Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

glue ups bowing

Posts

glue ups bowing

#1

glue ups bowing

STICKY

>I GLUED UP SOME 1X POP. TO MAKE A CABINET DOOR 39x22, A DAY OR SO AFTER I TOOK IT OUT OF THE CLAMPS IT STARTED TO BOW, I ALTERNATED THE RINGS UP DOWN, THE M.C. WAS AT 7%, I JOINTED THE EDGES, WHAT GIVES???? THE ONLY THING I CAN THINK OF IS THAT I HAD TO PUT A RABBIT IN THE DOOR AND THIS SOMEHOW CAUSED THE BOW.

Re: glue ups bowing

#2

Re: glue ups bowing

Barry Irby

>Unlikely the rabbet caused it to bow.

Where was it stored or laying after you did the glue up? If you layed it on the floor/slab it is possible one side got damp and the other side was dry-er and that caused the bow.

Stock prep could be at fault. Did you dress more off one side than the other? If the center of each board was wetter than the surface you can set up a situation where the board cups after it is dressed.

Re: glue ups bowing

#3

Re: glue ups bowing

Bill Tindall

>Alternating the grain has no useful benefit. Lay up panels for best looks.

You panel bowed because it is either gaining or loosing moisture on one side more than the other. You will have to remember details of how the lumber and panel was handled to think how this situation came to pass. If the problem was introduced after the panel was made then exposing the panel to air uniformly will straighten it out.

There is another source of bow. Pipe clamps bow when clamping panels. This bow will be set in the panel. For this reason I don't own pipe clamps.

Re: glue ups bowing

#4

Too much clamping pressure

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mountain

Re: glue ups bowing

#5

Re: Too much clamping pressure

Barry Turner

>You may be right. Use just enough clamp pressure to snug up the joints. It is not necessary or even desireable to use maximum clamping pressure. Easy does it.

Re: glue ups bowing

#6

Re: glue ups bowing

Dick Coers

>You didn't mention how wide the boards were that you glued up. If you used 10" boards they can add to the problem. A commercial shop wouldn't use anything wider than 4" to limit the bow. A trick I started using years ago was to alternate the faces of the boards against the jointer fence. I try to get the fence set at dead 90 degrees, but I can still maybe have a little error. If one face goes against the fence and it machines at 89 degrees, then run the other board the opposite direction, it will be machined at 91 degrees. Put the two errors together and you get a flat joint.

Re: glue ups bowing

#7

Re: glue ups bowing

STICKY

>thanks for responses guys, i appreciate it alot,i use bar clamps, the blank was layed flat on my workbench, in the garage which is heated, i ripped and jointed the edges equally + - 1/4, and my clamping pressure like my wealth is always just enough thanks guys keep'em coming

Re: glue ups bowing

#8

Re: glue ups bowing

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>you should also alternate clamps from one side to the other to equalize that tendency to distort the board.

Re: glue ups bowing

#9

Re: glue ups bowing

Fred Davis

>Bruces response about uneven clamping pressure from one side to the other is easily the biggest cause of bowing in the panel.

If your jointer is not set at 90 degrees , then you set up a condition that will bow just two boards.

Check you setting and if is slightly off and your in a hurry , joint two boards at time ,holding then face to face or back to back .

Of course you will still need to remember the sequence when you clamp them..

A Plano glue press eliminates a lot of the problems associated with bar or pipe clamps.

FredD

Re: glue ups bowing

#10

this advice is contrary to manufacturer recommenda

Bill Tindall

>Franklin, the Titebond company, recommends 100 to 300 psi and Borden, the Elmers company, recommends 150 psi pressure for edge gluing. If you watch panels being assembled at a factory they snug the clamps with air wrenches. The clamps are stiff I-beam type so they don't flex.

If the panel is bowing in the clamps the problem is not too much pressure, rather it is a problem of clamping technique. If the clamps are too limber to apply adequate clamp pressure, then alternate them top and bottom to even the forces, or apply cauls(something I never need to do on 3/4" lumber using stiff clamps.

Re: glue ups bowing

#11

a comment on you comments

Bill Tindall

>I use the jointer technique you describe and agree it works well. Even if the jointer is set up perfectly to begin with knife wear will eventually change the jointed angle slightly. This technique perfectly compensates for the fence not being exactly 90 degrees to the knives.

One need not fear using wide boards for panels if the panel looks better with the wide board. The best rule for gluing panels is to assemble them in the most attractive way because all the other "rules" are of no significant benefit.

As an example, we were in the hardwood lumber business for many years and over that time set aside some exceptional wide lumber to use for "special occasions". It seemed a waste to sell it to someone that was going to reduce it to strips. These boards have set for many years and remained flat. What is going to make them suddenly decide to not be flat if the are made into a top or door panel? The answer is nothing that wouldn't affect a panel assembled from narrow pieces.

I have all sorts of furniture assembled from lumber up to 18" wide. My favorite example is the storage cabinet at Pleasant Hill, KY shaker town. Its side is a 20+" wide piece of walnut and it is doing fine. One of the ways to tell authentic period furniture is to examine the width of the lumber used. Only the recent stuff will be made from narrow boards.

Panel bowing is typically a result of differential moisture gain or loss between the two panel sides and this effect will affect panels assembled in any way. The solution is to assemble panels from properly dried lumber, acclimated to the shop environment. After the panel is assembled do not expose one side to conditions different from the other side.

Re: glue ups bowing

#12

Laying flat on workbench

Dustmaker Mike

>I always clamp up a panel then stand it on end to allow airflow around it. I have had panels bow because I left them flat on my bench just raised the height of the clamp.

Re: glue ups bowing

#13

Another thought.....

Barry Irby

>Examine what you have Carefully. Put a straight edge across the panel and see how the panel bowed. You may also need a shorter straight edge. With the short straight edge you should be able to tell if the boards themselves cupped or if it is the joints that are at an angle.

If it is the boards themselves, you need to think about whether the lumber was properly dried or if you did not dress it equally on both sides. If it is the joints, you may have a setup problem on your jointer as mentioned by others. Two 89 degree angles add up to a 178 degree panel. If you have a number of these the panel would look slightly coopered.

Thinking this through might give you a better place to start.

Re: glue ups bowing

#14

Re: glue ups bowing

Howard Acheson

>>>> the blank was layed flat on my workbench, in the garage which is heated,

I don't know if someone as mentioned this already, but the above is the reason your panel warped. Laying it on another surface that prevented the air from freely circulating to both sides equally created an uneven moisture content between the surfaces. Never lay a panel on another surface unless you put stickers underneath. Store it on edge being sure air can get to both sides.

The good news is that if you now sticker the panel it should flatten out.

Re: glue ups bowing

#15

Re: this advice is contrary to manufacturer recomm

Barry Turner

>Well, I don't know if it's contrary to manufacturer's advice or not, since I don't have any accurate way of measuring my clamp pressure. I won't question Franklin's or Titebond's recommendations. They undoubtedly know a lot more about glues and gluing than I do.

That said, I do know that it is possible to use too much clamp pressure. When I was in college in Industrial Arts, we had some guys in class have joint failures, due to "dry joints". They had used so much clamp pressure, they squeezed all of the glue out of the joint. I also know that I'm not having any bowing when I do glue-ups, nor do I have joint failures. If you have to use cauls and extra clamps to keep glue-ups from bowing, something is wrong. Edges may not be jointed squarely. Or, clamp pressure may be too high.

Re: glue ups bowing

#16

Re: a comment on you comments

Dick Coers

>I agree in principle with your comments about wide boards. I've used plenty myself. The exception though, would be if the wide stock is taken from too close to the pith. I've never seen stock stay really flat (unless it was walnut) when the growth rings get tight. A good sawyer would not cut that way, but I was just trying to add some thoughts for consideration. Thanks for helping me clarify the use of wide stock.