What I do
Bill Tindall
>
something strange happened when I browsed the PIC file; not sure what is going to become of the attached PIC
I think you will find that when the sun light works on the oak that it will all become very similar. However, I always stain oak. I like a yellowish brown tint. I use anybody's oil wiping stain, for example Minwax. Any store worth buying from will let you dab samples on an oak board to see what it looks like.
We had a raging discussion of staining on the hand tool board a while back and I think my recommendations became accepted by those that tried them.
Step 1. Meticulously sand the piece spending most of your time with 100 grit, then follow with 120, and finally 180. I start with an air driven ROS sander and then hand sand the 120 and 180. If I was successful in using some other machine to sand with I would, but I haven't. They all, in my hands , leave scratches of one sort or another that show up when I stain.
Lack of satisfaction staining generally is a result of poor sanding. You are done with the 100 grit when all the planer marks are gone and there are no dull places indicating torn grain and not apparent scratches or swirls. Places are dull because they are catching saw dust. If they catch saw dust they will catch stain and become dark resulting in the dreaded "Blotchy Look". A card scraper is a good means of removing torn grain; much faster than sand paper or even a belt sander.
Step 2. Make a "rubber" or "tampon" like is used for shellac application. It will be a golf ball sized wad of cotton, cotton cloth, or sheep wool and then wrap a cover of cotton or linen over the ball and secure with a "twistie" or string or just twist and hold it. It will look like a badminton bird. Dab the bird in the stain picking up a bit and rub it on the wood. Dab and rub building the color until you like it. If you want the pores dark, as most do, then you will need to get the bird fairly wet and squeeze the stain into the pores.
You can do this step with a brush, slathering on stain and wiping it off but this approach is most wasteful of stain and the color depth will be what will be, without the ability to control it.
Step 3 Clean up with a clean cloth and let dry before top coating.