First, I would ask how you know which is up
Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6
>or down? If it is just a matter of flair at one end, then yes you might get a more balanced look.
Otherwise, I think I would be really challenged to tell the difference. I think the slight shade that someone might assume is from up / down, probably is from a slight difference between the angle of medullar rays being compounded, since most QS doesn't actually radiate perfectly from the heart, but is slightly RIft.
There may be exceptions however, I don't think R Oak is one of them. A couple of years ago, I was laying up some really tight fiddle-back Sapelle, for a 10' vanity which was all horizontal grain. On my workbench top with florescent light overhead, I thought I had a perfect match. Then when I installed, and turned on the recessed light, which were positioned to maximize the chatoyancy, a couple of them were dull and had to be flipped.
This is of course due to the fact that even though the pattern looks like it is an up and down wave relative to the face, it is actually closer to a side to side wave of the grain when the tree was growing.