Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Apprenticeship, week 16

Posts

Apprenticeship, week 16

#1

Apprenticeship, week 16

Nathan

>Last Thursday, Master kept his promise and had me �stand at the lathe all day�. Fortunately for me, I didn�t just stand there - he turned it on and showed me some basic techniques, and I actually turned three candlesticks (beech and white maple) and a small spruce bowl. It was great, although I didn�t actually finish anything. Since I turned the candlesticks out of narrow material, I�m going to have to make bases for them separately. I started on a beech base, but it took forever just to rough it out. The pine bowl is finished from the outside, but I haven�t started on the inside yet. Still, I was surprised that I was able to actually make something remotely useful on my first time at the lathe.

Today Master was out all day, so I was sort of left to my own devices. This was the second time, and both times I tried to make the best of it by practicing at the grinder and sharpening station. Today I spent two or three hours at it. Here are some observations:

(1) It�s important to get a feeling for the stone you�re using � i.e., how fast it cuts and how flat it is. Today I managed to get that feeling, and I must say, it felt good but it was a long time coming. I spent over an hour trying to flatten the back of a 1� chisel, which I thought was improperly sharpened. I thought my stone was just cutting REALLY slow, but the longer it took to flatten the back, the more suspicious I got. Finally I decided to try 220-grit sandpaper � I figured that might speed up the process. I found a piece of float and imagine my surprise � with only a few strokes (3? 5?) the back miraculously became flat. At that moment it dawned on me that the stone was concave and that no matter how long I stood there, the back would never become flat using a concave stone.

(Ha, I know this is really basic stuff, but it marked a major leap in my understanding of and skill level in sharpening.)

So I decided to ask for help. Master wasn't in today, so I asked one of the guys. He suggested that I flatten the stone on the side of a big grinding wheel that was lying around. I tried hard to get the stone flat, and I did make some progress but it was very slow going (though not as slow as the process of flattening the back of the chisel on the non-flat stone - it was encouraging to see real progress). After about an hour I judged that to get both the "coarse" and "fine" sides of the stone truly flat, I'd have to rub it on the grinding wheel vigorously for at least another 2 hours. Still, I had made enough progress to see that the stone was now flat around the edges and on both ends. Flat enough to get a chisel sharpened properly.

(2) The question is, at what point do you declare it "sharp"? Someone � I think it was Christopher Schwarz � wrote that as you gain experience in sharpening, your definition of �sharp� changes. I�ve found this is true, even in my short four months of sharpening. When I started, I was delighted at the �before ... after� difference between my totally dull tools and what they were transformed into when I rubbed them in the right way on a concave stone. Soon, though, that no longer seemed sharp enough to me. When I got a bit better at sharpening, I was delighted when I managed to raise a burr across the entire edge of the tool and chase it on finer and finer stones until I couldn't feel it anymore. Now, though, I�m realizing that this level of �sharp� (at least in my hands on my stones) is what Christopher Schwarz refers to as �working dull�. Today, I would like my chisels to be �shaving sharp� when I�m finished with them on the stone, but either my finest stone (a piece of slate) is not fine enough, or my technique is not there yet.

(3) On the other hand, I�m not sure if attaining shaving sharp is worth the extra effort. It seems like after spending lots of time getting a tool to that level, having it revert to �working dull� after a couple minutes of use will be discouraging.

(4) I now understand why many woodworkers refuse to let anyone else sharpen on their stones.

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

#2

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

Fred Davis

>Good to hear your progressing Nathan, but I gotta tell you , you or your "Master" are making sharpening edge tools much harder then it needs to be.

Regarding flattening stones , either have your Master get a diamond loaded flat strop to flatten stones with or buy one yourself.

It only takes a couple of strokes to keep a stone flat, do it every time before you sharpen and hone and then you won't dread doing it.

As far as degree of sharp goes , the hardness of the metal of your tools and the angle of the edge will vary the degree that you can remove the metal on the edge and still have a serviceable edge.

The specie of the wood also varies greatly in hardness and abrasiveness.

If you every watch a Butcher cut meat with a knife , you will get a idea of how sharp he needs it by the repeated stroking the edge with a steel.

Touching up the edge of a plane iron or wood chisel frequently , rather the when you absolutely have too will make planing or cutting Mortises a pleasure instead of a chore.

Many woodworkers who hand plane instead of using power rhapsodize over the feeling of a sharp plane iron removing shavings you can see though ;-))

Makes a nice sound too.

I walked into Abilene High wood shop some years back when the instructor was in his first year out of College and pitifully inadequate in tool use or Nomenclature and he was running wood though the Planer when he saw me and stopped to ask what I needed.

I told him his Planer knives were seriously dull and needed grinding.

When he inquired how I knew that without inspecting the knives, I told him I could tell it when I was walking across the parking lot by the racket the planer was making.

Keep up the good work .

FredD

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

#3

The old school *LINK*

Nathan

>Hi Fred:

Yeah, well, Master wasn't in yesterday. If he had been there, the day would have been much different. But, actually, I'm kind of glad he wasn't there yesterday because it gave me an opportunity to really think about the problem.

By way of explanation: first, this is not really a hand-tool shop. Alot of the work they do is in veneered and melamine-coated particleboard, almost 100% dowel joinery using a Line Boring Machine. I almost hesitate to say it, but certainly in terms of sheer volume of material, they do far more work in sheet stock than in solid wood. Second, when they do work in solid wood (still a daily occurence), they machine it. Hand tools are pulled out ONLY for tasks that simply cannot be done reasonably using a machine. That, perhaps, explains why the sharpening station is neglected.

Master himself is from the Czech "old school", which developed out of the German school (he himself told me that the Czechs originally learned woodworking from the Germans, and he also said both the Czechs and the Germans couldn't hold a candle - basically - to the French, but that's a discussion for another day). When I asked him how the stones are flattened - whether a diamond is used - he laughed at the idea. No, he said, stones are flattened by rubbing them against eachother.

So I hope this explains somewhat (though it does not excuse) why Master's stones are concave. Actually, Master HE sharpens a chisel is to raise a burr on the bench grinder and then go directly to chasing it on the fine, slate stone. That particular stone is in a "near-flat" state, like my oilstone.

When you say diamond strop, are you referring to this black DMT thing? It costs "only" $70 here. It's only 6x2" - is this big enough to flatten a stone that is basically the same size, or even a bit longer?


DMT Black (Extra Coarse) "stone"

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

#4

Fred..Abilene high...Where (KS, TX)

Terry Alexander

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

#5

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

FredD

>Nathan,

I don't wish to confuse you about sharpening or start a argument with your teacher , he learned a old technique that has fallen by the way side for a good reason, rubbing oil stones together to flatten them is very slow and inefficient.

Part of your training should be how to improve work flow and promote efficiency in that work . After all time is money.

Do yourself a favor get the DVD titled "Sharpening Profiled Hand Tools" by Larry Williams , a contributor on this forum

It is sold by Lie-Nielsen ToolWorks.

You will be glad you did.

FredD

Re: Apprenticeship, week 16

#6

Re: Fred..Abilene high...Where (KS, TX)

FredD

>Abilene , Kansas ,

Tis the city of Wild Bill Hiccok and President Eisenhower.

The city your Abilene was named after.

FredD