Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

Posts

Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

#1

Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

Pete in Holland, MI

>Getting ready to glue up some table tops of red quarter-sawn oak. Seems I remember someone stating the panels will look better if the "tree top ends" all face the same direction, so the light effects on the rays are all the same.

Anyone agree with this statement ? Or is it better to alternate them? What's your experience here ?

Thanx !

Pete

Re: Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

#2

heartwood to heartwood, sapwood to sapwood

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Paul

Glue the heartwood to the heartwood and sapwood to the sapwood.

Differential expansion between heartwood and sapwood will cause a step in the tabletop that can be easily avoided by matching the rates of shrinkage of both boards.

Another point of view.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

#3

Oops! ... sorry, wrong name Pete

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

#4

tree top ends?

Bill Tindall

>That is a term I never heard of and I don't know what it means. It strikes me as yet another "rule" for assembling panels that has no practical basis, like alternating grain and the like.

Rather than obeying some rule of thumb, instead lay out the wood for best appearance which should be easily done empirically on some saw horses or the bench. I have never seen a problem from assembling panels according to best appearance. If you are unsure of what looks best consult some handy critics.

Re: Quarter sawn oak glue-ups - - - grain question

#5

First, I would ask how you know which is up

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>or down? If it is just a matter of flair at one end, then yes you might get a more balanced look.

Otherwise, I think I would be really challenged to tell the difference. I think the slight shade that someone might assume is from up / down, probably is from a slight difference between the angle of medullar rays being compounded, since most QS doesn't actually radiate perfectly from the heart, but is slightly RIft.

There may be exceptions however, I don't think R Oak is one of them. A couple of years ago, I was laying up some really tight fiddle-back Sapelle, for a 10' vanity which was all horizontal grain. On my workbench top with florescent light overhead, I thought I had a perfect match. Then when I installed, and turned on the recessed light, which were positioned to maximize the chatoyancy, a couple of them were dull and had to be flipped.

This is of course due to the fact that even though the pattern looks like it is an up and down wave relative to the face, it is actually closer to a side to side wave of the grain when the tree was growing.