I for one.
davhamm
>I maybe in the minority, But I don't like the look of the new site. Can't put my finger on exactly why. Its just not visually apealing.
I know part of it is all the darn lines but it seems to be more than that also.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
I for one.
davhamm
>I maybe in the minority, But I don't like the look of the new site. Can't put my finger on exactly why. Its just not visually apealing.
I know part of it is all the darn lines but it seems to be more than that also.
Re: I for one.
Dale Stansbery
>I find the lines annoying also. A single blank line would be adequate. Also, the text size opens 1 size larger than it used too on my computer, and downsizing it to a comfortable size each visit is an annoyance. Other than that, It seems to work fine, though I haven't tried any new features.
I Haven't had it open in all red text yet since the switch, so hopefully Foxfire likes it a little better as well.
Re: I for one.
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla
>I am not happy with it either. I hate change when I am comfortable with something. But then I am not wild about babies, puppy dogs, and pollywogs either. By the time I get comfortable with this it will change again. I guess change is good-Hope so.
Re: I for one.
del schisler
>I don't find any thing wrong Font size is good for those that ware glass It just took some time in going to differnt places and finding out where it is All the same but in a different spot Oh well can't please every body You would have to change it every day Just to keep up on changes for everbody ?? Nice site i am on it 3 or 5 time's a day I Like the OT post's You never know what you may run into for a topic thanks for the site
Re: I for one.
Howard Norman
>I don't think that the horizontal lines add anything but I certainly would not spend any time to remove them if it was my decision. As I have said before I like the larger font size since it makes it easier for me to read.
Re: I for one.
Richard McComas
>Silly me, I like the lines.
Organization
David Yoho
>When we were testing the new look before it went live, one of the changes I noticed immediately were the lines. Personally, I like them because they help organize or separate the posts and makes it easier to distinguish one group from another.
David
I like the lines
JKJ in East TN
>The lines are in two places - between threads in the index and between individual messages when the user preference is set to Guestbook for viewing all the messages in a thread.
The lines between threads in the index are great and make browsing the index easier. I like the lines between the individual messages too - they don't do much for simple messages (like this one) that consist primarily of one or two paragraphs, but the separator lines sure help visually with a thread containing several more complex messages that have a number of paragraphs, individual lines, tables, photos, etc. I think the lines reduce visual clutter and stress and make following a thread easier. The do take up a bit more space and require more scrolling, as does the larger font, but scrolling is quick.
JKJ
Re: I for one.
Joseph Mulherin, Sr.
>The lines were put in to separate the various messages into blocks so we could read the problems and the associated answers from the members without having to search for them. Ellis has done a very good workmanlikeship in doing so....
get used to it. Every time someone makes a change from the "old" way to a "new" way someone makes waves about it....
Re: I for one.
davhamm
>Well, wasn't really making wave's just posting my opinion. I assumed feedback was desired.
As for Old way to New way... I hang out on probably 10 forums never seen this line format, and after seeing it I think I know why.
Change is not always for the better. Personally I love change and experimentation. But I also except comments and criticism, and change to something else when the feedback isn't positive.
Visual Clutter . . .
steve mackay
>Gotta say, the lines help me with my Brain Clutter. Used to scroll down just keying on the threads that changed to green (I had already read). A lot of times (on my machine) they hadn't turned color. Now I can scan the whole page in "chuncks" and recognize threads I'm keeping track of a lot easier.
Re: I for one hadn't noticed the lines
Stuart Johnson
>I didn't even notice the lines prior to this thread so I must be okay with them. I like the new font size but it won't bother me if it reverts to one size smaller. How long does it take to hit ctrl - or + to adjust it to whatever size you want?
Font size
davhamm
>Well, since you all mentioned it I did play around and ya the font size is another issue. The Ctrl trick doesn't work cause it changes all sizes and the side menu bar is already smaller, using Ctrl - makes that to small.
Oh well. I just recently returned to this site, and will probably vote with my feet.
Re: Font size
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>Give it some time!
Ellis just installed the new software a few days ago, and is still working on a bunch of the bugs and tweaks which always accompany a new software install. There are definitely some new and welcome features, and I believe he said there are more to come.
He's not a big corporation with a staff of highly-paid, full-time computer jockeys. That makes big transitions like this more difficult, but I think makes for a better site in the day-to-day management, as he's more personable in his dealings with the members.
Jason
Give it time for Profiles to go up
Barb Siddiqui
>as people figure out how to return to the forums. I'd think you'd be fair enough to 'vote with your feet' due to content rather than new peculiarities you find irksome. It just takes getting used to, and problems will be ironed out as things move along. The wealth of knowledge and generosity on this site makes it worth the effort.
Some thoughts on this, and a test for you
Ellis Walentine
>First, let me say that I understand that change is intrinsically upsetting to people. I found it as a manager in various organizations and I find it here every day. In the case of the relatively minor changes we've made in appearances (verdana type vs. generic sans-serif, dividing lines visually separating threads and messages, fixed viewport as opposed to full-width screens), there were good reasons for all those changes, all having to do with readability. They weren't decisions taken lightly. If something seems wrong, consider that it may be only different, and your conditioned view might take a little while to adapt. I took great pains to keep most of the messageboard appearance the same -- background, navigation, ad placement -- even the threaded message options and font colors -- because I knew for certain that some people were going to complain, and I really wanted to minimize the cause for complaint.
Tobe honest, our real objective here was to add user-friendly features, cure buggy behavior on certain platforms and browsers, set up better spam defenses, and allow for certain user amenities that I thought you'd like -- text formatting, multiple picture and file uploads, smilies, etc. It would be easy for me to be pretty depressed if you find minor appearance issues to outweigh all the gains we've made with then new format. But, I think we've done pretty well overall -- pending some performance improvements pending -- and I would invite you to *not* vote with your feet, and not encourage anyone else to either. Feedback is fine and much appreciated. Let's keep it constructive though.
Thanks,
Ellis
PS Here's a direct comparison of type faces and sizes for you:
1. This is our new type face on the new boards.
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their party.
1b. Here's the same font at 90%.
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their party.
2. This is our old type face from the previous messageboards.
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their party.
2b. This is our old type face about 15% larger.
Now is the time for all good men to come to the aid of their party.
What do you think? Is one better? Do you have any other suggestions?
Re: Some thoughts on this, and a test for you
Ace Karner
>It's been a couple days now but the new format has really sunk in and I like it. My biggest problem was figuring out how to find where firefox keeps my cookies so I could get re-registered. 
Great Job Ellis, keep up the good work.
**delete Firefox cookies**
John K Jordan
>To delete the WC cookie in Firefox,
- close down any Woodcentral tabs and windows
(Better yet, exit Firefox and restart with Google or something)
- click on the menu item Tools, Options
- choose the Privacy option
- click "remove individual cookies"
- highlight the Woodcentral entry
- click "remove cookies"
JKJ
1b, and...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>I would love it if the page width adapted to the size of my browser window.
As it is now, I'm working on a 17" widescreen laptop, with a Google widget bar taking up about 1.25" on the right. My browser window takes up the rest, but WC has additional margins of about 1.5" on each side of the menus and messages. Using Ctrl+ will cause WC in the window to be fully justified, but along with that comes two notches up in a text size that is already (IMHO) too large.
Jason, dispassionately (and hopefully, constructively) criticizing
Re: 1b, and...
John K Jordan
>"....with a Google widget bar taking up about 1.25" on the right"
Yikes, no offense but that sounds insane to me! Seems like a horrible waste of screen space. Why not put the gadgets on a custom Google page and keep that fullscreen on a tab? Or it's only a click away if you put it in a bookmarks toolbar or link list.
JKJ
Widgets
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>They're desktop widgets in Win7. I keep time and temp there and keep my taskbar (or whatever it's called in Win7) pretty small at the bottom. My laptop also has a keypad to the right side, so as I sit here, my center of focus is offset to the left anyway.
Jason
Either 2 or 2b, depending on your vision
wilbur
Yabut....
Ellis Walentine
>...we need to hear from the people who don't like the new type size. Here's the chance to let your voice be heard.
Ellis
Re: Either 2 or 2b, depending on your vision
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
>2B or not 2B. That is the question. 
Re: Yabut....
Stephen Kirk
>Larger is better for me.