Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Porter-Cable Belt Sander

Posts

Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#1

Porter-Cable Belt Sander

Barry Turner

>I just purchased a new 352VS Porter-Cable 3" X 21" belt sander. I also considered the DeWalt 3" X 21" belt sander. Both machines have received favorable reviews on Amazon.

Because of past experience, I went with the Porter-Cable. This sander replaces an ancient Porter-Cable 503, which is a great sander, but is rough on aging backs because it is so heavy.

My new PC is still in the box, any opinions? Did I choose wisely or am I going to be disappointed?

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#2

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>is what you're doing with the 503.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#3

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

Barry Turner

>For right now, I'm hanging onto it........just in case I find the replacement to be way too lightweight.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#4

experience with the 503....and others

Bill Tindall

>Back before I adapted air driven ROS sanding I used a belt sander for initial surface preparation. I went through several sanders rejecting them for a flaw they all had. I never figured out why, but these "lesser" sanders were prone to leaving a divot when the sander was pulled back at the end of a forward sanding stroke. This divot would be about an inch by inch and a half. It wouldn't be too apparent until I went to finer grit and then it would show up as scratches that would not be removed by the finer grit.

The venerable 503 didn't cause this problem, for what ever reason. I always suspected the weight of the 503 kept it better balanced on the wood, but this is just a guess. Let us know how the replacement works out.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#5

Belt-sanding Necessity

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I approached the use of this tool with the following definition in mind:

BELT SANDER: Cuts grooves and other free-form concave shapes into otherwise flat wood surfaces. Especially useful for giving wood doors and floors that antique �lived in� look, as well as establishing just how thin and cheap the veneer is on IKEA furniture.



Then I discovered the "sanding frame" that fits under and around the machine to control both the balance and the contact patch, plus it will index the platen to the wood surface. In short, this tames the savage beastie into a controlled and precision tool. Unfortunately, not all tool companies make a frame for their belters. PC, Bosch, and Ryobi are the Good Guys, but even they don't make frames to match all models. I've had an in-line Ryobi 321EVS for about 15 years, and it's rare that the frame comes off if it. Correctly dialed in, I can just about take only the finish off a table top and leave the wood intact and dead flat with no bumps or digs.

If they make one to fit your sander, BUY IT!!

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#6

Re: experience with the 503....and others

Barry Turner

>I bought my 503 about 20+ years ago from a friend who built custom furniture for a living. I walked into his shop one morning as he was finishing sanding the top of a cherry drop-leaf table. Against the light, you could see this barely perceptible "trail" of the sander's path across the table top. He asked me if I wanted to buy a good sander for $45.00? Knowing that 503's sold for over $400, I bought it on the spot.

Once I got home with my prize, I set about troubleshooting the problem. It seems there was a bad bearing and seal on the rear rubber drum. This caused oil to collect on the surface of the drum. This caused a ridge of sanding dust to build up. This ridge on the drum telegraphed through the sanding belt and was visible on the sanded surface.

The fix was to have the bearings and seals replaced. No more problem. As for your experience with the 503, I suspect you didn't have a problem with it because it is better balanced than the other sanders you tried. The 503 is a great sander, it's just a little heavy for my aging back.

Over the years, my 503 has served me well, in spite of being rebuilt a few times. I'll let you know how it goes with the 352VS. I suspect it will not be quite the sander as the 503, but I think my back will be all the happier because of the reduced weight.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#7

Re: experience with the 503....and others

del schisler

>I don't know what my number's are on mine one is a 3x21 and is noisey but work's good and the 2nd one is a 4x24 whisper which is heavey and quite sand's well These are work horses and probly won't dye I use them most every day or so Retired so work when i wan't to If you are buying I guess you bought one already I don't belive you will be disapointed Just get good belt's Blow the dust out all the time That is what i do They are like new each time i use them

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#8

Another cause for that symptom,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

>is a small chip of wood, or sawdust, getting behind the platen or pad under the platen, will force a small bump under it, thus sanding harder in one spot than the rest of the platen.

One of the trade-offs of going to smaller lighter sanders than the 503 is that the belt speed may be slower, which means taking longer, and the lighter weight might call for more downward pressure while sanding. This might make more work than lifting the heavier sander which only needs to be guided around.

A couple of other things about the 503. Since it is worm drive, the motor starting torque makes it want to tilt over at start-up, so I always hold it above the work, start, then contact the work on the move. Also, since it cuts so fast, and the grips are higher above than most sanders, if there is any side-tilting pressure by the operator, the edge of the belt will cut faster on one side than the other, if you move the sander straight up and down the board in the ling of travel.

Rather than changing the sanding pattern diagonally across the grain, I like to keep the belt travel along the grain of the wood, but use a diagonal path across the face of the wood, with a slight lift at each end of motion change.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#9

In defense of punctuation

Bill Tindall

>Punctuation was invented to make reading text easier and with more precise understanding.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#10

Re: In defense

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Del's been posting here for a long time. All you usually need do is read the Caps.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#11

Re: Belt-sanding Necessity

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>I agree. I bought the Ryobi sanding frame for my rebadged Craftsman 3x21 sander. I leave it off when I'm using the sander for shaping applications, but it's always on for anything that needs precision, and has saved me a lot of aggravation.

Re: Porter-Cable Belt Sander

#12

SWMBO  Story

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>We were attempting to recycle some cabinets I made out of birch ply about 30 years ago. They had been finished with Minwax stain topped with oil poly. "She" asked if there was anything she could do to help, so I motioned to one piece that needed to have the finish taken off the top. "No chemicals for me," she cautioned. So I put a fresh 180 grit belt in the sander, adjusted the frame, and said "go to it." She did.

Took the poly and just about all the stain off but didn't have a single burn-through on the veneer. She then wise-cracked that "this wood stuff isn't as hard to do as I thought." I then offered her the ROS to do some ash, but she wisely declined.