Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

white oak

Posts

white oak

#1

white oak

Danny P

>To start with, I purchase my wood rough sawn and recently finished making the Arts and Craft bed that was featured in Wood Magazine. Turned out quit nice and am now starting on the night stands. Went and purchased another 100 ft or so of lumber and started milling it down. I've started noticing that some of the grain has cracks in it or should I say that it is separating, and was wondering what kind of filler is recommended for this that won't alter the end result with the stain. From what I understand from talking to other woodworkers is that this is fairly common with white oak. I might also add that this oak is not quartersawn.

Thanks for any suggestions or recommendations.

Danny P

Re: white oak

#2

Re: white oak

Barry Turner

>I have just finished a small project with Red Oak. It too had extensive cracking along the grain, especially near the ends of the boards. I consider these cracks to be defects and cut them away. Although you certainly can fill these cracks in your White Oak, fillers will do little to restore structural strength if the cracks are deep.

Re: white oak

#3

Re: white oak

Danny P

>I guess I should have said that the grain is opening up instead of the board actually cracking. Hopefully that makes a little more sense of what I was trying to convey.

Re: white oak

#4

Re: white oak

John K Jordan

>Are you referring to "honeycombing", internal checking that does not necessarily start at the end of the boards and does not necessarily extend to the surface of a face? I've seen pictures of severe honeycombing which looked like lens-shaped interior voids on a transverse section. You can search the sawing and drying or knowledgebase on Woodweb.com for more information. Honeycombing is evidently a common degrade in oak and caused by improper kiln drying. I've never seen it (I don't have a kiln so I air dry what I cut on my own sawmill) but I understand honeycomb is a cause to reject the lumber.

Does the separation follow the rings? Severe ring shake is probably worse than other defects since it can cause the entire board to fall apart. I have mostly seen ring shake in walnut.

JKJ

Re: white oak

#5

Re: white oak

Fred Davis

>Hard to say without actually seeing it , but sounds like the cells have collapsed which is caused by to rapid drying and not adjusting for it by steaming in the Kiln.

I have seen a entire 33,000 board feet load on a railcar in JC Higgins Steam kiln , in Union City ,Ca. which was run by a good friend of mind who had many years experience running that Kiln , ruined by the most rapid and severe cell collapse, that plant had ever seen.

The operator had his Kiln log gone over by the head office and they couldn't determine why that particular load decided to go south.

FredD

Re: white oak

#6

Re: white oak

Danny P

>John, I understand what you're talking about with the honeycomb. There is a piece or two that has some of that. The opening of the grain is random and doesn't go all the way thru the board.

Re: white oak

#7

lumber is defective, return it

Bill Tindall

>As some of you know we sold hardwood lumber for many years and we never sold any white oak with the grain separating. I will not go into details of the many ways this problem can occur but the bottom line is that it is a defect and should not be there in top grade lumber. If you didn't buy the top grade of lumber then the grade you bought may allow some fraction of this defect.

There is no way to fix this problem. If you finish over these cracks they will reappear as the lumber naturally expands and contracts with age.