Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Leigh FMT Question

Posts

Leigh FMT Question

#1

Leigh FMT Question

Pete

>I need (want) a Leigh FMT. I've been looking all around the net and my local stores for a break on the "usual" MSRP and nobody is budging! Does anyone have any experience at hunting for one, and should I go ahead and jump, or could patience pay off? I thank you, and my wife (who is waiting for me to make 96 M&Ts on 4 new dining chairs) thanks you,

Pete

PS - Someone out there want to sell me theirs?

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#2

Re: Leigh FMT Question

Rickey LoDico

>I've only seen it come down in price on one occasion at Lee Valley a few years ago. I jumped on it then for 100.00 less than any other place.

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#3

Re: Leigh FMT Question

Pete

>Thanks. I found on a blog elsewhere that the Wood Whisperer Blog was giving one away in January. I went over there to check that out. Bottom line is I think I'm going to go ahead and buy one. I've got chairs to make, and I'm pretty sure I'll be making them all year if I can successfully pull of this first order from my wife

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#4

Re: Leigh FMT Question

mike from American Sycamore

>you will not regret this purchase...unit works great and Leigh is a great company and provides excellant customer service. I do mind paying top $ for such great quality and service.

Mike

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#5

Re: Leigh FMT Question

mdclor

>It will be way cheaper to buy the FMT and build the chairs than to purchase chairs comparable to the quality you will build. At least that is the logic I always use. :)

HTH,

Merle

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#6

Re: Leigh FMT Question

Pete

>Thanks. I'm anxious to get it... Now I just have to figure out which vendor gets my business...

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#7

Re: Leigh FMT Question *LINK*

charlie belden

>Save yourself some grief - and go with Loose Tenon joinery. Parts visible dimensions rather than parts' visible dimensions PLUS tenon lenght(s) make life simpler. And with angled tenons - often required when doing chairs - a loose tenon will be stronger.

When you add up the cost of the basic jig and bits and guides "accessories" - you're pushin' a grand - which is what the Festool DOMINO goes for - loaded and with an assortment of "domino" sizes - in quantity. Unlike the FMT, which requires laying out AT LEAST the centerline/centerline of each of the types of mortises you will be making, and you've got a clamping and unclamping and aligning stuff to do - along with keeping track of parts orientation - so you don't end up with TWO "lefts" and no "right" - or an offset tenon or mortise - offset in the wrong direction . . .

Seriously have a look at the DOMINO before making your purchasing decision.

I own and use a DOMINO, but have no connection with Festool or any of their dealers/distributors.


User view of Festool's DOMINO

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#8

Re: Leigh FMT Question

Pete

>Hadn't even considered a Domino... I'll hold off until I research them a bit more. Any other opinions on FMT vice the Domino?

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#9

Opinions - FMT vs DOMINO *LINK*

charlie belden

>First off - given the option - I see loose tenon M&T joinery preferable to "true" M&T joinery. Since the option to cut mortises in end grain is available thanks to jigs and routers - or more recently - the DOMINO - why mess with cutting tenons - by any means? Tenons complicate things unnecessarily. Blow one - and most of the time there's another on "the other end" - and you either need to make this part - and its matching part - if you've got a front apron, you probably have a back apron that's a mirror image of the front apron - then you've got a problem. You can cut off the blown tenon and cut a good one - and do the same for the "matching" part - or you can make a whole new part. Either way it's a hassle.

With loose tenon joinery the parts are ALL their visible lengths - no adding for the TWO tenons. And if you cut a mortise in the wrong place - plug it - and try again - in 30 minutes to an hour (glue set time).

Now to the FMT.

I HAD the TREND M&T JIG which works much like the FMT - though the set up and clamping is easier with the FMT. What became very apparent from my experience with the TREND, and by studying the FMT - is that unless your mortises are perfectly symetric - ie centered on at least one axis of the mortise - you can easily cut a bunch of nice crisp clean mortises - in the wrong place - and not realize there's a problem til dry fit time. Describing why this is a big issue is difficult with just words- and I've been trying for a while now to illustrate what can go wrong - and how easy it is to make a mistake. Have a look at the attached illustration of four possible outcomes - with "A" being what you want.

The other "challenge" with the TREND and the FMT - is holding the part - and keeping it there. Imagine cutting a mortise in the side of something 3 or 4 feet long - with just the first 8 or 10" in the jig - the rest hanging out the end of the jig. Or imagine cutting a mortise or two - in the end of a part four or more feet long - or on the wide face of a 3/4" thick by 2" wide face frame component.

And then there's the These Parts Must Be Cut With The Part Horizontal - and These Parts Must Be Cut With The Part Vertical requirement of a FIXED Jig/Parts Must Move approach of the TREND and FMT. With the DOMINO the part can remain horizontal - on your bench top - and the hand held mortise cutting device changes orientation as required.

Then there's the set up requirements - from Reference End and Reference Face or Reference Edge (you need TWO of the three to locate the mortise in space). With the jigs, that means one set up for "Lefts" and another for "Rights" With the DOMINO, there are "reference pins" on either side of the centerline that will be cut - and "outrigger pins" if the distance to centerline is greater than 37 mm. Register the left or right "pin" against your reference end - and make the cut.

Look at the table with apron example on the attached link, study the illustrations and then think about how to cut these mortises on a TREND or FMT. Notice that the DOMINO mortises are ALL cut with the part laying flat on the bench - and be aware that NO clamping was required - at all.

Want something else to consider? OK - WHERE will you put the FMT - and all its accessories - when they aren't being used. Will YOU have to make something to coral the parts that don't stay on the jig? The DOMINO comes with a Systainer that holds it and its accessories - and another for the collection of dominos - and they stack - and lock together - and you can stand on them - if you want to.

The FMT - and even the MultiRouter - are Last Generation units - router and jig based M&T Jigs. The DOMINO is the NEXT Generation mortising method - hand held. For furniture scale loose tenon joinery - and even larger projects - IMHO - it replaces what's gone before. Now if you want to make doll house scale stuff - well there, the advantage goes to the FMT. The FMT is the best - of its generation. But the DOMINO is one of the new generation of woodworking tools - the Festool plunge circular saw and guide rail being another of the new generation.

Don't let the fact that the DOMINO looks like a biscuit cutter mislead you - it is definitely NOT a biscuit cutter.

If you have more questions about the DOMINO - feel free to ask away and I'll try and answer them.


img

Table Legs, Table Aprons Example

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#10

Re: Opinions - FMT vs DOMINO

Pete

>OK... so far I like what I see with the Domino. I'm building 4 dining chairs that resemble basic Stickley type. On the "undercarriage" of the chair is the stretchers, etc... They are 3/4 x 3/4. and on my originals, are joined using round tenons. They are also angled. With either the FMT or the Domino I'm not sure I could use them there...

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#11

Re: Opinions - FMT vs DOMINO

Jesse Cloud

>I've done similar things with both the fmt and the domino.

If your concern is the small dimension of the stretcher or the angle, both can do that in stride. Just clamp the workpiece into the fmt very carefully. With the Domino, you will need the optional trim stop accessory - it holds small pieces while the domino plunges. The Domino fence angles, so no problem. One of the main uses for the Domino is splicing small trim, not unlike your project.

If the intersection of the leg and the stretcher is curved, this will be a wrinkle for either tool. You will probably want to make some sort of hold-down/positioning jig for each workpiece.

Both are great tools. But when I bought my Domino, I sold the FMT and haven't missed it. With the new FMT the entry cost is lower, though.

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#12

Re: Opinions - FMT vs DOMINO

Pete

>I have decided to get the Domino set up. I pick it up tonight at Woodcraft. I was debating on getting it on-line, and in the end decided to support these local guys. They've been friendly over the years, and helpful, too. Thanks to everyone who offered up opinions and helpful comments along the way. I look forward to posting photos of the chairs (mainly because I'll be done then!) when I get them finished,

Pete

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#13

Ellis Walentine

Excellent explanation, Charlie

Ellis Walentine

Re: Leigh FMT Question

#14

Re: Opinions - FMT vs DOMINO

Jesse Cloud

>Hey Pete,

Congratulations! I think you will really like the Domino. The good news is that there is no risk. Festool offers a full refund no questions asked for the first 30 days. After that, Festool used tools hold their value incredibly well. Like in the old days of Toyota, you may be able to sell a used tool for more than you paid for it, given annual price increases.

The only advice I would give is not to get carried away with the speed aspect. I find myself so amazed by how fast the thing works that I keep going faster and faster until I booger something up. Like any tool, you have to mark the mortise location accurately and hold the tool firmly.

Enjoy!