.) We are not excessive users of soap in our washing machine or dishwasher, but I could cut back on the dishwashing liquid I use when hand washing pots and pans, I guess.

-- We've lived in this house for 5 years, but the house itself is 60-70 years old.

-- Finally, there have been no drainage issues since I cleared out the BWG. I tested this by completely filling up my kitchen sink and letting it drain all at once, and with multiple wash cycles since clearing out the BWG.

So back to my original question: how worried should I be about blockage in the drain line on the outside of the house? It seems plausible that if a BWG is going to form, the far end of the trap on the main sewer where it exits the house would be the spot to do it.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#11

Re: Clarifications

Galen Vetterick

>With the two seperate lines leaving the house are you on city sewer or a septic tank? Maybe it was converted from septic tank to city sewer? Common to run the bathrooms through the septic tank and the gray water bypassed around it.

You may have run a dishwaher more than the past owner and the more aggressive dishwashing soap cut all the old waste buildup to cause the plug.

Only sure way to know about the line to the sewer is spend the money and have it cleaned. It may work for many years more but being an older home it could have red clay tile from the home to sewer and these can be subject to tree roots and even the old tile collapsing any time. If plumbers know it is old tile very few will try to clean as they know old tiles have a good chance of breaking.

I'd leave it alone.

Galen

Done the septic tank to city sewer changes and replacing old tile with new D.I. pipe on others.

Re: OT: Plumbing question - soap plug in drain

#12

Re: Clarifications

Barry Irby

>I agree with Galen. The pipe outside the house may be either Orangeburg or clay tile. Either of which are subject to tree roots. Or it could be cast iron and that can fail after a very long time. And it may have been a gray water line as he mentions. In the days of septic tanks it was not unusual to pipe the gray water directly to a small drain field without it's passing through the septic tank. (The phosphate based soaps of the day were not good for septic tanks. Modern soaps, except TSP, don't contain phosphates.) It is possible that if you had a septic tank and someone converted to city sewer the failed to connect the gray water to the sewer. This can be tested by opening the manhole of the sewer and dumping dye down the kitchen sink drain until it shows up in the manhole, or NOT.

I am sort of the "let sleeping dogs lie" school on this. Or If it ain't broke, don't fix it. You have lived there for years and this is the first time it has clogged up. It may have been building that clog for years before you moved in. You know how to clean it out now. Opening the clean out and check it a year from now. If nothing, then wait five years. Perhaps adopt better grease and soap management techniques.

If you go to investigating the sewer you may end up spending thousands to improve on something that is working.