Spalted piece in question
JL
>
I was asking earlier about preserving the coloration of the spalting. (Thanks for the reply, Mark.) This is the piece in "question".
It is also a test of the new board from my perspective.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Spalted piece in question
JL
>
I was asking earlier about preserving the coloration of the spalting. (Thanks for the reply, Mark.) This is the piece in "question".
It is also a test of the new board from my perspective.
Re: Spalted piece in question
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Morning JL,
Now seeing the piece, since most of the surface exhibits spalting in one stage or another, I would concentrate on preservation of the natural color rather than trying to "blend" areas with a toner.
Keep in mind that strong UV light will always be this wood's enemy, so regardless of finish, I'd plan to keep it out of the sun. Even so, your red flecks will be the first to go. I've had some box elder pieces loose their red in a matter of several months.
The blues will be more durable, but they too will fade. The spalt lines will be there forever.
You'll get a large "pop" out of the SealCoat on this piece, and the maple will be quite striking in its color. I do wonder, however, if you're going to have some trouble blending white oak with it. You might find yourself in the position of having to bleach out the warm oak to fit with the cool blues and pale tans in the maple.
In any event, I'd surly go with a water-clear finish like Target's stuff or General's HP poly or Enduro lines. The other benefit of the shellac sealer is that it will prevent the waterborne finishes from raising the grain. You might also do well to repost your question on Jeff Jewitt's finishing forum or ask Jeff directly.
Please post a pic when you're done!
[No, I didn't call you Shirley
]
Re: Spalted piece in question
Clint Searl
>Here's an example of spalted maple and spalted beech under NC lacquer with no other treatment.
Clint

For Comparison
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Lovely piece, Clint.
Attached is a Box Elder turning [about 12"] finished with Ultra Pale shellac sealer topped with General Finish's Enduro Super Clear Poly.

And....
Clint Searl
>Box elder under alkyd lacquer.
Clint 
clint Nice buck eye piece
del schisler
>I like the california buck eye piece on the left I have lot's of it Nice wood to work with
Re: Spalted piece in question
JL
>I may just end up painting the white oak and hard maple black - and leaving the spalted soft maple clear and finish it in the manner in which you described.
Second Suggstion - For Black
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>That's doable and can work out very well, but instead of paint for the black, I'd suggest you "ebonize" the oak with black dye and finish with the waterborne tinted with the same dye. The black finish will have some visual depth and richness that way. Try it in some scrap to compare the effect. I'd make samples with both open and filled pores to see. Filling the open pores is pretty easy to do with a little Crystal-Lac filler that will be available from were you buy the dye and finish from (not Home Depot however).
I was going to use milk paint.
JL
>And quite a few coats of finish.