Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

"Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

Posts

"Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#1

"Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

Ray - Middletown, IN

>This is new to me, not sure how long its been on the market. What are the collective thoughts.

Ray


Bio-Solv

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#2

JL

Re: "Green" solvent replacement

JL

>I don't know about collective thoughts, but I'll give you several as a chemist.

Looks to me like it is ethyl lactate - an ester of ethyl alcohol and lactic acid. You can get ethyl alcohol from a number of sources and lactic acid from a number of sources. I'm not sure what their proprietary co-solvents are - they don't list those.

Should it work? Definitely for cleaning and such. Does it work as well as mineral spirits, acetone, etc for thinning? Probably not - not quite the same chemistry. Would I try it? Sure - but I'm not going to pay much more for it.

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: What he said, plus.....

Jesper, Denmark

>Their description of the Ethyl lactate blend in the MSDS, it appears to me that this applies:

Ethyl lactate is also produced industrially from petrochemical stocks, and this ethyl lactate consists of the racemic mixture of levo and dextro forms. In some jurisdictions, the natural product is exempt from many restrictions placed upon use and disposal of solvents.

So the claims - as is usual for these wonder preparations - take a few liberties. Just like "waterbased" paints, which contain co-solvents to make the oil based resins mix with water. PGMEA is a typical one, which was the cause of birth defects in pregnant women working in the semiconductor industry.

Sometimes,the known hazards are easy to deal with, but unknown ones can be very bad for you.

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#4

Re: "Green" solvent replacement

Roy Anderson

>I agree with "JL". From a chemical engineer's point of view, ethyl lactate is probably a good cleaning solvent, but it will hydrolyze into lactic acid and ethanol in water. This is probably pretty harsh on your hands and the product information clearly spells out that it will eat up standard vinyl gloves. It is not compatible with PVC pipe, so be careful when you pore it down the sink. However, MEK and Toluene are probably not good for your PVC pipe, either.

They don't advertise it as a paint or lacquer thinner. Just a cleaner.

In the FAQ section of their web site they say it is primarily derived from corn, which is why they consider it green and carbon neutral. This is probably better than pumping oil, but keep in mind that it takes fertilizer produced from a chemical plant to grow the corn and gasoline and diesel to harvest the corn and energy to process the corn. It also increases the cost of corn used for food because of market demand. If you are a farmer, you will probably like this. So although it's greenness is probably better than importing crude oil from people who don't like us, it's not a panacea.

A coupla things I do like about it: it is not very flammable, unlike MEK, Acetone or Toluene and it is pretty harmless on exposure, other than being an irritant, unlike Toluene, which can have some negative health effects.

Note: there is an uncommon wealth of information on just about any chemical you can come across in Wikipedia.

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#5

The price I received in an ad was

Ray - Middletown, IN

>under $15 a quart, and under $50 a gallon. Way to expensive for me. Wish the MSDS would list a substance as septic system safe or not.

Ray

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#7

What "problem" do you hope to improve or solve

Bill Tindall

>The "evil" chemical companies provide this or that solvent for this or than task because over time these solvents have proven to be best for this or that task. If someone comes along and says "use this, for this or that task, because my stuff is "green" you can be sure you will be giving up something- price or performance likely- for this dubious benefit. So step one should be determining what problem am I trying to solve by changing the piddly amount of solvent I used in my woodworking operations. Keep in mind that the rest of the world evaporates millions of pounds of the typical solvents each year, so don't expect to have any measurable environmental impact. All the common solvents are safe to use in the quantities used in woodworking so long as flammability is considered, so one is not going to get any benefit from a switch on this account.

I would anticipate it will be a poor substitute for cleaning anything greasy. This stuff is a high boiling solvent, BP is 300 F. So it is not going to go away very quickly from the surface cleaned. Don't try using it as paint thinner or hell will freeze over (perhaps likely given recent weather pattern) before it finally evaporates. On the other hand its very high flash point could be beneficial in some cleaning situations, for example a confined space with ignition sources.

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#8

JL

It is "septic safe"..

JL

>The bacteria in a septic system would easily digest the ethyl lactate or the ethanol and lactic acid.

Re: "Green" solvent replacement *LINK*

#9

Re: What "problem" do you hope to improve or solve

Chuck Kettler

>I sure hope you are starting to thaw out Bill. Forty degrees feels pretty good today.